5 ms·
As an anesthesiologist I routinely gave anesthesia to patients (usually children) undergoing MRIs over a 38-year career. I never had anxiety in my daily practi
by bookofjoe 1y ago
As an anesthesiologist I routinely gave anesthesia to patients (usually children) undergoing MRIs over a 38-year career.
I never had anxiety in my daily practice in the OR but anesthesia in the MRI suite ALWAYS provoked anxiety because:
1. I had to anesthetize the patient in the sub-basement, two floors below the main OR — where there were always other anesthesiologists able to help in an emergency. In the MRI suite, no one could hear my silent screams if I got in trouble nor were there knowledgeable extra hands to, for example, squeeze the breathing bag if I needed to prepare for an emergency intubation.
2. Once the patient was anesthetized and the heavy door to the MRI machine room was closed and locked, I could only monitor my unconscious patient through a darkened heavy glass window. Sure, I had monitors for EKG and oxygen saturation outside the MRI room, near the control board where technicians operated the machine, but the automatic blood pressure cuff inflator dial on the anesthesia machine was inside the room and hard to see through the dark glass.
3. It was my good fortune to never have had an emergency in the MRI suite, but events such as that reported above in the OP happened from time to time in hospitals throughout the U.S. and were occasionally reported in the anesthesia literature with the expected cautionary advice. Many more events occurred than were reported.
- adastra22 1y agoI don't mean this in a bad way, and I am genuinely curious: what is an anesthesiologist doing on HN?
- xeonmc 1y ago[flagged]
- magicalhippo 1y agoMaybe he's a midnight hacker? I work as a programmer, but it was and still is my hobby. And I could have ended up in a different line of work. In which case I'd most likely still be here but with a different day job experience.
- fouc 1y agoHN users cover a broad spectrum of people, computer developers are just a subset.
- 0x7cfe 1y agoJust in case, Con Kolivas, a prominent contributor to the Linux kernel, is also an active and practicing anesthesiologist. People are awesome. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Con_Kolivas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Con_Kolivas
- foo-bar-bat 1y agoI think the sorting hat outcomes for technical polymaths and driven entrepreneurs is the hat is sometimes quantum, and can rightfully put you into any or multiple houses at Hogwarts? Like Harry. Last time I had a major surgery the anesthesiologist at Stanford was also simultaneously a full time employee of Apple. (At the time we were competitors; we figured out during surgical prep that we had friends/colleagues in common.) Similarly, while working at another FAANG company, one of my colleagues was simultaneously a practicing MD (PCP) at Stanford. He later left both jobs, to start own biz. At one point he referred me to another Stanford doc who was simultaneously the founder of a diagnostic-tech startup, which sadly has since fizzled. Lastly, I know a practicing anesthesiologist married to a serial entrepreneur who's built and sold stuff you've heard of. They or some of their hundreds of employees may be here, dunno. Won't out them.
- zabzonk 1y agoWhy darkened glass?
- nness 1y agoFrom a cursory search, seems like 1. Privacy, and 2. RF shielding of equipment behind the glass and from influencing the MRI scan itself.
- bookofjoe 1y agoPrivacy is irrelevant: the MRI suite is so remote from the rest of the hospital that no one goes there who isn't supposed to be there.
- Luc 1y agoIt's not darkened on purpose, but as a result of containing electromagnetic radiation shielding.
- queuebert 1y agoThe EM shielding is simply a wire mesh, not tint. The glass doesn't have to be darkened, and probably wasn't, but often the room is darkened to make the scan more comfortable and calming. Also, in my experience the room doesn't have many lights, and the patient is inside the bore, making them hard to see.
- milano89 1y ago>I routinely gave anesthesia to patients benzodiazepines?
- bookofjoe 1y agoGeneral anesthesia; the nurse attending the patient was qualified to administer benzodiazepines.
- hermitcrab 1y ago>In the MRI suite, no one could hear my silent screams I understand it is caused the 'donut of death' for that reason.
- rscho 1y agoThe MRI+anesthesia problem has recently got much worse, since we're now seeing MRI hybrid ORs pop up. Compounded with the 'lean management' principles en vogue in hospitals, this is a disaster waiting to happen. Personnel is often affected to multiple ORs, including standard and hybrid sites.
- seanicus 1y agoThanks for the insight. re:#3 how do mistakes not get reported? Is it because this incident resulted in a police report and is unusual in this context?
- rscho 1y agoThis time it killed someone. Usually, it's just a bed or a respirator that ends up stuck in the ring.
