6 ms·
> Islam gets called out more often because it does more damage. This is shortsighted. I personally think all religious belief is harmful, but in the sweep of h
by lutusp 14y ago
> Islam gets called out more often because it does more damage.
This is shortsighted. I personally think all religious belief is harmful, but in the sweep of history, Islam has a record of much more tolerance than Christianity, to name just one other religion.
Over long periods of time, Islamic cities and countries were much more tolerant of other religions than Christian cities and countries. Christianity has, and deserves, a reputation for being utterly intolerant of other religions.
This is not to excuse the excesses of Islam, when and where they took place, and I personally think the world would be a better place without religion. But it's simply inaccurate to describe Islam as doing more damage from a historical perspective.
I speak as someone who tried to open a Planned Parenthood clinic in a rural area (where it was really needed), was threatened with death more often than I care to remember, and who saw clinics and doctor's offices set on fire with depressing regularity. But this can't compare to the Inquisition, a time when Christianity displayed its true colors.
- yohui 14y agolmm is clearly thinking of the current situation, not historical score-keeping. The past can be a wonderful source of inspiration, but we cannot parcel out criticism and praise now based on events far past living memory.
- lutusp 14y ago> The past can be a wonderful source of inspiration, but we cannot parcel out criticism and praise now based on events far past living memory. And those who fail to understand the lessons of history are doomed to relive them.
- rjknight 14y agoI don't think there's a philosophical framework within which we can really assess which of two world religions is "more harmful". It sounds to me like you're picking the most salient examples to you personally, and choosing to generalise from them. The character of a religion is not merely shaped by the principles of the religion but by the society in which that religion is present. The Islam of early medieval Spain is different to the Islam of 19th century Saudi Arabia, which is in turn different to the Islam of 17th century India or 21st century Sudan. The Christianity of the Inquisition is different to the Christianity of William Wilberforce, which in turn differs from the Christianity of Constantine and so on. In reality, we can only really judge people by their actions, rather than their professed religion. Religion of any kind is no excuse for bad behaviour, nor should a person's religion detract from the good that they do.
- berntb 14y agoDawkins' main problem with your criticism of Christianity would probably be that it is too short... As other comments have noted, he has criticized Christianity more than Islam. For a less well known counter example, this is from a not so extreme Muslim country (a few friends are from Bangladesh, so I read up a bit). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vested_Property_Act_%28Bangladesh%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vested_Property_Act_%28Banglade... >> It is officially estimated that about 75% of all Hindu lands in Bangladesh have been seized by using this act Edit: I have to ask -- why do left wing people have much less problems with the quite common Muslim antisemitism, than with Nazi antisemitism? Most of the arguments (except for the religious ones) and sources were copied from the nazis. It is even written in official(!) media in the Muslim world.
- lutusp 14y ago> why do left wing people have much less problems with the quite common Muslim antisemitism, than with Nazi antisemitism? I think you may be a bit confused. Muslims living in the Middle East aren't antiSemitic (unless they hate themselves). They may or may not be anti-Israeli, but it's a little simplistic to describe them as antiSemitic, since the're in large part Semitic themselves. Nazis were really antiSemitic in the classic sense (against Jews). This is a difficult label to apply to people who are racially nearly identical to the Semites in Israel. All I am saying is the problems of the Middle East don't fit into simple categories. > As other comments have noted, he has criticized Christianity more than Islam. Yes -- probably more to avoid what befell Salman Rushdie than any deeper goal.
- berntb 14y ago>>Muslims living in the Middle East aren't antiSemitic (unless they hate themselves). The word "antisemite" was created by an antisemite for just that specific meaning. See "gay" and other words that change their meaning. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#Etymology_and_usage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#Etymology_and_usag... This discuss the prevalent antisemitism in the Arab world (check the rest of the Muslim world on Wikipedia yourself) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_Arab_world http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_the_Arab_world Edit: I have seen others dismiss racist hatred with an attempt at linguistics, but happily seldom on HN. Where do you guys pick up this kind of "argument"? Seriously, checking your links you're obviously smarter and more educated than most people I've ever met.
- yannickt 14y agoChristianity has a long and strong track record of intolerance, but I don't think it can be disputed that Islam does much more damage today. One out of three (!) British Muslims aged 16 to 24 believe that Muslim apostates should be executed [1]. In many Islamic countries, "crimes" like apostasy, adultery, or homosexuality are punishable by stoning or death, and such punishment is state sanctioned. This level of intolerance was commonplace in Christianity in the past, but it is virtually unheard of in predominantly Christian countries today. [1] http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Islam_and_Apostasy#Helpful_Hints_for_ex-Muslims http://wikiislam.net/wiki/Islam_and_Apostasy#Helpful_Hints_f...
- kleim 14y ago"Islamic cities and countries were much more tolerant of other religions than Christian cities and countries" Of course. You were safe and treated as nearly equal to other citizens as long as you paid a tax for your "protection": the Dhimmi.
- batista 14y agoWhich is very advanced for the times, and even for today.