4 ms·
Even though I've been researching with interest, so far I haven't run across much in the American healthcare system that makes me question my decision (as an Am
by _delirium 14y ago
Even though I've been researching with interest, so far I haven't run across much in the American healthcare system that makes me question my decision (as an American) to move to Denmark. My taxes are higher, but my costs are very predictable, and by design cannot ever bankrupt me: I pay a flat 8% of my income to support the national healthcare system. I won't end up with a charge equal to 20% or 50% or 500% of my income in any circumstance, not even if I get cancer or find myself unemployed. So it's guaranteed that I will always be able to pay my healthcare costs without great hardship.
I do hope someday to move back to the USA (mix of language / "feels like home"), and am mildly hopeful that PPACA will make it feasible, by 2014, for an individual to buy private health insurance without worrying about preexisting conditions and rescissions and whatnot. But we'll see. For now, Danish is growing on me. :P
Incidentally, this kind of emergency care would be free even for a tourist in Denmark. Regular use of the national health system is only available to legal residents, but acute emergency care is considered a basic service not subject to billing, like police and fire response.
- vegardx 14y agoLife saving treatment is usually like this all over the world, and in Denmark they will give you a bill unless you're apart of EU, as you'd have the EU health insurance (EHIC), which is free. This card is also valid in countries in the Schengen Area, like Norway, Switzerland and Lichtenstein.
- _delirium 14y agoMany countries bill for emergency stays. US emergency rooms definitely send bills, even if it's acute live-saving treatment. Even Canada, which has national healthcare for residents, will bill nonresidents who visit an ER. If you're from another country, you may get away with just not paying one of those bills, because if it's life-saving care they have to provide it before verifying you can pay. But they'll still try to collect on it. That's one reason it's common for people to buy travel health insurance that covers emergency care. Afaik, Denmark doesn't require the EHIC for acute emergency care. Anyone is eligible for unbilled emergency care, with some exceptions to combat medical tourism (if you're found to have traveled to Denmark for the specific purpose of entering an ER to treat a health condition). The EHIC qualifies you for some additional care, e.g. childbirth. This is actually a big current sore point in Danish politics, because many other EU countries don't extend a reciprocal courtesy.
- waqf 14y ago> Even Canada, which has national healthcare for residents, will bill nonresidents who visit an ER. Even Canada? Canada by its location would be at acute risk for medical tourism from the US, if it didn't bill for ER treatment. That problem isn't as big for Europe, Australia, etc.
- _delirium 14y agoThat makes sense, I agree. The "even" was more given its reputation: most Europeans I know are not surprised that the US sends large bills for ER visits, but don't expect the same from Canada. I could almost imagine a financially manageable system where Canada gave free ER care to anyone except Americans, but that would produce obvious political problems.
- vegardx 14y agoYou're still stuck with a bill, if you're a foreigner. They will treat you, like they will in most of the world. But you're still stuck with a bill afterwards. Also, unless my memory is totally off, each country has to pay up for EHIC, depending on who used what, and visa versa. So the cost should be evened out. Edit, because I cannot reply to you later down: I think we have a different view on what emergency medical care is. In most of the world you will get fixed up so that you are no longer in life threatening condition, this is the case in USA, Denmark and Norway. But afterwards you will have to pay, even in Denmark, as long as you're not apart of EU and have the European Health Insurance Card or a citizen of any of the Nordic countries, which has a special agreement.
- _delirium 14y agoThat isn't the case; Denmark simply does not charge for acute emergency visits, and does not send a bill. In addition, they pay for their own residents who incur such bills within the EU on trips under 30 days [1], which is part of the controversy: a French person who ends up in a Danish ER is not billed, but a Danish person who ends up in a French ER is billed, with the bill paid by the Danish government. Most Danes would prefer that each country provide free emergency care to all, like they do with fire and police. [1] http://www.sos.dk/en/Corporate/OurNetwork/ForMedicalFacilities/TheDanishTravelHealthInsuranceScheme/ http://www.sos.dk/en/Corporate/OurNetwork/ForMedicalFaciliti...
- marquis 14y agoHaving experienced emergency care in both Denmark and the U.S., this is also the main reason I won't relocate to the U.S. until this is sorted out. I had what was thought to be a broken ankle in Denmark thanks to icy conditions and I was so well looked after, and charged nothing, I was awe inspired and wish there had been some way to pay it back. I sliced a finger in the U.S. and was made to feel like a statistic, with a $1000 bill. Thanks to inexpensive travel insurance that cost me just $100, but how I am supposed to feel when my travel insurance is less than quarter of the price that actual insurance would be if I lived there? (Edit from reading other comments: probably not charged in Denmark because of European health reciprocity, but they never verified this at the hospital).
