5 ms·
I'll repeat my statement from when the 1 billion dollar verdict was made, since it seems like little will change before people vote with their wallets: Today A
by josteink 14y ago
I'll repeat my statement from when the 1 billion dollar verdict was made, since it seems like little will change before people vote with their wallets:
Today Apple went down in history as the biggest patent-troll of all time, stiffling innovation and competition like nobody has ever done before.
If you are a software-developer you should recognize the fundamental threat which Apple represents to your profession.
Boycott Apple if you want to be able to stay in business in the long term future. Throw away your Macbooks, iPhones and iPads. Ditch your iTunes and iTunes account. Get rid of everything Apple. All of it.
Be vocal about your code of ethical software conduct and how that prohibits involving anything made by Apple into anything you ever do.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ThePherocity 14y agoApple is a company compelled to be greedy. It's actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible given any legal and ethical way it can. Suing another giant tech company over legitimate patents is ethical. The system is designed so that a trial determines if the patents are legit. This is what happened. If you don't like that, then fix the fucking patent system. Quit whining that your favourite tech company lost. Companies are not teams, they are simply the manufacturer of a product that you either bought or chose not to buy. If you don't like the way a company is legally and ethically running it's business, then change the law. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided.
- statictype 14y agoSuing another giant tech company over legitimate patents is ethical If you don't like the way a company is legally and ethically running it's business, then change the law. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided. You seem to be confused about the difference between 'ethical' and 'legally allowed'.
- ThePherocity 14y agoNo, I'm not, and the reason you think I am is because you're not looking at the whole picture. Apple invests it's shareholder dollars in R&D on the promise that they will return on that investment. Apple spent years getting it right, and then Samsung copies the work and spits out a competing product in a fraction of the time. Apple is suing because Samsung stole ideas, and Samsung is leveraging it's business on Apples R&D. Now, I don't think ideas or design should have a monetary value. But if you live in a world where ideas have currency, then stealing ideas is theft. We need to change the laws so ideas are free to all men. Apple isn't the problem, it's simply the best at navigating the problem.
- sanxiyn 14y ago"Samsung is leveraging its business on Apple's R&D." Samsung is leveraging its business on Google's R&D. With Google's consent. Fixed that for you.
- ThePherocity 14y agoWell, absolutely, Samsung is leveraging Google's, and many companies R&D. But R&D isn't cheep, intuitive, or obvious. Blackberry decided not to copy Apple very much, still created some great phones from a product view and they died. Nokia copied not at all, and they're not doing too well. HTC copied a little, and they are doing okayish. Samsung copied a lot more and is doing the best. My argument is all ideas should be free. We should adopt the good ideas globally so every phone copies the best ideas. You get an inventors monopoly for as long as it takes to reverse engineer. In our current product cycles, that's ~2+years. All problems solved.
- vetinari 14y agoGalaxy S3/Note/Nexus have nothing in common with Apple R&D. Just because Samsung is providing better mousetrap to the market does not mean that it is riding on Apple. Btw, the first cellphone was made by Motorola. The first cellphone with MP3 player was made by Samsung. Is Apple riding their R&D?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- vetinari 14y ago> If you don't like the way a company is legally and ethically running it's business, then change the law. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided. "Vote with your wallet" is a valid strategy. Just because the company you like is at the receiving end, does not change it's validity.
- Bill_Dimm 14y agoIt's actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible given any legal and ethical way it can. What law says that? I seriously want to know. Don't boycott the company who is succeeding best at working within the framework provided. Why not? As a consumer, am I not entitled to buy (or not buy) from whoever I want? Am I really not allowed to take any other factors into account beyond the legality of the company's behavior?
- LVB 14y agoEven if it is "actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible" (please show me that law), over what time frame? It's not unreasonable that this aggressive policy could result in a diminished Apple image/reputation that could negatively affect long term profits more than any alleged patent infringement.
- gregsq 14y agoThere is no law that obligates the directors of a company to maximise profit, at least under the Corporations Act that I know of in the UK. There is a statutory requirement to act in the best interests of the legal entity that is the corporation, and what these obligations are has been further defined under case law. There is no such law here in the UK. I will leave the US corporation law context to someone else with specific knowledge.
