4 ms·
Solar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) but prices are continuing to decrease. Sadly, the US is hitting a hiccup as the c
by Aurornis 1y ago
Solar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) but prices are continuing to decrease.
Sadly, the US is hitting a hiccup as the current administration is going out of their way to make solar installs harder and more expensive. Putting tariffs on solar equipment imports is an insane self-defeat. We should be importing as much cheap solar and battery gear as we can get our hands on.
Give it a couple years of price progress and political turnover and I think we’re going to be in a great position.
- jillesvangurp 1y ago> Solar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) but prices are continuing to decrease. Exactly, gas is heavily subsidized and government supported in the US. And even with that support it only barely scrapes ahead. Courtesy of current and future tax payers coughing up the interest payments on the trillions of dollars in debt. That's not going to last indefinitely. The key point here is that the difference is a bit artificial. In the rest of the world where installing solar is something like a third of the cost (no tariffs, less installation bureaucracy, less crippling rules and legislation, etc.) and where batteries can be imported closer to cost price from China, the picture is very different. If it's importing LNG vs. cheap solar panels + batteries, the latter is already very attractive in many places. Even at higher latitudes than the 49th parallel below which most of the US is. And it's on track to get a lot better. Production for sodium ion batteries is starting to come online in China. It will be a while before those make it to the US due to the politics. But some are now projecting cost as low as 10$/kwh for those mid term. 1 mwh battery would cost about 10K$ at those prices. And they have quite long lives (thousands of charge cycles). You can run a house on one of those for well over a month in the US. Much longer in places where houses are better insulated and more efficient. It will be a few years before we can get these obviously. But it's a nice mental model for what a reasonably affordable battery will be able to do soon.
- bjourne 1y ago> And it's on track to get a lot better. Production for sodium ion batteries is starting to come online in China. It will be a while before those make it to the US due to the politics. But some are now projecting cost as low as 10$/kwh for those mid term. Is that a typo? Just a year ago ago batteries were expected to drop to $80/kWh around 2026-2027... $10/kWh in the near future is absolutely insane.
- nicoburns 1y agoWhat counts as "soon" is pretty subjective of course, but $10/kWh is only 3 halving's from $80/kWh. So it wouldn't be too surprising if $80/kWh in 2026 corresponded to $10/kWh in 2030.
- jillesvangurp 1y ago2030 only five years. And the original was not a typo. But it is a best case prediction. Whether that's 2028 or 2038 is a bit immaterial. What matters here is the basic principle that sodium ion batteries don't contain any hard to get or expensive materials. So the materials are cheap to source and the manufacturing process is well understood and should benefit from economies of scale, learning effects, etc. The point is that prices are coming down and the further these come down the worse it gets for gas. It's also worth noting that we've been on a bit of a journey with solar panels. Prices for those have also fallen quite a bit in the last decade and might fall further. That puts any investments to do with gas plants solidly under water within just a few years. Which is why there is a reluctance in the market to invest in that sort of thing despite considerable political pressure in parts of the US to do so.
- bityard 1y ago> Putting tariffs on solar equipment imports is an insane self-defeat. We should be importing as much cheap solar and battery gear as we can get our hands on. The tariffs are going to impact me heavily because I had planned on buying a shitload of solar in the next 3-5 years. If the price on solar triples in that timeframe (as the price on other things has in the last few years), I will not be "going solar" after all except for a few small hobby projects. That being said, we should not lose sight of the fact that the REASON solar is cheap right now is because it manufactured almost exclusively in the far east, at cost, subsidized by a communist state, to stifle worldwide competition. I don't think that is good for the world either. There is likely (hopefully) a middle ground here somewhere.
- nicoburns 1y ago> subsidized by a communist state, to stifle worldwide competition I don't think "to stifle competition" is right. I suspect China would love it if other countries were investing in solar as much as they are. They just want the tech ASAP.
- throwaway473825 1y ago> subsidized by a communist state, to stifle worldwide competition China primarily wants to cut oil and gas imports. Exports are a bonus.