- encoderer 14y agoIt's not fair, and not right, but it is a fact that for the most part, most of us here don't have to worry about that. If you're a software engineer or systems administrator or similar type of professional earning a fair living it's not at all uncommon to have completely free health insurance for yourself, and affordable options to cover your family. I haven't worked for a place with an individual premium in 5 years. Again, not saying the system isn't broken, but rather that there's a reason all Americans aren't vocally supporting the ACA and the president: this is mostly a lower-middle-class-and-below problem
- _delirium 14y agoI agree, and I feel it used to work even better in that respect, when educated Americans typically had lifetime employment. I would guess that's one reason the debate is growing louder lately. The West basically solved the healthcare problem via collective coverage, but in different ways: the European countries did it nationwide, but the US did it with employer group plans. That was almost equivalent, for people with good jobs, as long as people stayed in jobs for life: having the IBM group plan was about as good as having state health coverage, as long as the IBM job was more or less for life. It's more broken if you're middle-class-or-below (as you mention) or an entrepreneur who isn't either early-20s-and-healthy or raking in huge piles of cash. The part that seems most out of keeping with the American ethos is how anti-entrepreneur it is: you get good collectivized coverage if you work for IBM or Microsoft or Google (because it's socialized across their employee base), but if you start your own company or are trying to buy insurance for a 10-person company's employees, well then you're screwed.
- forrestthewoods 14y ago8% sounds great. US currently spends around 16% of GDP on health care every year. I think the majority of Americans would support a universal health care system that provides far more coverage at half the cost. Instead our total spend is expected to double by 2020. Source: http://money.cnn.com/2011/07/28/news/economy/healthcare_spending_forecast/index.htm http://money.cnn.com/2011/07/28/news/economy/healthcare_spen...
- vegardx 14y agoShould be noted that there is not a direct correlation between tax paid for health care and cost of health care. It's heavily subsidised by the government, from taxes taken elsewhere. In Norway it's like this: Senior citizen: 4,7% Employed: 7,8% Self-employed: 11% Last time I checked we spent around 9% of GDP on healthcare.
- anonymoushn 14y agoThe great thing is that this expense grows at a rate of 9%/year while the economy is stagnant. If GDP miraculously and immediately begins to grow at 5%/year, health care spending will completely eclipse it in 50 years. If it does not, health care spending will completely eclipse it in 28 years.
- lesterbuck 14y agoHerbert Stein's Law: "If something cannot go on forever, it will stop." The only question is how the rate of growth will slow/stop.
- tptacek 14y agoWorth noting that the US leads Europe in outcomes for serious illnesses (particularly cancer), and the US provides access to specialists in days where other countries often have multi-week or even multi-month delays.
- olefoo 14y agoYes, but, europeans generally see a healthcare provider more often and are more often diagnosed before they reach an acute stage. If you look at the graphs [1][2][3] that compare per capita expenditures per country with life expectancy per country. You'll see that they are generally getting equivalent or better outcomes at less than half the cost. And I can tell you that for my own part, even with health insurance, the deductible is so high that it might as well not exist as far as basic checkups and doctor visits go. 1 http://ucatlas.ucsc.edu/spend.php http://ucatlas.ucsc.edu/spend.php 2. http://blogs.ngm.com/blog_central/2009/12/the-cost-of-care.html http://blogs.ngm.com/blog_central/2009/12/the-cost-of-care.h... 3. http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2011/03/health_costs_and_life_expectancy http://www.economist.com/blogs/buttonwood/2011/03/health_cos...
- fernly 14y agoWhat is your legal status in Denmark, and how did you achieve it? Are you a "resident alien" or an immigrant or what? What restrictions/hoops did you have to jump to get permanent residence status? What did it cost?
- _delirium 14y agoUnfortunately it's not the most friendly country for immigration, partly as a result of the right-wing coalition that tightened rules over the past few years (Sweden is better, as far as the Scandinavian countries go). But there are some exceptions: it's easy for EU citizens (due to being in the EU), and it's easy if you have a professional-level job offer (no US-style H1B quotas). I'm a researcher hired by a Danish university, which made for a fairly easy fast-track visa under the "researchers scheme" [1]. In fact the entire process was by mail and took one round-trip: I mailed my passport, offer letter, photos, and application to the NYC consultate, and they mailed back my passport with a visa pasted into it. Most professionals with an offer will also be able to get a visa; it's not nearly as restricted as getting U.S. visas is. If you have an offer that pays more than 375,000 DKK ($63,500), you qualify under the "pay limit scheme" for similarly preferential treatment [2]. Getting permanent residency depends on if you're an EU citizen. If yes, it's just a matter of remaining in the country as a legal resident for at least 5 uninterrupted years. If you're from outside the EU, there are more requirements [3], including that you must be employed for 3 of the 5, and must pass a language exam establishing basic competence in the language (which is unfortunately quite difficult to speak, though the grammar and vocabulary are not particularly difficult). I must also give them kudos for giving all of this information in not only English, but straightforward, non-legalese English. Dealing with the Danish state is generally not a horrible experience so far, even for someone who speaks no Danish. [1] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/researchers.htm http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/researchers... [2] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/pay-limit-scheme.htm http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/work/pay-limit-s... [3] http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/permanent-residence-permit/ http://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/permanent-reside...
- fernly 14y ago