4 ms·
If woman really are getting paid less for the same work as men wouldn't employers do the arbitrage of hiring women instead of men?
by PaulHoule 1y ago
If woman really are getting paid less for the same work as men wouldn't employers do the arbitrage of hiring women instead of men?
- betaby 1y agohttps://www.aol.com/gen-z-gender-pay-gap-050000387.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9vbGQucmVkZGl0LmNvbS9yL0Vjb25vbWljcy9jb21tZW50cy8xbDRyZ3llL3RoZV9nZW5fel9nZW5kZXJfcGF5X2dhcF9oYXNfcmV2ZXJzZWRfd2l0aF95b3VuZy8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAKKEulQQ3GRxSaYCvCG9qjgWZYl48QqleQmcCokeMntN9thH8BzqHYKFXoAte8zw7z3Itd1P_03BQ_6DYRyLT6OO7yOrmNjQqTDq9CWwI9vxc-qq6FfneWh1W9uSMu11KNMhSOCiOVD4y-GbKh9qaXhDWop2c062ztJlVlNC1UWn https://www.aol.com/gen-z-gender-pay-gap-050000387.html?gucc...
- yieldcrv 1y agoWe all noticed it was just impoverished and uneducated young women blaming their incompetency on the wage gap and patriarchal influences, while really all other women in their age range had closed it to the extent that they are even making up for the women that drag the wages down Its pretty impressive overall, but extremely funny watching some women be left behind and not even know it
- williamdclt 1y ago"We all noticed" except the people gathering actual data of course. https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/earningsandworkinghours/bulletins/genderpaygapintheuk/2024 https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwor... shows disparities in skilled trades: in fact _more_ disparity in skilled trades. For example 15% gap for developers. But I'm glad you "noticed" something different, problem solved then. > extremely funny Regardless of the reality of the gender pay gap, this is a disgusting attitude.
- yieldcrv 1y agoI responded to an article about the 18-24 age range, your source is not segmented that way. let me know when you have counterpoints to that The amusement comes from what the uneducated women wind up doing and how they rationalize it. Mansplaining is out, laughter is in.
- mdorazio 1y agoIn general, women get paid the same as men, within the error of measurement, and have for many years. The trope of women making less than men comes from an apples to oranges comparison. Women choose less lucrative careers, leave the workforce more often to care for children, and care more about work-life balance. The result is that on average across the workforce, women make less. But if you look at an individual career track and control for hours worked/overtime, years of experience, etc. it’s generally quite even. In fact, there’s a recent trend of young women making more than their male counterparts, as per the link in this thread.
- yieldcrv 1y agoAdditionally, many women are not mimicking their competition in how the career ladder is approached. There is a fear of coming across as too assertive within the organization she is already employed in. What’s understated is that plenty of men come across as too cocky too and get passed up within the organization and at other organizations. But some men, with the societal incentive to get ahead, continues aiming higher at other organizations with the same playbook, and enough of them find the organization that is indexing for that attitude. I dont have a way to quantify this behavior by gender, I frequently see women not considering it though, overindexed on getting the promotion in the org and navigating that. The competition doesn’t care about their perception at the place they are already employed, and are aiming on getting offers all the time for leverage.
- supriyo-biswas 1y ago> But some men, with the societal incentive to get ahead, continues aiming higher at other organizations with the same playbook, and enough of them find the organization that is indexing for that attitude. At a previous employer, I had skip levels who apparently only made disparaging statements in public settings (and only in public settings, they’d dismiss it lightly if you tried to discuss said feedback in private settings) involving their indirect reports; this was their apparent way of ruling with an iron fist so that they come across as effective managers and have more projects directed towards them by the leadership. Even as a man, it was everything I never wanted to become; I can completely see why women, who generally pursue (or at least try to maintain the impression of) collaborative relationships often want to do nothing with it.
- bigstrat2003 1y agoYes, which is why that theory is very unlikely to be true. Even if employers were such committed sexists that they only employed men to their detriment, they would eventually get outcompeted by less sexist competitors who hired a cheaper (yet just as effective) workforce.
- delusional 1y agoI like contextualizing that question using a tool Matt Levine wrote about to understand the problem of doing fundamental analysis for a short sale. Winning a short position requires two things. The obvious one is that it requires something to be overvalued. If we posit that women are paid less, which is what your argument does, we have covered the first condition. The second thing required is a way for the market to become aware of this discrepancy. That would be the missing piece. Companies/Managers/Founders are the ones valuing the work. If they value the work less when a woman does it, then something has to change that valuation. It won't correct by itself.
- meroes 1y agoYoung women are also getting paid more than young men
- antithesizer 1y agoApparently they have been
- jabjq 1y agoHave you ever worked in a place full of women?