2 ms·
I don't think it's so much racism per se as a militant nationalism and national-exceptionalist view, as the key defining feature (we are the best nation and wil
by _delirium 14y ago
I don't think it's so much racism per se as a militant nationalism and national-exceptionalist view, as the key defining feature (we are the best nation and will build a glory that will shine for the ages).
Before Hitler forced him to pass anti-Jewish laws, Mussolini wasn't particularly racist, just nationalist. His thing was the eternal greatness of Italy, the connection to ancient Roman glory, the new legions of Italy rebuilding the Roman empire, reorienting society on martial and patriotic lines, etc., etc. The collectivism basically stems from that: the Nation above all. To me, that's a very right-wing sort of collectivism, whereas both the left and liberals have more of an internationalist and multicultural orientation.
It's true that it's not libertarian (either right-libertarian or left-libertarian). But I don't think it's too alien from cultural conservatism and "national greatness conservatism", which also places a high emphasis on patriotism and the nation, and is highly critical of individuals who deviate from what they see as the good of the community (hence the traditional conservative support for censorship of blasphemous, prurient, and seditious literature, as they believe it's the government's job to prevent this kind of deviance). As one litmus test, we might look at which parts of the political spectrum support mandatory Pledge of Allegiance recitation, in order to train the youth to put their Nation first.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI also don't think it's too alien from modern American liberalism, which similarly places a high emphasis on patriotism and national greatness. Remember when we used to be the greatest manufacturing power, with a glorious middle class? The state can bring our next golden age. Similarly, "Nation Above All" sounds a lot like "Ask not how the State can serve you, ask how you can serve the State" (JFK's verbiage tweaked only slightly). "All within the state" sounds like it describes the "Life of Julia". I'd really like to know what modern conservatives you feel embody the "Nation/State Above All". Isn't Romney's slogan these days "we [individuals] built it, not the state?" As for punishing those who deviate from what they see as the good of the community, most major ideologies favor that. It's nothing unusual, which is why there is also traditional liberal support for censorship (of slightly different topics).