4 ms·
Basically humans are the greatest long distance runners the planet has ever known. Sorry, you're wrong, and that book is not a particularly accurate reference.
by btilly 14y ago
Basically humans are the greatest long distance runners the planet has ever known.
Sorry, you're wrong, and that book is not a particularly accurate reference. Read http://www.sbrunning.org/Reviews/BookWhyWeRun.htm http://www.sbrunning.org/Reviews/BookWhyWeRun.htm for some sanity on this.
As an example of a better long-distance runner, there was a kangaroo which was observed in the wild, to have travelled 200 miles in 10 hours. Since it probably did not go in a straight line, it likely travelled farther.
That's almost 8x the distance of a marathon, at around 50% faster than the absolute best human marathon time, all done over wild terrain.
- gnaritas 14y agoKangaroos don't run. :)
- btilly 14y agoBut ostriches do. Both ostriches and a pronghorn antelope are capable of running a marathon in about 45 minutes. I don't know how much farther they can keep going, but at that distance we're totally outclassed by them. Sled dogs in the ididitrod regularly go 15 mph for 6 hours. That's faster than a human does a marathon, for several times the distance, while dragging a heavy object behind them. We're designed for running long distances, and do very well at it for a primate. But we are very, very far from being champions at it.
- ohashi 14y agoWould that be the cooling factor, mentioned in the article, at play?
- btilly 14y agoCooling is definitely not a problem for sled dogs running in the snow. (Surviving blizzards is a different story.) But the kangaroo was traveling in an environment that is hotter than humans are OK running in. Camels are another good runner, in camel races they regularly maintain speeds comparable to top notch marathoners for about 2x the distance while running in conditions hot enough that a running human would collapse from heat stroke. So yes, cooling matters. But if you're trying to squeeze out a niche for running long distances in hot weather, you still are going to have extreme trouble finding a regime where we are best. If you really want humans to win, you need a combination obstacle course/distance run. There is nothing that runs at our speed for long distances that can also climb. Of course once you go into that niche, we're no longer being judged on our ability to run, are we?
- city41 14y agoYes but you guys have to keep in mind the marathon is nowhere near our upper limit. People run 100 mile ultra marathons all the time. The Tarahumara have been known to run even further than that. It's probably reasonable a human can run 120, 150 even 200 miles in one prolonged effort. Not to mention in more than one effort there's almost no limit to how far a human can run. Dean Karnazes ran across the entire United States, over 3000 miles.
- btilly 14y agoLet's take a good human ultramarathoner. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Meltzer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karl_Meltzer has repeatedly demonstrated that he can run 100 miles in about 19 hours. So a bit over 5 miles per hour. (And he's often beating human competitors by hours when he does that.) The record time in the ididarod represents dogs running on average at close to that speed, through snow, while towing a load, for about 1100 miles. Of course the dogs were only running for a fraction of that time. They needed breaks to eat, sleep, etc. And they carried all of their food. I guarantee that Karl Metzer could not, even under ideal circumstances, manage to run 1100 miles in anywhere close to comparable time. Also let's go back to that kangaroo. Researchers happened to notice that one ran about 2x the distance that Karl did in half the time that he did. There is no particular reason to believe that the kangaroo could not have done the same thing the next day. I don't care how you slice it. There is simply no way that humans are the best long-distance runners on the planet.
- gnaritas 14y ago> The record time in the ididarod represents dogs running on average at close to that speed, through snow, while towing a load, for about 1100 miles. It's only relevant how long they can run without a break; not how far or how far they can run in a given time. You seem to completely miss the point everyone is making about humans being long distance runners; they mean a single run without stopping to rest. The point is the human cooling system that allows man to run continuously without overheating like animals seem to. > Also let's go back to that kangaroo. Researchers happened to notice that one ran about 2x the distance that Karl did in half the time that he did. I'll remind you again, Kangaroos don't run. :)
- gnaritas 14y agoPeople are talking about distance, you keep bringing up speed?
- btilly 14y agoRead it again. I am talking about animals that run both farther and faster than we do.
- gnaritas 14y agoBut no one else is, you seem to not get that no one cares about your point. They're making the point about human distance running without a break and you're going on about unrelated topics of speed. No one disputes that animals are faster, or can travel further in a given time. The issue is who can run the longest non stop without resting or overheating.