5 ms·
Adding up all of the wealth in a small region and then calculating wealth inequality against a small number of households makes for some triggering headlines, b
by Aurornis 1y ago
Adding up all of the wealth in a small region and then calculating wealth inequality against a small number of households makes for some triggering headlines, but it’s not a very useful metric for anything in the real world.
A though exercise: If these 9 households moved to another city, the wealth inequality would improve. But what has actually been accomplished? Tax revenues would actually drop.
A lot of these perspectives cater to an idea that wealth is zero sum. If a small number of households have a lot of wealth, some people assume it must have been amassed by taking it from the other households. The more people believe in zero-sum thinking, the more egregious this feels.
- apwell23 1y ago> A lot of these perspectives cater to an idea that wealth is zero sum. ofcourse its zero sum. There are only so many natural resources to exploit. Zuckerberg owns like half of lake tahoe and Hawaii.
- anothereng 1y agoif it were zero sum then how come middle class people nowadays live better lives than kings 500 years ago?
- bgwalter 1y agoI'd rather have Versailles than my current apartment. I think all standard pro-billionaire talking points have been exhausted in these comments.
- anothereng 1y agoso you want to be rich and are mad that you're not?
- Tadpole9181 1y agoOh, he was wrong, now all pro-billionaire talking points have been exhausted.
- happytoexplain 1y agoWhat a hideous mindset. This attitude is the origin of the ruin of civilization.
- heavyset_go 1y agoWhat middle class person has thousands of literal servants who will spend every waking hour serving, feeding, cleaning, tailoring, cooking and creating for them in their giant, country-spanning estates? How many middle class people have the God-given divine right to rule and demand the sons of every nobleman to fight to keep and expand their power? How many middle class people literally own a country and can dictate what happens in it from the top down? How many vineyards do middle class people own? How many garden hermits[1] do they keep on their estates simply for their ambience and kitsch? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden_hermit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden_hermit
- anothereng 1y agoyou don't need that many servants when you have businesses that offer the same services and you can afford them. Or you think middle class people can't afford travelling, laundry services, food delivery, etc. The second thing you're referring to is power. Power I admit can be zero sum but most people are not ambitious in that way, they just want material wealth not political power.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- heavyset_go 1y agoSorry, using DoorDash to order fast food is not the same thing as having a team of the country's best chefs cooking every meal for you in your castle using ingredients your farmers hand-picked on your own vast swathes of premium farmland. Sounds healthier, too. Similarly, spending $10 at McDonald's is not the same thing as having teams of servants tending to your every whim every waking moment until you die. If you can't see that clear difference, I don't think you're approaching this in good faith. You shouldn't have to stretch the truth this much to make your point if it's actually true and you know it.
- ninkendo 1y agoLet’s compare my quality of life to a king 500 years ago. I have air conditioning. I have running water and a toilet. I have antibiotics. And all sorts of other medicine that actually works. When I have to get an operation done I can go under anesthesia rather than it being literal torture. And I won’t be killed by an infection resulting from the tiniest cut. I have literally endless entertainment. More than I can ever consume in a lifetime. I have access to just about any piece of information that has ever existed and been made public. I don’t have to worry about being killed by an uprising. I can go on.
- happytoexplain 1y agoNobody is arguing that it is zero-sum across time. It is zero sum across space (i.e. across people).
- Chinjut 1y agoMiddle class people are forced to work at jobs doing what some boss tells them to do instead of what they like with the majority of their waking hours. In that regard, they live lives far from as pleasurable as those of kings.
- soulofmischief 1y agoIt's not zero sum if we regulate these resources. The sun provides low entropy which we can convert to an increasing stockpile of wealth. The problem is how we've decided to distribute it, and whether we can successfully transition to mining our local solar system.
- apwell23 1y ago> It's not zero sum if we regulate these resources. That would be good for billionaires because they can be the only ones that have access to those resources. See what is happening in lake tahoe.
- soulofmischief 1y agoYes, proper regulation benefits everyone. You're hinting at the idea that "regulation" will turn into regulatory capture. I share that fear, but at that point we're not talking about real regulation, just political theatre.
- apwell23 1y agoIts not just mark. Most of lake tahoe properties stay empty most of the year. They loudly regulate any new development. Thats happening all over country, even in my middle class neighborhood. Not sure what kind of regulation in this case would benefit everyone.
- soulofmischief 1y agoMy comment was about regulating the consumption of natural resources. Property allocation is a whole other political beast.
