5 ms·
Here's the key sentence in the article: "'We're looking at a very interesting population scenario'—one that does not jibe entirely with what we thought we knew
by tokenadult 14y ago
Here's the key sentence in the article: "'We're looking at a very interesting population scenario'—one that does not jibe entirely with what we thought we knew about how waves modern human populations migrated into and through Asia and out to Oceania's islands."
Svante Pääbo was the pioneer of doing DNA sequencing on samples of old human tissues (he started with Egyptian mummies when he was an Egyptologist). I heard a lecture by Pääbo at the 2008 Nobel Conference
https://gustavus.edu/events/nobelconference/2008/presenters.php https://gustavus.edu/events/nobelconference/2008/presenters....
and heard there from some of the other researchers who use DNA analysis to trace human origins.
One of the problems in the discipline so far, as you can well figure out for yourself by thinking about it, is that the sample sizes for defining what genome pattern is "modern human" are still remarkably small, especially when we get to full genome sequences of individuals with well determined geographic origin, and smaller still for Neanderthal sequences and smallest of all for Denisovan sequences. So much work still needs to be done to figure out what the usual range of free variation of genes that are not under strong selection pressure is in the hominin genome line.
Figuring out what genes actually do at the individual level in a genome as complicated as the human genome has turned out to be much harder than was first supposed (as mentioned in the submitted article), so while tracing lineages with gene markers that are not under strong selection pressure helps define geographical population groups with common founder populations, knowing even an individual's complete genome does little to show the traits of the individual. (The first human genome sequenced didn't even reveal that the sequenced individual has blue eyes, for example.)
Turkheimer, E. (2012). Genome wide association studies of behavior are social science. In K. S. Plaisance & T.A.C. Reydon (Eds.) Philosophy of Behavioral Biology (pp. 43-64). New York, NY: Springer.
http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Turkheimer%20GWAS%20EWAS%20Final.pdf http://people.virginia.edu/~ent3c/papers2/Turkheimer%20GWAS%...
"If the history of empirical psychology has taught researchers anything, it is that correlations between causally distant variables cannot be counted on to lead to coherent etiological models."
"Most Genetic Associations with General Intelligence Probably False Positives"
http://www.arts.cornell.edu/econ/dbenjamin/IQ-SNPs-PsychSci-20111205-accepted.pdf http://www.arts.cornell.edu/econ/dbenjamin/IQ-SNPs-PsychSci-...
Johnson, Penke, and Spinath (2011) "Understanding Heritability: What it is and What it is Not"
http://www.larspenke.eu/pdfs/Johnson_Penke_Spinath_2011_-_Heritability_rejoinder.pdf http://www.larspenke.eu/pdfs/Johnson_Penke_Spinath_2011_-_He...
"Presuming this is correct and, as Visscher and Keller appear to have implied, applicable to most behavioural traits, this indicates that literally thousands of genes are likely involved in each trait, with no single polymorphism having substantial effect, which is the quasi-in?nite model to which Munafo and Flint refer. Whatever would we as psychologists do with such information?"
AFTER EDIT: The interesting question raised by the top-level comment that was posted before this comment has received some good replies. The question, and the issue of defining a "species," reminds me of what Richard Dawkins points out about common descent. If you lined up in a line by order of descent with ALL of your ancestors, including the ancestors no longer living, as you looked at each individual in the line you could say "He is the son of the father standing next to him," going back as far as you want, even hundreds of millions of years, and yet at some point in the deep past the ancestors would not look anything at all like "humans," or indeed even like mammals or like tetrapods. At the individual level, OF COURSE you are part of the same species as your parents (by definition of "species"). Life on Earth today has a common ancestor, or at the very least a common set of one-celled ancestors, by general agreement of biologists, so all the species that have differentiated from one another over time can be traced to common ancestors of multiple species. You are undoubtedly related to your parents, who belong to the same species you do, but you have remote ancestors whom no one would call individuals of the species Homo sapiens. There simply isn't any definite line to draw between one species and the next, historically, and that was what was shocking about Darwin's idea of branching speciation from common ancestors, the only idea he presented visually in his book The Origin of Species.
