4 ms·
So increase taxes and increase supply until it meets demand. You can still do this while prohibiting private ownership of medical systems and their underlying r
by toomuchtodo 1y ago
So increase taxes and increase supply until it meets demand. You can still do this while prohibiting private ownership of medical systems and their underlying real estate.
https://www.axios.com/2025/03/17/private-equity-health-care-state-legislation https://www.axios.com/2025/03/17/private-equity-health-care-...
- tptacek 1y agoEasy to say, very difficult to do. Public funding and the single-payer portion of the US health care system is responsible for the scarcity of doctors --- Medicare controls residency slots, and deliberately restricts them to prevent an oversupply of doctors. Medical systems around the world in every configuration have these problems in one form or another.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoCertainly, I expect more of the UHC CEO’s outcome until the system moves towards success versus failure as long as the US for profit machine continues to squeeze the population for healthcare while public funding declines in the near term. “We’ve tried nothing and we’re all out of options.” seems to be the equilibrium we keep arriving at, despite it being unsustainable. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZhCYisIQB8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZhCYisIQB8
- tptacek 1y agoI'm really not interested in attempts to mascotize the mentally ill guy who pointlessly shot someone to death on the street in Manhattan.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI'm not taking a moral perspective on it, I am saying cause->effect. If people run out of options in a failing, suboptimal system (which I'm unsure you can say the US healthcare system is anything but, based on the evidence), they will resort to the options that remain for recourse.
- tptacek 1y agoThe framing smuggles in a moral perspective. You have the cause wrong; the shooting wasn't a policy intervention, except as to how America handles mental health and gun ownership.
- const_cast 1y agoIt was a policy intervention in the sense that Americans have no choice in policy. Your healthcare is entirely decided by people who are not your doctors. Every medicine you take, how long you go to the doctor, what surgeries you can get - your insurer unilaterally decides this. Not your doctor. There's no voting system or merit system. You can't just simply find a better doctor - because your doctor is an empty vessel, they make no decisions. You have, legitimately, zero recourse. Shooting someone is then very rational. We have made that one of the only choices, period. The insurance companies have all but guaranteed this outcome.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoExactly this.
- tptacek 1y agoYeah, no. You're making exactly the argument I claimed you were making, and it's false.
- mindslight 1y ago... thus giving the whole system the constraints of public funding and single-payer, so that scarcity isn't something to be feared - we're already suffering it. But furthermore, that scarcity is then leveraged by less regulated market actors to constrain competition and jack up prices, giving us the worst of both worlds. A fully public single payer system would mean bureaucrats would produce a report concluding that more doctors are needed to keep costs from spiraling, and the number of residency slots would be increased. A more freer market would mean hospitals/doctors were paying for all of their own residency slots and they'd up the number through price signals. Instead, we have neither feedback mechanism.
- tptacek 1y agoWe already have exactly that system: Medicare (and its bureaucrats) determine how many doctors we need, by setting the number of residency slots. The system that makes this calculation is public, single-payer, and state-driven, and it produces the outcome you experience in American health care.
- mindslight 1y agoYes, I agreed with your point and then kept going. If you're referring to my second paragraph - the difference is that the medicare part of the system does not have to fully contend with the resulting cost from doctor shortages as it sets its own prices below market rate. The larger overall point is that system is only responsible for half of what we experience with American health care - the shortage part. But then we don't even get the benefits of the price controls until we reach Medicare age.
- tptacek 1y agoMedicare should fund drastically more residency slots. But that aside, I think Medicare is a pretty slick compromise between what's challenging about state-funded health care and private market health care: at the lifetime inflection point where people's medical costs drastically increase, publicly-funded single-payer kicks in; before that, people with (actuarially) far lower costs get the benefits of private market care. A thriving private market is created that provides benefits even to the publicly-funded care. Obviously, the system has an enormous problem: it costs too much, because medical providers operate cartels that jack prices up.