- Wistar 1y agoBack in 2001 a 6-year-old boy undergoing an MRI was killed when an unsecured oxygen tank was pulled in to the machine. https://www.psqh.com/analysis/mri-safety-10-years-later/ https://www.psqh.com/analysis/mri-safety-10-years-later/
- bookofjoe 1y agoDeaths in the OR like cardiac arrests, fatal hemorrhage from burst aneurysms, etc. are always reported within the hospital. Whether others outside learn about such things is often a matter of persistent family and relatives demanding to see the actual death report and contemporaneous notes. Fatal mistakes usually stay within hospital departments and are discussed at length in regular confidential Morbidity and Mortality conferences.
- vonneumannstan 1y ago>1. I had to anesthetize the patient in the sub-basement, two floors below the main OR — where there were always other anesthesiologists able to help in an emergency. In the MRI suite, no one could hear my silent screams if I got in trouble nor were there knowledgeable extra hands to, for example, squeeze the breathing bag if I needed to prepare for an emergency intubation. You are allowed to put patients under general with no one else present? That doesn't seem like it should be possible
- rscho 1y agoThere's always someone else. But the radiologist might not be at his/her most efficient doing anesthesia & resuscitation...
- bookofjoe 1y agoNo — there is NOT always someone else. And if others present are nurses, aides, radiologists, etc., they are generally of zero help in a crunch.
- fluidcruft 1y agoPretty sure that at the very least you are not operating the scanner. And the scanner generally nowadays must operate under the plus one staffing model (one certified technologist per scanner plus at least one additional level 2 MRI safety trained staff in the immediate vicinity). So no, you are not "alone".
- rscho 1y agoHe said he's been doing that for a long time. Plenty of time for stuff to happen, and security guidelines were not always as they are now.
- fluidcruft 1y agoAn anesthesiologist was never operating an MRI scanner at any point in history.
- lostlogin 1y ago> Once the patient was anesthetized and the heavy door to the MRI machine room was closed and locked, I could only monitor my unconscious patient through a darkened heavy glass window. Why was the door locked?
- azalemeth 1y agoWe have ear defenders and staff inside and monitoring visible in both locations -- anaesthetic machine in the control room. There's not much you can safely do in the fringe field but you can do CPR and rapidly get someone out of the room (and before my spinal injury I used to practice both of those regularly, particularly when part of a team scanning patients with inotropes)
- fragmede 1y agoSo no one can accidentally walk into the room while wearing metal while it is on, to prevent injuries like the post we're commenting on, from happening.
- lostlogin 1y agoThe door shouldn’t be locked when staff are present. It certainly shouldn’t with people inside. I work in MRI.
- fluidcruft 1y agoNo, that's wrong. The locks are because the magnet is always on but the scanner is not always staffed. The scanner door is never locked when the scanner is staffed or a patient is inside.
- fragmede 1y agointeresting!
- fluidcruft 1y agoThere's some sort of latching mechanism to seal the faraday cage. Sometimes it's a latch, sometimes it's pneumatic or a bladder that inflates. The doors can also lock (I'm pretty sure they are required to be locked when qualified personnel are not present) but usually they are not locked when the scanner is staffed and in use.
- thaumasiotes 1y agoWhy is anyone getting general anesthesia for an MRI? It's a non-invasive procedure.
- Xiol32 1y agoTo add to the sibling comment, being stuck in a small, incredibly loud tube usually pinned under some receiver isn't great for claustrophobic patients either.
- BuildTheRobots 1y agoA lot of people get panic attacks / claustrophobia and are incapable of getting in or staying still for a scan. I have a lot of sympathy. I'm pretty good in confined spaces usually, but even after multiple MRIs it's still a surprisingly stressful experience. The buildup and safety questions make the pre-experience worrying. The aperture is surprisingly small. Depending on the scan, part of you might be caged in place, and it's extremely noisy and you're aware of a lot of mass and power spinning very close to your face. Also, some of the radiologists don't help. It's not deliberate, but they're entirely desensitised to the experience (and often haven't actually gone through it themselves; which again seems crazy considering the lack of radiation). My last scan was of my lower back, but they were already set up (from the previous scan) to feed me in head first rather than feet first. From their point of view it saves a bit of faffing with the software and moving the pillow to the other end. From a patients point of view it makes all the difference in the world; it's a very different psychological experience having your legs inside with your head free, vs being stuck head first in something and having it whizz past next to your head. I've had a goodly (read unhealthy) number of CT and MRI scans and I'm bright enough to understand which one is significantly more detrimental to my long term health. I'm also aware that on a subconscious almost cellular level, it's the benign one that absolutely terrifies me every time...
- magicalhippo 1y agoMy dad's cancer spread to the bones in the spine and rib cage. He told me it was incredibly challenging and exhausting to stay still during scans as it just hurt so bad. Several times they had to redo scans as he moved. I can certainly imagine there are many similar scenarios where it's just not possible for a patient to be completely still, or it's better for them to avoid excessive rescans.