- mistercow 14y ago>It's actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible given any legal and ethical way it can. A corporation has a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of its shareholders, but I think this fact is greatly overstated. Since "best interest" is such a flexible and uncertain concept, most cases where people bring this up are not really the "legal imperative to be assholes" that they believe. By suing Samsung over this, Apple has risked triggering an all out patent war between the major players in the mobile market which could end up costing them tremendous legal fees and may wound them grievously if any of the ensuing lawsuits were not decided in their favor. Suppose Apple had not taken to Samsung to court over these patents. Does it really seem plausible to you that the shareholders would sue Apple's board of directors, and win? But assuming that corporations are legally expected to perfectly predict the future and optimize for their shareholders' interests, a boycott would still be warranted. If we let companies see that acting like a bully will hurt their bottom line, then those companies will be legally compelled to act in the interest of their shareholders by not being bullies.
- gregsq 14y agoSpeaking from the UK perspective, the false idea that maximisation of profit is inferred in any way by corporation law is sometimes more easily seen when examining the case of 'Private' companies. These are companies still limited by shares, or stocks, but where the director, the single shareholder, and the employee are all one and the same person. It can be a valuable example because it is easy to show how a director making decisions that maximise benefits to the shareholder are not necessarily in the best interests of the company entity, and in fact are viewed with suspicion by regulating bodies. The best interests of the company include many other considerations besides shareholder return. One of those has to be long term viability for a long lived corporate entity. Eroding goodwill and reputational or brand damage go directly to the heart of the concept of director responsibility.
- danmaz74 14y agoOn the contrary, your own logic would imply that a boycott is the only logical action to take. You say that it is "actually the law for Apple to make as much money as possible given any legal and ethical [sic] way it can". So, the only way to help Apple management back off from the use of preposterous software patents without the serious risk of breaking that law would be to enact a boycott and create a serious damage to the company image for doing so. A damage that could make that course of action not the one to "make as much money as possible".
- unobfuscate 14y agoI grew up using a Mac. My dad first bought a Macintosh SE back in the late 80’s, and I spent my days playing breakout (or whatever it was called back then). I finally got my own machine in the mid 90’s, my sparkling little Performa 5200. I learned how to program on it, building little programs using a Pascal-like language. On my walks to school, there was a daily battle with all my PC owning chums, the evangelical nature was strong. After a stint using University machines, I picked up the first Intel Macbook back in 2006. My laptop died earlier this year, and I decided to simplify my portable life by picking up the New iPad. I’ve also owned a few different permutations of the shuffle over the years, enjoying it's simplicity and lack of features. With news of the forthcoming retina 13 inch Macbook pro, I was contemplating getting a new laptop (the ipad is fun, but I miss coding on the go). But today, that thought officially died. We are done, Apple and I. They have gone too far, and I can no longer support them as a company. Every dollar I spend on their products will go toward killing the very place I call home. I encourage everyone to vote with their wallets. If you believe Apple is hurting our industry, stop supporting them. Next time someone asks me for gadget/computer advice, I will be pointing them in a different direction.
- rimantas 14y ago> Today Apple went down in history as the biggest > patent-troll of all time, stiffling innovation and > competition like nobody has ever done before. Only Apple is no patent troll, because they produce and sell high quality products which other companies try to copy. Please, tell me how much innovation will be stiffled when Samsung can no longer produce these highly original connectors http://www.davidglover.org/facsimilist/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/apple-iphone-usb-cable-2007-vs-samsung-galaxy-tab-usb-cable-2010.jpg http://www.davidglover.org/facsimilist/wp-content/uploads/20..., or USB adapters: http://cdn.mactrast.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Samsung-Power-Adapter-ripoff-1.png http://cdn.mactrast.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/Samsung-P... > Throw away your Macbooks, iPhones and iPads. Indeed, you won't need them, others came with a plenty of fresh ideas: http://dewith.com/2012/its-not-just-phones/ http://dewith.com/2012/its-not-just-phones/
- vibrunazo 14y agoSee, this is why we should use the term "patent extortion" instead of trolls. To avoid pedants like the above.
- fpgeek 14y agoI tend to prefer "patent ogre" myself.
- unobfuscate 14y agoHow exactly is this whole power adapter and usb connector thing even relevant? Who sits down, and decides to buy a product based on the configuration of the included cables? I sure don't. Nobody is arguing Apple hasn't done great things for the evolution of phones and laptops, but so have other companies. Least we all forget, Apple is the granddaddy of ripping off technologies (and good for them, we are better off for it).
- emehrkay 14y agoYeah they definitely are not patent trolls unless the meaning of the term has changed since Lodsys made the news earlier this year. Lodsys seems to just be a company who has a bunch of patents and waits for someone to implement one and sue. Apple created something, got it patented, and took it to court. To me that seems like it is what the patent system is about. I dont agree with patents in the current form, but that is the game right now.
- wissler 14y agoYes, the time has come for an Apple boycott, both by consumers of their products and by any decent engineers that work for Apple.