9 ms·
Driverless cars promise to reduce accidents, revolutionise transport
- jalanco 14y agoThe likelihood of the Teamster's union allowing (i.e., not obstructing) driverless cargo hauling to succeed in the US would be close to zero.
- Someone 14y agoI think they would be beaten by the tactic that killed Fleet Street (where newsprinters got rid of all their personnel by moving their business, but leaving outdated personnel such as typesetters behind. See http://www.mediauk.com/article/32718/the-fleet-street-revolution http://www.mediauk.com/article/32718/the-fleet-street-revolu...): secretly buy your driverless trucks, and replace all your drivers overnight. That way, you won't have employees that can strike against the change.
- maxerickson 14y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the trucking companies are able to offer them a competitive wage for acting as freight minders. They might even end up with similar pay for less total hours away from home.
- Someone 14y agoWhat freight would there be to mind that isn't minded already today? The only thing I can think of is the freight on the driverless cars, but I do not see how that would lead to "less total hours away from home"
- maxerickson 14y agoA trucker is only allowed to drive a certain number of hours a day, mostly because they are supposed to rest. If they aren't driving, they can sleep while the truck is moving.
- Someone 14y ago=> trucks will make more hours a day driving => we need need fewer trucks => we need fewer drivers minding those fewer trucks I fail to see what would make truck owners offer 'competitive salaries' given that there will likely be X>1 truck drivers competing for each 'truck minder' job, and that the job requires fewer qualifications (drivers do the minding today, and future minders will not need a drover's license)
- kinofcain 14y agoI think the biggest problem with adoption is going to be integrating them into traffic. A car that obeys the speed limits and follows at a safe distance is going to have issues driving in someplace like Los Angeles. It will be interesting to see how that plays out. For instance, what happens when other more agressive drivers learn that they can just cut off driverless cars and the software will just happily slow down to let them pass? It's a really interesting problem set.
- poblano 14y agoI guess, but the saving grace is that the passengers of such cars are less likely to care, unless they're in some special rush. I mean, if I had one, I would be reading or working or talking to someone, and might not even notice a few extra minutes transit time. It'd be like riding public transit minus the inconveniences (noise, strangers, waiting).
- agumonkey 14y agoThe shifting in perception of cars is interesting. It's almost like auto-automobiles are giving us hours of lifetime back.
- dandrews 14y agoI stopped caring much about extra minutes on the road when cruise control became standard equipment - years ago. When I drive a car without cruise I tend to be competitive and aggressive, but with cruise I set it and chill out. People may pass but I no longer care. Bring on the Google cars and I'll detach completely.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rogerbinns 14y agoThe other side effect is that the driverless cars behaving like that will help reduce congestion! See the experiments and data at http://trafficwaves.org http://trafficwaves.org - note he does talk about "aggressive" drivers taking advantage and how effective it actually is. And all these self driving cars have cameras and black boxes. It would be simple to prove that someone (or something) has been driving like a dick. That isn't illegal yet ...
- lda 14y agoThe article outlines some (current) limitations in the car's judgement when evaluating the dangerosity of an object ahead. If/when this becomes mainstream, how long until pranksters and terrorists find ways to leverage limitations and cause accidents?
- olalonde 14y agoThat's an interesting thought. Driverless cars could also be used for targeted assassinations by provoking deadly accidents. Of course, it can be done with regular cars except that whoever causes the accident has to be willing to put his life on the line.
- martindale 14y agoIn theory, accidents provoked by these cars would be standouts in a history of safety.
- majormajor 14y agoIs causing accidents in self-driving cars going to be any more a target than causing accidents in human-driven cars? Seems you could already wreak a lot of havoc with rush-hour traffic if you really wanted to. Blinding/distracting drivers, obstacles, maybe little bombs?
- protomyth 14y agoWell, since self-driving cars are new and don't have the protection of an earlier history of precedents, then yes, they will be much bigger legal targets. The whole overblown spontaneous acceleration incidents would be a good pointer.
- Estragon 14y agoDriverless trucks with no passengers will totally be targets for vandalism and theft.
- PedroBatista 14y agoThey can also cut our balls once and for all and put us out of our misery. So much is spent pursuing "safety" and squeezing that extra minute of "productivity" that everyone is forgetting to live their lives as human beings.
- sanderjd 14y agoI don't see the connection between driving and "living my life as a human being", or the connection between riding in an automated vehicle and "having my balls cut". Human identity has nothing to do with driving. I can't wait until I don't have to do it anymore.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI generally disagree with the GP post, but I think automated cars will almost certainly result in more closely monitored and controlled travel.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoNo more so than already exists by almost everybody carrying a mobile phone.
