8 ms·
Roman dodecahedron: 12-sided object has baffled archaeologists for centuries
- adastra22 1y agoIt’s a tool for making fingers in knitted gloves. It’s rather annoying that this click bait “archeologists baffled” story keeps propagating.
- quantified 1y agoCan you point to an example or a youtube? Sounds great but the object in the photo looks a bit abstracted.
- adastra22 1y agoI don't really do YouTube, but putting "dodecahedron knitting" into the search box got this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76AvV601yJ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76AvV601yJ0
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gilleain 1y agoHere is a fairly comprehensive analysis by an archeologist that mentions the knitting argument, but dismisses it https://youtu.be/UbGtkbqbjtY?si=kJNAUqtRQMyf5Nja https://youtu.be/UbGtkbqbjtY?si=kJNAUqtRQMyf5Nja
- bookofjoe 1y agoI didn't know that so I went and read about them. I could not find a single source that definitively states that "it's a tool for making fingers in knitted gloves." That there are YouTube videos showing it being used to do exactly that does NOT mean that was its intended or original function. In fact, all of the sources I consulted stated that your proposed function is one of approximately 50 possible and speculated uses but that there is still no conclusive evidence as to the device's original function. Thus, I find your characterization of the article as "click bait" to be wide of the mark.
- meindnoch 1y agoStop perpetuating made-up pseudoarchaelogical stories.
- masklinn 1y agoThat's a hypothesis amongst others, but it's just that, with essentially no hard evidence backing it up. And there's counter-evidence (if mostly circumstantial) in that the first known knitted artefacts are from centuries later, to say nothing of knitting spools which they would predate by some 1300 years. This hypothesis also lacks a lot of explanatory power e.g. why did some of them find (and take) room in coin hoards? Why have they been found all over Gallia, Germania, and Britannia, but not Italia, Hispania, or the Oriens?
- fiedzia 1y ago> why did some of them find (and take) room in coin hoards? People who had access to gold used some of it to create jewellery. > Why have they been found all over Gallia, Germania, and Britannia, but not Italia, Hispania, or the Oriens? Certain types of jewellery can be found in certain regions. This can be attributed to specific trading network or local preferences. I don't know if that could be proven, but makes sense to me.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 1y agoKnitting spools are not jewellery.
- nwallin 1y agoIt's a nifty theory, but unfortunately, it isn't true. If it were used for that, there would be wear at the bases of the little knobs as the yarn rubs along it. None of the dodecahedrons we have show any wear in those areas.
- sandspar 1y agoThe objects were found in graves and coin hoards. Why would people ask to be buried with a knitting accessory?
- ceejayoz 1y agoWhy not? Egyptian pharaohs were buried with (among other things) food and everyday necessities, because it was believed they'd take them along to the afterlife for use there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grave_goods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grave_goods Modern society is not much different: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/photo/ohio-mans-wish-fulfilled-he-buried-motorcycle-flna2d12034835 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/photo/ohio-mans-wish-fulfilled-...
- pavel_lishin 1y agoI feel like "why not" is not a sufficient answer, especially when trying to explain a single object. The pharaohs were buried with everything, including people, so that's not a great analogy.
- ceejayoz 1y agoFrom the article: > Archaeologists have recovered dodecahedrons from the graves of men and women, in coin hoards and even in refuse heaps, so a blanket explanation for their use has not been found. There's no indication these were the only things in graves that I can see.
- sandspar 1y agoYou could easily find information about Roman burial practices. It would help you decide whether knitting accessories fit the pattern.
- NelsonMinar 1y agoEvery time someone posts this article someone smugly says "it's a tool for knitting" and then everyone speculates and points to folks saying it's not a tool for knitting.
- tristramb 1y agoIn my estimation this is amost certainly correct. It accounts for most if not all of the observed properties of these objects. The other suggestions only ever account for one or two. But lazy journalists, aided by AI, will no doubt continue to treat all the suggestions as equally likely.