- philipkglass 1y agoChina was a big solar exporter before it was a big solar installer. China had a small solar manufacturing capacity in 2003. By 2008 it was number one in the world for solar manufacturing and it has remained there since: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_China#/media/File:Largest_Producers_of_Solar_Cells_by_Country-Market_Share.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_China#/media/Fi... But it didn't start installing large quantities of solar power domestically until 2013: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_China#Solar_PV_by_province https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_China#Solar_PV_... Before that, solar power was too expensive for large scale use inside China. Chinese renewable energy growth was mostly hydropower and wind before 2013. Now of course China is by far #1 in yearly solar power installations as well as solar manufacturing, and that in combination with electric vehicle adoption is helping to curb oil demand: "China’s electric car revolution hammers demand for oil" https://finance.yahoo.com/news/china-electric-car-revolution-hammers-155408191.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/china-electric-car-revolution...
- bmelton 1y agoI haven't heard anyone say it out loud, but I'd wager it's in large part related to things like Chinese solar panels containing remotely triggerable kill-switches and/or having the ability to function as unauthorized mesh relays https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/climate-energy/ghost-machine-rogue-communication-devices-found-chinese-inverters-2025-05-14/ https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/climate-energy/ghost-...
- EvanAnderson 1y agoI could see subterfuge in the inverters, but aren't panels themselves electrically very simple? I would think a rogue device within the panel itself would be apparent. It's still worth examining the panels in minute detail. I just think it would be a ton more difficult to hide much functionality within a panel.
- 05 1y agoReds under beds, again?
- jandrese 1y agoYou can trace out the circuits on a traditional solar panel. They aren't complex devices. If someone managed to hide some kind of control chip in there and also some sort of connectivity to trigger it then my hat is off to them. I would worry more about the inverters, including microinverters. Also consider that if someone is doing industrial sabotage on that scale it would be much easier to attack the fossil fuel and nuclear power plants and their enormous computer controlled generators. Even hydroelectric would be susceptible. Or maybe attack the substations. There is nothing unique or special about solar panels that makes them a good target, and their highly distributed and diverse nature actually makes them more difficult.
- ben_w 1y agoOther targets may be more appropriate, but: > and their highly distributed and diverse nature actually makes them more difficult Distributed doesn't make it harder, if/when there's a common failure mode. See e.g. this with the power grid which is obviously as distributed as any PV connected to it: https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-new-attack-to-take-down-european-power-grid/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2025/01/could-hackers-use-n...
- gpm 1y ago> Solar and batteries are still more expensive than gas (as the article admits) On the contrary > The sunniest US city, Las Vegas [...] It could get to 60% solar+storage at $65/MWh — cheaper than gas. The article asserts that until you are generating the majority of your power from Solar+Storage, at least in favorable places, solar is cheaper than gas... And it reached that conclusion under the incredibly unfavourable assumption that all the solar is in the same place, not being distributed around by a grid averaging out the amount of cloud cover over space.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pydry 1y agoalso waaaaaaay cheaper than nuclear power.
- MostlyStable 1y agoIn a thread decrying policy choices that are artificially making one particular kind of power generation more expensive than they have to be, this seems like a weird comment to make.
- matthewdgreen 1y agoIs nuclear power only expensive because of policy choices? I know it's cheaper in, say, China where the policy is different, but it still isn't anywhere as cheap as solar.
- ben_w 1y agoYes on both halves of that. Expensive in that the policy choice is "we want the worst-case to be affordable", and that this includes not only explosive meltdowns but also international treaties to make sure nobody steals radioisotopes. More than it needs to be, because anecdotes I've heard about radiation spills include "some liquid was spilled on the tarmac so we had to dig up a long deep trench; the replacement had some granite in and was more radioactive than the stuff it replaced".
- rozap 1y agoMore expensive than gas, if you power 98% of the grid with it. But if you power 60% of the grid, it's cheaper than gas. Useful distinction imo.
- bryanlarsen 1y agoThe linked white paper says that the cutover point is at 97% for sunny locations in the US, and more surprisingly, 90% for cloudy mainland US locations.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoThe great part is... we already have more than enough Nuclear, Hydro, Wind, and Geothermal power for that other 10% - so going 100% solar would be asinine.
