3 ms·
I'm not taking a moral perspective on it, I am saying cause->effect. If people run out of options in a failing, suboptimal system (which I'm unsure you can say
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
I'm not taking a moral perspective on it, I am saying cause->effect. If people run out of options in a failing, suboptimal system (which I'm unsure you can say the US healthcare system is anything but, based on the evidence), they will resort to the options that remain for recourse.
- tptacek 1y agoThe framing smuggles in a moral perspective. You have the cause wrong; the shooting wasn't a policy intervention, except as to how America handles mental health and gun ownership.
- const_cast 1y agoIt was a policy intervention in the sense that Americans have no choice in policy. Your healthcare is entirely decided by people who are not your doctors. Every medicine you take, how long you go to the doctor, what surgeries you can get - your insurer unilaterally decides this. Not your doctor. There's no voting system or merit system. You can't just simply find a better doctor - because your doctor is an empty vessel, they make no decisions. You have, legitimately, zero recourse. Shooting someone is then very rational. We have made that one of the only choices, period. The insurance companies have all but guaranteed this outcome.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoExactly this.
- tptacek 1y agoYeah, no. You're making exactly the argument I claimed you were making, and it's false.