5 ms·
You can now buy eggs from in-ovo sexed hens
- throwawaymaths 1y agois the consumer vote necessary? it seems like producers might appreciate saving 50% on feeding chicks
- michaelmrose 1y agoThey don't feed them. They grind them up alive then use the resulting slush to feed to other things.
- throwawaymaths 1y agowhat do those chicks eat? IIUC they aren't sexed immediately after hatching? Maybe I'm wrong.
- ashtonbaker 1y agoSexing is typically done immediately after hatching, yes.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ashtonbaker 1y agoThey don't feed male chicks - from the first paragraph: > in the United States alone, approximately 350 million male chicks are routinely culled each year, typically by methods such as maceration (being ground up alive).
- jacknews 1y agobut they'd save on incubating the eggs which they could otherwise use or sell.
- ashtonbaker 1y agoI suppose that is true. But I imagine that the scale of egg incubation to produce hens is a relatively small portion of total egg production, since each hen produces many eggs. You'd probably have to compare the cost of incubating an egg and the labor to manually sex the chick to the per-egg cost of this technology. I would be surprised if that comes out in favor of the in-egg-sexing tech right now, but it would be great if it did.
- senkora 1y ago> In-ovo sexing is still at the beginning stages of its rollout, and while it has become substantially cheaper since it became available 7 years ago, it still adds a few cent per dozen to the production cost of eggs. I’m sure we’ll get there but for now it costs more.
- bazhova 1y agoThey don't feed the males - they just kill them.
- homeless_engi 1y agoMale chicks are not feed nor raised but rather fed into a device quite similar to a wood chipper shortly áfter birth. You can read more about it here [1] or find some quite graphic videos on YouTube. This is addressed in the article: "In polling, only 10% of Americans correctly identify that male chicks in the egg industry are killed shortly after hatching. A plurality mistakenly believe these chicks are raised for meat, and another 10% even think that male chickens can lay eggs. Most people are surprised, and often disturbed, to learn the truth: in the United States alone, approximately 350 million male chicks are routinely culled each year, typically by methods such as maceration (being ground up alive)." 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick_culling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick_culling
- throwawaymaths 1y agoyeah I'm aware of male culling.
- fhd2 1y ago"10% even think that male chickens can lay eggs" I really didn't see that one coming.
- miningape 1y agoYeah I got whiplash from my head snapping back to read that again
- xigoi 1y agoThere was also that time when a milk company wrote the names of the cows who produced the milk on the cartons and some feminist complained that all the names were female.
- clort 1y agois it an urban legend, or do you have reference for that?
- tialaramex 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 1y agoDiscovered via https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-391 https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/open-thread-391
- monster_truck 1y agoThere's no way that math is right. The wikipedia article says the US culls billions of male chicks annually. Was this written by an LLM? heh
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- homeless_engi 1y agoThe US culls 350 million male chicks per year, per this article. Wikipedia says billions of male chicks are culled worldwide, which seems plausible when accounting for EU, China, India, SA, SEA etc. The citation on Wikipedia looks legit to me as well. Edit: Wikipedia does indeed cite several different figures, including a "billions" number which does not seem plausible. Thanks monster_truck for pointing this out, and apologies for my misunderstanding!
- sebzim4500 1y agoIIRC humanity eats like 70B chickens a year so sounds very plausible to me.
- michaelmior 1y agoThe Wikipedia article clearly has some errors, but I'm not sure where since I'm not an expert. In one spot, it says 7 billion chicks are culled annually worldwide, in other it says 8.5 billion just in the US. I assume these are likely estimates taken from different sources or at different time periods, but still, I wouldn't assume Wikipedia is accurate.
- tastyfreeze 1y agoThat kinda checks out. 1.2 billion hens are butchered in the US annually. So, maybe not multiple billions of male chicks in the grinder. But, certainly over a billion. It might get to 2 billion if you count 375 million layers and some untold number of personal chickens.
- bethekidyouwant 1y agoPeople have been killing male chicks, and keeping just a single rooster since the beginning of chickens Also is the quality of the life of these non-culled female chickens good somehow?
- donw 1y agoI’m also curious if the tech is real, or if this is just yet another scam designed to separate well-meaning people from their money.
- zahlman 1y agoThe point is to not have to wait for the male chicks to be born.
- bethekidyouwant 1y agoThe article is about morality. Comment about economics. Implementation costs more. Ok.
- zahlman 1y agoMy comment is exactly as much about morality as the article is, or as your comment is.
- Maskawanian 1y ago[flagged]
- michaelmrose 1y agomale chicks aren't useful if we bring them into being we will have to kill them.
- tastyfreeze 1y agoMale chicks make as good of soup as hens. However, roosters are assholes and don't get along with other roosters by the time they are butcher weight.
- hansvm 1y agoThey don't get along with any animals, and the problem starts well before they're butcher weight. It's not uncommon for an entire hen house to wind up murdered if you don't sex your chickens.