- taftster 1y agoThe total sum of all natural resources has yet to be discovered. We were supposed to hit peak oil in what, the 1990's? Trees are on a dramatic decline, but they still exist. No one can correctly or meaningfully count the amount of natural resources left in total existence. And when there's scarcity, another solution tends to emerge as substitute. As such, as parent stated, it's not a zero sum game. Zero sum assumes you can define the end state. That being said, whether or not it's zero-sum is meaningless, and I don't take issue with arguing against the parent. Ultimately, the wealth-gap is widening to detrimental effect. The middle class is being divided into haves and have nots. Whether you believe this is a problem, that's probably another type of discussion.
- apwell23 1y ago> And when there's scarcity, another solution tends to emerge as substitute. then why do we so much conservation and create all sorts of laws around it ?
- jcranmer 1y ago> We were supposed to hit peak oil in what, the 1990's? Originally the late 60's, actually, according to Wikipedia. The failure of Malthusian catastrophes to occur despite centuries of prediction hasn't dampened enthusiasm for predicting them to occur in the near future.
- benreesman 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bglusman 1y agoSo, OK, yes some specific assets are zero sum when defined narrowly…. But take Picassos. Well, ok, he’s been dead for 52 years, so sure, he’s not painting any more, but… he did… his paintings weren’t zero sum while he was alive, he created them and increased supply steadily during his life. Real estate is the classic example, true, but precious metals? They’re zero sum in one sense, but what do you think mining does? It increases the supply and effectively amount of precious metals in the world. Same for drilling for oil I guess, though I don’t really want to defend of encourage that, but, it’s still not exactly zero sum, even if I don’t like it, because you can’t just count wealth that’s inaccessible as equivalent to wealth that is accessible. So 3 of your 4 examples are perfect examples that wealth is NOT really zero sum at all. And you can’t eat those. So what about food? Food production has been increased… what, 500x maybe in the last 100 years via agricultural technology investment and science. That’s a lot fewer people starving or going hungry… admittedly we now have the opposite problem via obesity epidemic, but, now here comes GLP-1 innovation which… also increases wealth? Wealth is a pretty tricky thing to define but if people are paying money for it voluntarily it seems to qualify.
- bigbadfeline 1y ago> but what do you think mining does? It increases the supply and effectively amount of precious metals in the world. Population increases faster the mining operations, so this specific example is negative sum in per-capita terms.
- TFYS 1y agoYes, not all things are zero-sum, but enough are that inequality really does matter. Take labor for example. There's only a limited number of skilled people. Who do those skilled people work for? The people that can give them the most money. So, instead of using their skills to build farms, housing, schools and other things that benefit a large number of people they use their skills to build yachts, mansions and manipulation algorithms. Demand from those with wealth increases the price of skilled labor to the point where people with no money can not afford it. Skilled people from poor communities move to the places where the rich throw their capital around, work on things that the wealthy think are important, and the communities they leave behind suffer as a result.
- conception 1y agoIt’s not zero sum but that doesn’t mean the very wealthy aren’t taking substantial more of the pie’s growth as its grows, if not nearly all of it.
- monero-xmr 1y agoAll that matters is what you can purchase and what lifestyle you can afford. Despite living in supposed Dickensian-levels of inequality there is no better time in world history to be alive, by a long shot, and our poorest have it better than ever before
- surgical_fire 1y agoThat's not all that matters, although it is important. Excessive concentration of wealth has destructive consequences.
- pj_mukh 1y ago"destructive consequences." In the context of just Silicon Valley, what are they?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- surgical_fire 1y agoDid you just come out of a coma? The destructive and unchecked accumulation of wealth in SV is what allowed the creation of monstrosities such as the gig economy and massive surveillance. At the present moment in time it even allowed some tech oligarchs to directly influence elections in their favor, gaining access direct access to the high levels of government to have nugde government actions inntheir favor, curb regulatory interference that might put checks in their companies, etc. I am presuming younasked from a position of ignorance rather than finding all this desirable somehow.
- jayd16 1y agoYou're looking at this backwards. It's already an affluent area and even still wealth is so consolidated. What is the point of the thought experiment? No one is asking them to _move_.
- happytoexplain 1y ago>The more people believe in zero-sum thinking It is zero-sum. That's the correct way of thinking. It may not be absolutely zero-sum, but it is effectively zero-sum. As in: The effects, problems, and solutions - in practice - are the same as is if it were zero-sum.
- avmich 1y agoCan it be a negative-sum - the bigger inequality, the smaller the total?
- drivingmenuts 1y agoWhile they are perhaps paying large amounts of local taxes, are these taxes in the same proportion as those of lesser wealth and are these taxes in proportion to their influence? For most wealthy people, taxes are an afterthought given the tax breaks they have access to.
- antonvs 1y agoThe point is that SV is packed to the brim with very wealthy people, so this is a demonstration of the scale of the wealth inequality, which is something people tend to have difficulty wrapping their heads around.