3 ms·
Perhaps, but isn't there the risk that a charismatic leader could get team members to essentially do the work for him/her? Sure, you could say that's a lesson i
by danso 14y ago
Perhaps, but isn't there the risk that a charismatic leader could get team members to essentially do the work for him/her? Sure, you could say that's a lesson in life, but ideally, you want a passing grade in engineering mechanics to mean that that person has competency in engineering, not merely the politics and management of engineering.
Of course, this risk is mitigated by having the final weighted much heavier than the rest of the coursework and not being take home. But that approach ends up going to the polar extreme of valuing collaboration
- Anechoic 14y agoPerhaps, but isn't there the risk that a charismatic leader could get team members to essentially do the work for him/her? There were charismatic students who tried that, but it would become apparently very quickly what was happening and that point our competitiveness would kick in and we would demand contributions from that person before we would assist any further. But yes, there is always someone who will abuse the system, and you're not going to get far trying to achieve 100% compliance all the time.
- ghshephard 14y agoThe mechanism to avoid having a charismatic leader unfairly being granted credentials in courses not based on their knowledge is have a pass/fail (heavily protctored) exam at the end of the sememster drawing on knowledge from all the sections of the course. Fail the exam, fail the course. Pass the exam, you get the grade you earned throughout the semester. We had a few of those at SFU, and they were awesome - the only ones who ever failed them were the cheaters - The ones who had actually done all the work/exams finished them in about half the time allocated.
- danielweber 14y agoOn assignments, that ends up with the charismatic leader not understanding what's going on come test time. (I am unfamiliar with collaboration on take-home tests.) The practice questions really are warm-ups for the test in most classes.
- victorhn 14y ago"Perhaps, but isn't there the risk that a charismatic leader could get team members to essentially do the work for him/her?" Funny, you mention that. There was a "charismatic guy" who passed trough my whole computer engineering program just by getting a dedicated and smart girlfriend who would help him in all the assignments and even give him copy during written tests. The guy could not program to save his life, and yet got his degree. At the end of the program he ditched her instantly and got a hot girlfriend instead, i kind of felt sorry for her girlfriend, but there is your life lesson.