- esperent 1y ago> It's not uncommon for an entire hen house to wind up murdered if you don't sex your chickens. Can you explain what you mean by this?
- b112 1y agoJust google chicken glasses as a start of a thread to pull on.
- esperent 1y agoYes, I'm aware that chickens can be aggressive or even occasionally cannibalistic (although that's never happened to any groups of chickens I've seen). But that doesn't explain anything about why you're saying an entire hen house can be murdered when you fail to sex chicks. I've never heard that male chicken are worse in this regard, excessive feather pecking is a result of keeping chickens in terrible environments like battery/cage farms and happens in fully female groups. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feather_pecking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feather_pecking
- setgree 1y agoIf you were a chicken behind the veil of ignorance choosing your fate, would you choose immediate death (male) or a short, difficult, confined life (female)? To many advocates, it’s self-evident that the hen’s life is better than immediate death. This is not obvious to me. It depends on the hen’s quality of life.
- Insanity 1y agoInteresting perspective. Although the “death” can happen in various ways - humane or not humane. But ultimately I can get behind the idea that the immediate death is the better outcome in the big picture..
- michaelmrose 1y agoThey aren't choosing between being male or female they are identifying eggs that are going to develop into males early and removing them. They are thus choosing between ceasing to exist before they are aware of their own existence and living approximately one day and then being ground up alive.
- mitthrowaway2 1y agoYou're discussing a different counterfactual than the post you are replying to.
- foxyv 1y agoI would be happy if we could just ban battery cages to start. I can't think of a more horrible fate aside from being a foie gras goose or a veal calf.
- michaelmrose 1y agoHow do 10% not know boys don't lay eggs and the plurality not realize we don't eat roosters
- kreco 1y agoIf you have a chicken farm, you likely eat roosters time to time.
- whywhywhywhy 1y ago> not realize we don't eat roosters The French do.
- jacknews 1y agocoq au vin?
- npteljes 1y agoPeople are not required to think about the food, so they don't. For example, it's widely known that milk comes from cows, but not that the cow needs to be pregnant in order to do so, again and again. It's just not something that one faces in their day to day life. These things just spawn on supermarket shelves, and that's about it.
- nemomarx 1y agoI wouldn't have thought we don't eat roosters. We eat bulls, so the line of thought that you use one sex for production and one for meat is kinda easy? (and hens for meat when they age out of laying etc)
- aaronbaugher 1y agoIt's actually somewhat the same in cattle. There are beef breeds of cattle for meat and dairy breeds for milk. Dairy breeds tend to be skinnier and don't grow as efficiently, so the bulls don't make good beef steers. There's kind of a specialty market in them for people who think a dairy steer raised and fed over a longer time for meat is better than the beef breeds that have been focused on efficient growth. But some dairy bull calves are just killed. The heifer calves are far more valuable.
- nemomarx 1y agoInteresting that this is already a quarter of the market in Europe? So presumably most of the wrinkles in the technique have been solved by now
- tantalor 1y agoIs there really a big difference if the chick is destroyed shortly before or shortly after hatching? Why is hatched-or-not the ethical standard?
- rtkwe 1y agoThe embryo is a lot less developed at the 9-15 day window, there's not a chance to really feel pain or panic and from a human perspective they're a lot less cute so their death is less affecting. The change from barely differentiate lump to chick happens rapidly in the last few days: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-72004-y/figures/2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-72004-y/figures/2
- cFyrute 1y agoIt's just a clump of cells. Maybe the hen isn't ready to start a family and is still discovering herself? Her broody her choice.
- RansomStark 1y agoNot a fan of the delivery, but, I think its an interesting point, and that both movements have a similar idea at their core, that life begins at birth / hatching. I think the parallels are interesting.
- em-bee 1y agobut if we go there we need to ask a more fundamental question. (to avoid a misinterpretation of what i am saying, i'd like to make clear that i am not vegan or vegetarian, i do eat meat and eggs) the question on where life begins is rather irrelevant until we answer the question of where the life of a chicken is supposed to end. if the possibility that life may begin at conception is going to be a consideration when destroying eggs because they are male, then the same consideration must be made when we chose to eat eggs in the first place. we can't argue that eating eggs is ok, but destroying them is not. consequently, as long as we eat eggs the question of when life begins is not really relevant. the relevant questions are: can we avoid destroying/wasting those eggs at all (can we eat them?) and if ee have to destroy them, what is the most humane way to go about it? my intuition suggests that destroying the eggs is more humane than letting them hatch
- mbb70 1y agoThere are at least 4 ethical/price tiers for eggs based on the quality of the hens life, and this adds a 5th to protect rooster chicks from slaughter. Ethical eggs are a luxury good that I can afford and am willing to pay for, but the blatant 'will trade cash for feeling ethical' is tough.
- ZFleck 1y agoTo those arguing that this is irrelevant, I urge you to search for a video of this "culling" yourself. All the logic in the world can't ease my stomach after watching a conveyer belt of chicks get dumped directly into a meat grinder. It's simply not right. And while there are still many issues remaining in the meat industry (arguably its existence at all), this is one less.