- bryanlarsen 1y agoIt's not quite that simple. You need to be able to supply 100% of demand 10% of the time, and we don't have enough nuclear, hydro and wind to do that. 100% of demand 10% of the time is an oversimplification, but a reasonable one.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- billy99k 1y ago"Sadly, the US is hitting a hiccup as the current administration is going out of their way to make solar installs harder and more expensive" The other group has been trying to tax solar for years: https://solarrights.org/blog/2025/05/06/solartax2024/ https://solarrights.org/blog/2025/05/06/solartax2024/ Why no outcry on HN?
- empath75 1y ago> The other group has been trying to tax solar for years: https://solarrights.org/blog/2025/05/06/solartax2024/ https://solarrights.org/blog/2025/05/06/solartax2024/ Sorry, what other group. Power companies?
- billy99k 1y agoHEH "They unsuccessfully tried again in 2024, working with Governor Newsom to try and slip a Solar Tax in his proposed budget."
- empath75 1y agoRemind me again who is in charge of the California state legislature, and who voted against this 'tax'.
- billy99k 1y agoSo you aren't going to blame the governor, but some how will blame the Republicans for all of these issues and more? If you were at least a little more honest, I might be able to have a discussion with you.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoAs someone who greatly supports solar power and the rights of homeowners to install solar, I think your link is total bullshit and calling it a "solar tax" is disingenuous by people that want something for free The fundamental problem with net metering is that it is obviously unsustainable and unfair. People who are hooked up to the grid benefit from more than just the energy they consume, but the hookup costs and maintenance of the grid is a real cost that power companies need to pay for. Perhaps even more obviously, any company that is in a retail business can only survive if they buy a product at a (cheaper) wholesale rate and sell it at a (more expensive) retail rate. Net metering is exactly the same as forcing power companies to buy energy at a retail rate. Again, this is obviously not sustainable. As a homeowner, of course I would love net metering, because I'd be getting a sweet deal. But it's not hard for me to see how this can't continue as solar power installations increase. Austin, TX, was one of the first locales to use "value of solar" pricing, and yeah, while it sucks for the homeowner, it is also fairer and more sustainable. I'm also not saying this is the only way to do things (e.g. you could have a monthly connection fee and a separate monthly power charge), but this "solar rights" group is just spinning bullshit because their sweet deal is about to come to an end.
- PaulKeeble 1y agoI don't think the USA is costing in the political risk of not converting to green energy. You do not want to be the only country emitting significant CO2 in a decades time when everyone else has transitioned. Partly it will be more expensive to keep burning fuel especially when the economy of scale decreases but also the political risk of sanctions will be very high.
- jillesvangurp 1y agoIt's the long term economics that the US should be worried about. Just because the US is sticking its head in the sand doesn't mean the rest of the world is slowing down investments along with it. Other countries are investing heavily in becoming energy independent which means they'll be building the infrastructure to generate lots of cheap energy to power their economies rather than depending on expensive fossil fuel imports. Part of which currently come from the US. The recent tariff madness is actually speeding all this up. The US as an manufacturing and export country already doesn't make much sense. And that will only get worse. Industry depends on energy and if that energy is locally more expensive than abroad, that puts any energy intensive business at a disadvantage when other countries start running on really cheap renewables and battery. If you look at this globally, there are a lot of emerging markets that never imported that much oil, coal, and gas to begin with that probably never will. They'll be growing fueled by cheap locally generated renewables. And then there are countries all over Asia and Europe that are mostly importing their fossil fuels that are going to decimate what they import over the next decades. All of that will shift the economic balance in their favor. Any one exporting fossil fuels (including the US) is going to have a rather big problem with shrinking exports. Places like China are far ahead of everyone else here. And an increasingly large part of their economy is actually selling their tech to other countries to get to a similar level.
- jayd16 1y agoIt'll be a long tail. The less people rely on fossil fuels, the cheaper it will get (until it gets so underused you start lose economies of scale). But even without any proper political leadership, America will follow the money and pick the most profitable choice.