4 ms·

I've always ignored instructions that say to only use that product's USB cord (things like my kitchen scale and water flossed) and have never had an issue. Soun

by jjice 1y ago

I've always ignored instructions that say to only use that product's USB cord (things like my kitchen scale and water flossed) and have never had an issue. Sounds like I've just gotten lucky though, based on your experience. I was under the impression that the USB protocol just fell back to 1a 5v when power negotiation was unsure. What kinds of devices?

Gigachad 1y ago
USB-C is 0v by default and you have to signal to get anything at all. A lot of junky devices are non compliant and aren’t set up to signal 5v so they get 0 when plugged in to a C-C cable.
- orbital-decay 1y ago
  How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with?
  - mrheosuper 1y ago
    using passive component
  - ianburrell 1y ago
    With resistors on the CC pins. In particular, there is resistor value that indicates legacy USB charging. This is in the USB-A to USB-C adapters and cables. The manufacturers cheaped out in not including the right resistors.
    - mikepurvis 1y ago
      I would also guess that some of these cases are designs that were adapted from previous USB mini- or micro-b configurations. Like an intern got the assignment, switched the connector, and wiped hands on pants, not realizing that an electrical change was required as well. And if you spin the new board and it works with the A->C cable sitting on your desk, then what could possibly be different about plugging it into a C<->C cable, right?
  - hulitu 1y ago
    > How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with? The spec was written by a SW engineer, this explains some things. /s
  - mystifyingpoi 1y ago
    This is a real issue. I have 2 powerbanks that cannot be charged by USB-C port when at 0%. The signaling circuitry simply doesn't work. No idea who designed this. It is silly beyond belief. I have to charge it with normal 5V A-to-C cable for 30 seconds, then unplug, then all the PD stuff will start working and I can fastcharge it with USB-C port again. I'm screwed without A-to-C cable.
    - Yokolos 1y ago
      Holy shit. This explains why my Anbernic 406v is so weird. If I drain the battery too much, it won't let me charge with anything except with a normal 5v USB A to C cable and the USB-C cable that I use to charge it while it's on does nothing. It makes so much sense now.
      - Kirby64 1y ago
        This (and the GP) are because your device supports some sort of fast charge USB-PD negotiation, but does not support what is known as “dead battery mode”. Basically, dead battery mode enables those pull down resistors by default (when no power is applied) so you can get 5V to the system, where eventually it would charge up and the chip that can do PD negotiation will be powered. Usually this is done simply by having the negotiation chip default to pull down resistors internally when unpowered.
        mystifyingpoi 1y ago
        Thanks, that solution sounds decent. Hope more manufacturers do it, seems I got unlucky.
  - cesarb 1y ago
    > How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with? Through a pair of resistors. The unpowered device connects each of the two CC pins to the ground pin through a separate resistor of a specific value. The cable connects one of these CC pins to the corresponding pin on the other end of the cable (the second pin on each side is used to power circuitry within the cable itself, if it's a higher-spec cable). On the host side, each of the two CC pins is connected to the power supply through a separate resistor of another specific value. When you plug all this together, you have the host power supply connected to ground through a pair of resistors, which is a simple voltage divider. When the host detects the resulting voltage on one of the CC pins, it knows there's a device on the other end which is not providing power, and it can connect the main power pins of the connector to its power supply.
- jjice 1y ago
  Ah that actually makes a lot more sense to start at 0. I appreciate the info.
lxgr 1y ago
USB-C hosts and power adapters are only allowed to provide 5V if they can sense a downstream device (either via a network of resistors or via explicit PD negotiation). Out-of-spec USB-C devices sometimes skip that, and out-of-spec USB-C chargers often (somewhat dangerously) always supply 5V, so the two mistakes sort of cancel out.
ziml77 1y ago
Careful. Some of these devices may not be USB-C at all but rather just using the port. If the device calls it USB then it's probably fine to use any cable, but if you just see "Type C", it's safest to assume they don't have it wired up according to any USB standard.

by jjice 1y ago

Gigachad 1y ago

USB-C is 0v by default and you have to signal to get anything at all. A lot of junky devices are non compliant and aren’t set up to signal 5v so they get 0 when plugged in to a C-C cable.

orbital-decay 1y ago
How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with?
- mrheosuper 1y ago
  using passive component
- ianburrell 1y ago
  With resistors on the CC pins. In particular, there is resistor value that indicates legacy USB charging. This is in the USB-A to USB-C adapters and cables. The manufacturers cheaped out in not including the right resistors.
  - mikepurvis 1y ago
    I would also guess that some of these cases are designs that were adapted from previous USB mini- or micro-b configurations. Like an intern got the assignment, switched the connector, and wiped hands on pants, not realizing that an electrical change was required as well. And if you spin the new board and it works with the A->C cable sitting on your desk, then what could possibly be different about plugging it into a C<->C cable, right?
- hulitu 1y ago
  > How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with? The spec was written by a SW engineer, this explains some things. /s
- mystifyingpoi 1y ago
  This is a real issue. I have 2 powerbanks that cannot be charged by USB-C port when at 0%. The signaling circuitry simply doesn't work. No idea who designed this. It is silly beyond belief. I have to charge it with normal 5V A-to-C cable for 30 seconds, then unplug, then all the PD stuff will start working and I can fastcharge it with USB-C port again. I'm screwed without A-to-C cable.
  - Yokolos 1y ago
    Holy shit. This explains why my Anbernic 406v is so weird. If I drain the battery too much, it won't let me charge with anything except with a normal 5v USB A to C cable and the USB-C cable that I use to charge it while it's on does nothing. It makes so much sense now.
    - Kirby64 1y ago
      This (and the GP) are because your device supports some sort of fast charge USB-PD negotiation, but does not support what is known as “dead battery mode”. Basically, dead battery mode enables those pull down resistors by default (when no power is applied) so you can get 5V to the system, where eventually it would charge up and the chip that can do PD negotiation will be powered. Usually this is done simply by having the negotiation chip default to pull down resistors internally when unpowered.
      - mystifyingpoi 1y ago
        Thanks, that solution sounds decent. Hope more manufacturers do it, seems I got unlucky.
- cesarb 1y ago
  > How does it negotiate with a host-powered device if it's unpowered to begin with? Through a pair of resistors. The unpowered device connects each of the two CC pins to the ground pin through a separate resistor of a specific value. The cable connects one of these CC pins to the corresponding pin on the other end of the cable (the second pin on each side is used to power circuitry within the cable itself, if it's a higher-spec cable). On the host side, each of the two CC pins is connected to the power supply through a separate resistor of another specific value. When you plug all this together, you have the host power supply connected to ground through a pair of resistors, which is a simple voltage divider. When the host detects the resulting voltage on one of the CC pins, it knows there's a device on the other end which is not providing power, and it can connect the main power pins of the connector to its power supply.
jjice 1y ago
Ah that actually makes a lot more sense to start at 0. I appreciate the info.

lxgr 1y ago

USB-C hosts and power adapters are only allowed to provide 5V if they can sense a downstream device (either via a network of resistors or via explicit PD negotiation). Out-of-spec USB-C devices sometimes skip that, and out-of-spec USB-C chargers often (somewhat dangerously) always supply 5V, so the two mistakes sort of cancel out.

ziml77 1y ago

Careful. Some of these devices may not be USB-C at all but rather just using the port. If the device calls it USB then it's probably fine to use any cable, but if you just see "Type C", it's safest to assume they don't have it wired up according to any USB standard.