For a book-length treatment of speciation as a scientific issue for the thoroughly curious, see Speciation by Jerry A. Coyne and H. Allen Orr,
http://www.amazon.com/Speciation-Jerry-A-Coyne/dp/0878930892 http://www.amazon.com/Speciation-Jerry-A-Coyne/dp/0878930892
which discusses mechanisms of speciation and how theories about those mechanisms are tested by biologists.
ONE MORE EDIT: The questioner in the other top-level comment is coming back with follow-up questions, which is good. The simple answer to the basic question is that biologists properly do NOT define a "species" by looking at DNA sequences, but by looking at reproductive behavior. For individuals who are dead and long gone, out inferences about reproductive behavior, and thus species definitions, are weak, and we shouldn't rely on a single DNA sequence to say a sample of old bones belongs to a different "species" from another sample of old bones until we gather other forms of evidence about the possibility of the individuals mating and having offspring with each other.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThank you for a detailed overview. I am still confused over the mechanism used to identify a "species" via mtDNA. I understand that the meaning of species as it stems from Linnaeus is unlikely to be useful in the DNA age, and I grasp the impossibility of defining when one species stops being another, but I would like to understand the science first, then the more political side of how to apply a loaded word like species to a DNA result.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoI understand that the meaning of species as it stems from Linnaeus is unlikely to be useful in the DNA age Actually it is more useful than ever. Genetically there is no line in the sand between one species and all others. That's how everything evolves. Only practically do you have a chance to draw a line in the sand between two groups of animals. And keep in mind it is possible for A + B to have fertile offspring, and B + C too, but not A + C. Freaky, but that's biology for you. That's why a practical kludge like "fertile with itself, but not with others" is the best definition to use.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI see, everything smoothes out. But that makes my question more relevant the article, and the scientists behind it seem to be saying there is a line to draw, between Denisovia and Humans and Neanderthal. And they can draw that line with mtDNA * how can we distinguish between three species 41000 years ago * what are the metrics in DNA used (% of gene sequences different?) * if we are saying that xmillion yrs ago there was a common ancestor and they diverged into three species who evovled down till 40k yrs ago, then how can we call them different species if we were still interbreeding 40k ago? If we were interbreeding then we were same species, so again what is the DNA based reason for saying seperate species? One last thing - if the A+B scenarios imply that say humans bred with Neanderthal and their offspring had to breed with denisovians whose offspring then could bring DNA back to human line, (while human/denisovians could never produce fertile offspring) then I still see the same issue if we interbreed we are same species, so what is the DNA based rationale for saying no we weren't if we were not interbreeding ... It makes more sense but presumably the mutations in different trees got shared after common ancestor ? Edit: tokenadult kindly re-edited and I did not spot it I time but makes the point that DNA definition of different species in Pre history is weak at best, and relies on other Indixators of breeding success. I shall assume that the "DNA shows a different species" to be poor science journalism rather than poor science and bookmark this for further Reading later apologies for any iPhone based typos. Edit again: Just checking: If we find two skeletons 250k yrs old, definitetly Neanderthal and human, sequence their genomes. Then find two skeletons at 150k one has acquired a random mtDNA mutation and then find the same mutation on both at 50k years ago - then can we estimate the odds of that being mutally independnt mutations? And is that what this branch of science is trying to do? (I remember Leakey being quoted as saying we have only found enough ancient skeleton bones to fit in the back of his car, so the above convenient pairs of skeletons are understandably hypothetical) pps HN and iPhones do not get on so if this editlooksawful I am justleaving it - thank you for the comments - always nice to have questions treated seriously - and thanks to tokenadult again for living upto your handle