2 ms·
Anecdotally, I know several people who have tried mushrooms and/or ayahuasca for depression in recent years and their results are nothing like the glowing Inter
by Aurornis 1y ago
Anecdotally, I know several people who have tried mushrooms and/or ayahuasca for depression in recent years and their results are nothing like the glowing Internet reports.
The worst case is a friend who became disconnected from reality for a very long time. Went from atheistic to believing in mystical ideas. He thought he was able to see and sense things that we could not, like auras and secret messages. He was getting better last time we checked but he’s hard to get in contact with now. No prior hints of psychosis or family history, just a psychedelic induced mental illness.
The other anecdotes were not as dramatic, but also not as positive or free of side effects as studies like this one would make you think. Multiple stories of extended periods of derealization or anxiety attacks that started after the trip. There are similar comments here throughout this comment section.
There was a time when sharing these negative stories was met with disbelief and downvotes. I think as it’s becoming more common people are realizing that the interaction between psychedelics and depression isn’t as great as it seemed for a few years when they were virtually being promoted by podcasters and social media influencers as a novel cure for depression.
- hattmall 1y agoPsychedelics are basically like shock therapy. The whole ketamine thing though is even crazier at least with psychedelics there is a forced introspection and very little addictive nature.
- chuckadams 1y agoI think a lot of the negative reception to negative anecdotes were because they were often in the context of legalization. "I know someone who went crazy after trying $foo so we should still lock people into iron cages just for the crime of possessing it." Debate tends to get polarized when doors are being kicked down. Academic studies that are disconnected from culture wars don't tend to provoke such responses, probably because they don't tend to reach the general public in the first place.
- landl0rd 1y agoWhich is a terrible strategy actually. People did the same with marijuana. “Dude it’s medicine lol. Dude it can’t possibly contribute to schizophrenia. Dude weed lmao.” All this does is create a credible argument that the pro legalization crowd are objectively lying to people and therefore untrustworthy.
- yieldcrv 1y agoIts natural! therefore God made it for us to consume braaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh just ignore things like cyanide, and mercury
- chuckadams 1y agoWhen it comes to truthful arguments, the anti-legalization crowd historically hasn't stood on very firm ground either. I think we can agree that perhaps with the heat dialed down a bit, we're allowed to have grown-up conversations now.
- Aurornis 1y ago> because they were often in the context of legalization. "I know someone who went crazy after trying $foo so we should still lock people into iron cages just for the crime of possessing it." I think that’s what people thought when reading negative anecdotes, but I definitely didn’t see a lot of suggestions that we lock people up. The same thing happened for marijuana: Any mention of negative effects would bring downvotes, scorn, and disbelief pre-legalization. Then once it was legal it became acceptable to say that marijuana wasn’t a panacea and using a lot of it was actually a problem. Before this change, it was common to read highly upvoted anecdotes here and on Reddit claiming everything from medicinal properties to fixing depression to improving driving skills (an actual claim I saw here and on Reddit multiple times). Now it’s widely acceptable that frequent marijuana use is not good for mental health and wellbeing, but that was once a thing you could not say on the internet.
- chuckadams 1y ago> definitely didn’t see a lot of suggestions that we lock people up. Nobody had to suggest that, it was the law of the land already. Hyperbolic argument is hyperbolic ("iron cages" was a bit of a tip-off) but consequences short of imprisonment were typically some other state-run means of destroying one's career, family, and/or life. Pointing out that this isn't a good thing and isn't actually working somehow made you into The Enemy Of Decency. And while there's still lots of Drug Warriors out there who still think that way, I'm encouraged at the increasing avenues for actually productive discussion. Seems to be the one politically-charged topic that isn't getting more toxic these days.
- Levitz 1y agoI'm sure it's nothing like a panacea, but I've lost count of the times in which getting some context behind a report of a bad experience shows recklessness or just plain old bad decisions. It also works the other way around, people even talk about how years of therapy didn't help but psilocybin did, and few seem to consider that maybe it was a combination of both? Perhaps all of that therapy that "didn't help" set the stage for something else. General problem with anecdata I guess.
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoI don't know if people have forgotten all the lessons from the 60s, but set and setting are still extremely important for what kind of experience you are going to have.
- pegasus 1y agoThat's why use should be done in a controlled setting, with an experienced guide (ideally a therapist).