3 ms·

The reality is most commercial software and users are on Windows machines. It is fundamentally a Blender interoperability, and 3rd party platform license compat

The reality is most commercial software and users are on Windows machines. It is fundamentally a Blender interoperability, and 3rd party platform license compatibility issue. We all wish it wasn't so, as many artists find the Windows file systems and color-calibration concepts bewildering. Making a feature platform specific to a negligible fraction of the users is inefficient, as many applications will never be ported to Linux platforms. Blender should be looking at its add-on ecosystem data, and evaluate where users find value. It is a very versatile program, but probably should be focused on media and game workflow interfaces rather than gimmicks. Best of luck =3

johnnyanmac 1y ago
I agree with you, but I think this limitation is for much simpler reasons, like "the contributor only knew how to make this feature in Linux, and only in Wayland". cross compatibility for stuff a base as color grading can be a thorny issue. If nothing else, it's better to have some implementation to reference for future platforms than none.
- Joel_Mckay 1y ago
  We've all seen too many plugins become version specific or indeterminately broken https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFZUB1eJb34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFZUB1eJb34 Someone needs to write a Blender color calibration solution next vacation =3
MrScruff 1y ago
The significant majority of the film and animation industry uses Linux.
- Joel_Mckay 1y ago
  Linux RTX CUDA drivers are getting better, but really depends on the use-case. For a Flamenco render farm it makes sense for sure. Creatives on wacom tablets and Adobe products etc. will exclude the Linux Desktop option. =3
  - MrScruff 1y ago
    Not just for the farm, the large majority of the movie and tv vfx and animation you see is done by artists using Linux workstations.
    - Joel_Mckay 1y ago
      Not the artists I meet, they love their wacom tablets and pressure responsive painting programs... i.e. most of the other software is windows only. I like Linux (use it everyday), but many CAD, Media, Animation, and Mocap application vendors simply don't publish ports outside Windows. Most studios have proprietary workflows with custom software. =3
      - MrScruff 1y ago
        Indeed but this is a discussion about Blender and you posted originally: > Making a feature platform specific to a negligible fraction of the users is inefficient, as many applications will never be ported to Linux platforms. All the large studios use Linux, that's why all the third party software that is used in feature animation and vfx is supported on Linux. So I'm just saying 'negligible fraction of users' in the case of Blender (which as a project would like to increase adoption in professional feature animation and vfx) isn't really true.
        Joel_Mckay 1y ago
        I am sure Studios account for a small portion of the 4.5 million unique downloads each release. Note that less the 20% of users ever touch film or animation projects, 73% are single users, and most related user applications are Adobe products. Stats are available from the published 2024 feedback data: https://survey.blender.org/feedback/2024/ https://survey.blender.org/feedback/2024/ Best of luck, =3 Recommended reading: https://www.poetry.com/poem/101535/the-blind-men-and-the-elephant https://www.poetry.com/poem/101535/the-blind-men-and-the-ele...
        MrScruff 1y ago

johnnyanmac 1y ago

I agree with you, but I think this limitation is for much simpler reasons, like "the contributor only knew how to make this feature in Linux, and only in Wayland". cross compatibility for stuff a base as color grading can be a thorny issue. If nothing else, it's better to have some implementation to reference for future platforms than none.

Joel_Mckay 1y ago
We've all seen too many plugins become version specific or indeterminately broken https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFZUB1eJb34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFZUB1eJb34 Someone needs to write a Blender color calibration solution next vacation =3

MrScruff 1y ago

The significant majority of the film and animation industry uses Linux.

Joel_Mckay 1y ago
Linux RTX CUDA drivers are getting better, but really depends on the use-case. For a Flamenco render farm it makes sense for sure. Creatives on wacom tablets and Adobe products etc. will exclude the Linux Desktop option. =3
- MrScruff 1y ago
  Not just for the farm, the large majority of the movie and tv vfx and animation you see is done by artists using Linux workstations.
  - Joel_Mckay 1y ago
    Not the artists I meet, they love their wacom tablets and pressure responsive painting programs... i.e. most of the other software is windows only. I like Linux (use it everyday), but many CAD, Media, Animation, and Mocap application vendors simply don't publish ports outside Windows. Most studios have proprietary workflows with custom software. =3
    - MrScruff 1y ago
      Indeed but this is a discussion about Blender and you posted originally: > Making a feature platform specific to a negligible fraction of the users is inefficient, as many applications will never be ported to Linux platforms. All the large studios use Linux, that's why all the third party software that is used in feature animation and vfx is supported on Linux. So I'm just saying 'negligible fraction of users' in the case of Blender (which as a project would like to increase adoption in professional feature animation and vfx) isn't really true.
      - Joel_Mckay 1y ago
        I am sure Studios account for a small portion of the 4.5 million unique downloads each release. Note that less the 20% of users ever touch film or animation projects, 73% are single users, and most related user applications are Adobe products. Stats are available from the published 2024 feedback data: https://survey.blender.org/feedback/2024/ https://survey.blender.org/feedback/2024/ Best of luck, =3 Recommended reading: https://www.poetry.com/poem/101535/the-blind-men-and-the-elephant https://www.poetry.com/poem/101535/the-blind-men-and-the-ele...
        MrScruff 1y ago