- dinfinity 1y ago> All the logic in the world can't ease my stomach after watching a conveyer belt of chicks get dumped directly into a meat grinder. It's simply not right. Where on the evolutionary scale do you draw the line and why, though? Remember that the feeling you experience is a very messy heuristic that exists to perform a basic evolutionary function. People have similar feelings when Boston Dynamics robots (or similar things) are kicked/'abused', even though they would never attribute any awareness or even the experience of pain to them. A feeling should always be the starting point of a rational appreciation of the situation; things are rarely "simply not right" and feelings are often wrong.
- timcobb 1y ago> conveyer belt of chicks get dumped directly into a meat grinder. I haven't seen it, and correct me if this is not the case, but it doesn't strike me as a bad way to go. Getting macerated beats most of the ways humans and wild animals die. Do these chicks have any idea "what hit them"?
- ada1981 1y agoThe lives of the hens is also horrific and painful and as soon as they drop in production they are killed. Just go vegan.
- ndr 1y agoDoes anyone know _how_ the detection process works? And is there anything done to the hen or the egg during that process that could make the egg less healthy or nutritious?
- RansomStark 1y agohormone testing was first and can work from 9 days (eggs hatch at day 21). Optical means (tend to work at a later point in the process around day 13-15), including various forms of spectroscopy (NMR, IR, etc): shine a light at the egg and look for differences. Egg should be absolutely fine, but there will be a chick in there, so if you wanted to eat it like an egg, you might end up closer to balut than you want / expect.
- yesfitz 1y agoFrom the article that you're commenting on: "There are multiple approaches to in-ovo sexing. One of the most prominent approaches uses advanced imaging to detect subtle optical differences between male and female embryos." "Another widely adopted technique involves taking a small fluid sample from inside the egg to test for sex-specific hormones or genetic markers. Kipster’s eggs, launching later this year, will use a technology of this class employing PCR analysis to detect the sex chromosome, developed by the company Respeggt."
- Mistletoe 1y ago> What are the alternatives? We are pleased to see that research is being carried out to look into ways of sexing chicks at an early stage, whilst still in the egg. These new technologies aim to do the sexing and disposal before the embryo can feel pain, which happens at around seven days. We are following these developments with interest. https://www.rspcaassured.org.uk/farmed-animal-welfare/egg-laying-hens/what-is-chick-maceration/ https://www.rspcaassured.org.uk/farmed-animal-welfare/egg-la...
- XorNot 1y agoI wonder what holds back developing a chicken which only produces female eggs. Feels like the volume should mean we're not experimentally limited in the technology, and the savings are obvious. Like a CRISPR system which turns off the male chromosomes in roosters or something.
- wetpaws 1y ago[dead]
- nashashmi 1y agoI am disturbed to find unwanted male chicks get “culled” because there is no market value for them in egg production. And there is no need for them in meat production. This tech is able to select the female eggs only for hatching and redirect the male eggs for egging. The result is we have more eggs for people. And less waste of resources. Win win. Also a win for PETA. Something like this should be adopted en masse for market value reasons.
- yesfitz 1y agoThe eggs that humans consume are unfertilized. The eggs containing males are fertilized and will not be sold in stores. They will be macerated while they're still in the egg instead of after hatching. Not much of a moral victory for anyone, especially considering that the hens that get to live don't have good lives.
- nashashmi 1y agoHad to look this up: https://learnpoultry.com/fertilized-vs-unfertilized-chicken-eggs/#:~:text=The%20eggs%20available%20in%20stores%20are%20either%20%EE%80%80fertile%EE%80%81 https://learnpoultry.com/fertilized-vs-unfertilized-chicken-... Apparently, many of the eggs sold in stores are infertile. But fertile eggs can still be eaten. The process of storing them away is a little bit more cumbersome because they go bad if they are not eaten fresh.
- noah_buddy 1y agoThis is the sort of issue that I think exposes a very interesting paradox in the average person. People are worried about seemingly extraordinary cruelty perpetrated against a cute animal (maceration of young chicks) but basically accept regular, banal cruelty against typical farm animals (the practice of eating farming and eating meat and eggs). I personally think the cause is at least on balance positive morally for any given male chick, but it’s not so clear to me that it’s moral if this scales to the point that the industry may raise more female chickens to lay eggs with less resources/comfort/etc.
- aaronbaugher 1y agoI think the factory egg industry has already stripped the resources/comfort down as far as possible, so I don't see how this could make that any worse. I'm normally resistant to claims that a new technology is going to make an unpleasant situation better, but in this case, I'm sympathetic. I'd rather get rid of the egg factories and have eggs raised the way my grandma did (and I still do). But that's not going to happen as long as people live in large cities. So if there's a way to identify the male eggs so they can be used as food before the chicks start to develop, rather than letting them hatch and then grinding up living, breathing birds, I'd have to say that's an improvement.