- PedroBatista 14y agoAt least you can smash it with a rock and continue to go where you want to go, when you want and how you want.
- PedroBatista 14y agoBy not knowing how to drive something, you are losing an important ability. Your reach will be 3 or 4 miles at most, and over time this passive "I just want to [_____], do it for me" mentality sets in. And for what? just not to drive? to have more 20min available to check your Twitter stream? Remember, you are choosing to be ignorant in a very important aspect of modern live, and i guess only those who at some point were deprived of it realize their importance.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- olalonde 14y agoI wonder how those cars will perform in places like Hanoi or Nanchang. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oetF3UTIwbc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oetF3UTIwbc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aodbmS_43M http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aodbmS_43M
- rogerbinns 14y agoHopefully there can be more public transport. The problem at the moment with most public transport is that it requires a human driver. That makes it relatively expensive for the transport of one or two people, or even 8 people. Some places have a partial solution (with driver) - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi The main reason for owning transport is because it guarantees availability when you need it, especially where you are and where you want to go. You pay quite a bit extra for that, and it does get inconvenient (having to park away from where you want to be, dealing with traffic, insurance, maintenance etc). Mobile infrastructure is very good in places like you mention (good coverage, low price) so this is solvable.
- jonaphin 14y agoI love the idea of driverless cars; it is nevertheless important to note that hacking might replace drunk driving as the #1 cause of deaths on the road.
- EliRivers 14y agoWith driverless cars, the largest expense of taxis - the driver - disappears. The driver of a taxi needs to make enough in a day to cover the periods when there are no fares, or travel from a low fare-density area back to the high fare-density areas (and in some regions with ridiculously constrained supply of taxis via "badges" or other such anti-competitive pro-monopoly legislation, to pay the ridiculous fee to just operate a cab). With the drivers removed, you now have a fleet of taxis that can run 24 hours a day (minus maintenance etc.), cost zero to just sit and wait for a fare, and can be managed and coordinated easily to migrate across the changing fare-density regions throughout the day. If the price and convenience goes down enough, various groups of people stop needing cars. They just use the "get me a cab" app on their smartphone (or just use the regular telephone) to get a cab when they need it. If this creates a positive feedback loop of cheaper & more convenient -> more people using it -> more taxis deploted -> cheaper & more convenient etc., then in some high-population areas, owning a car will become an unnecessary extravagance. Operated automatically gives scope for further savings; heading from point A to point C via B, and someone in B is also going to C? You'll get offered a "share this ride for this discount" option. All this leads, hopefully, to fewer cars needed to provide the same number of journeys, at lower cost. So, how do I go about shorting the car manufacturers? :p
- pdelgallego 14y agoYou forgot to mention another consequence, the return of the Luddites
- EliRivers 14y agoThe majority of Westeners know the following about cars; turn the wheel thing to pick a direction, push one pedal to go faster and one to go slower. Some of them also know how to operate the stick thingy. Removing this tiny scrap of knowledge is hardly returning to Ludditehood.
- pdelgallego 14y agoNot, but removing hundreds of thousands of taxi/truck drivers will do it
- jonlarson 14y agoI'd say no more than 50 years before driving by hand becomes illegal in most places, especially large cities. The benefits will just become too obvious.
- amit_m 14y agoThis might become a great transition technology. But leaves many problems unsolved: 1. All the issues surrounding fuel-burning engines OR all the issues surrounding huge and expensive batteries. 2. An inherent lack of energy efficiency. The payload/car-weight ratio is typically 1/10 or worse. 3. Cars are very expensive, they take a lot of space and require roads that take even more space. 4. Cars are not safe. Driverless cars really only solve (4) and have small advantages in terms of fuel efficiency and congestion. A network of Driverless taxis should be much cheaper than owning a car, since these cars will be utilized heavily throughout the day. An even better approach would be an automatically dispatched shared-taxi system that would group passengers that want to go to close destinations. I wonder why there isn't more effort directed towards Personal-Rapid-Transport system. i.e.small electric carts on dedicated lanes (or lines, or rails), with low weight and no battery. Like a packet-switched version of the train system. Such systems can be highly automatic, very energy-efficient and provide convenient rides relatively cheaply. It looks like we have had all the technology required to do it for at least 30 years. It seems that the only thing stopping this type of technology from being developed is that it requires someone with a lot of capital and guts who's not afraid of dealing with a regulatory nightmare. Unfortunately there aren't that many Elon Musks out there. Here are some specialized PRT systems in use: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_rapid_transit#Existing_and_planned_networks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_rapid_transit#Existing...