- nemo 1y agoKnitting hadn't been invented when these were around - we know the Romans made gloves, socks, and other garments with a great deal of supporting evidence, there's not a single example of a mitten, nor of any kind of knitting like this. The Romans wove cloth on a loom and stitched it together. There's no signs of wear on any examples of the dodecahedra, so it's not a hand tool that comes into contact with wool or metals which would leave at least micro-abrasions. Whatever these were they were not a hand tool. It snows in north Italy, why wouldn't they need gloves in some places where it snows outside of Gallia? The knitting tool is among the weakest hypotheses in terms of evidence. If journalists were to refer to these as a knitting tool it would be because they were lazy and didn't do any research into that hypothesis. In general journalists writing on this tend to acknowledge scholarly opinion that their use is unknown and hypotheses about it are speculative. The lazy journalists are the ones who write about how some Youtuber decided it's a knitting tool or whatever and uncritically repeat this without researching scholarly consensus or what historians and archaeologists have to say about the tool.
- meindnoch 1y ago>It accounts for most if not all of the observed properties of these objects 1. How does it account for the different-sized holes on the dodecahedron's faces? Before you answer "to knit for different sized fingers" let me remind you that knitting doesn't work like that, that is, the diameter of the final product is determined by the distance of the pegs, which is the same across all the faces. 2. How does it account for the similar-looking Roman icosahedrons? 3. How does it account for the fact that knitting was invented hundreds of years after the fall of the Roman Empire? This is some Joe Rogan-tier crank theory, that no self-respecting archaeologist takes seriously. It's literally based on a single YouTube video, yet for some reason it gets endlessly repeated, probably because it makes people feel good that a random grandma figured out something that the fat cats of the archaeologist establishment failed to crack.
- dang 1y agoRelated. Others? Solved? The Roman Dodecahedron [video] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40960287 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40960287 - July 2024 (2 comments) The Mysterious Roman Dodecahedron Was Possibly Just for Knitting - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40959715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40959715 - July 2024 (0 comments) The Enigma of the Roman Dodecahedron Is Revealed - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40853737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40853737 - July 2024 (2 comments) Roman Dodecahedron - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40829091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40829091 - June 2024 (1 comment) 'Great enigma': Amateur archaeologists unearth mysterious Roman object - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40205014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40205014 - April 2024 (1 comment) Another Roman dodecahedron has been unearthed in England - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39102069 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39102069 - Jan 2024 (381 comments) The mysterious dodecahedrons of the Roman Empire - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35937540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35937540 - May 2023 (99 comments) No one is certain what Roman bronze dodecahedrons were used for (2018) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29717215 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29717215 - Dec 2021 (207 comments) What were these Roman objects used for? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25237271 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25237271 - Nov 2020 (37 comments) The Mysterious Bronze Objects That Have Baffled Archaeologists for Centuries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21439351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21439351 - Nov 2019 (7 comments)
- TomMasz 1y agoIt's obvious that opinions are varied on what these were for. I wonder if the fact that they don't seem to appear in images or get mentioned in writing is some sort of clue. But that could mean anything from "so common not worth talking about" to "super secret usage we don't dare talk about".
- ceejayoz 1y agoI often wonder if future archaeologists will decide our civilization worshiped wasteful excess and landfills were our temples.
- readthenotes1 1y agoThey wouldn't be wrong
- bigstrat2003 1y agoI mean... they would be wrong though. I get what you're saying, but the accurate interpretation is that our civilization doesn't care about excess, not that we worship it.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoWe seem to worship consumption though (which leads to...).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- octaane 1y agoMy favorite theory that I've seen to explain these has been that they were a token showing the prowess/status of a metalworker or stoneworker - a kind of verifier of skill of the individual. In a mostly pre-literate society, where craftsmen could be itinerant, this theory made the most sense to me.
- deadbabe 1y agoDoesn’t explain why mostly women were buried with these.
- m0llusk 1y agoAnd most have been found around present day France.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pegasus 1y agoI would expect a lot more variability if this would be the purpose. For example, instead of corner balls, why not be a little creative and make them cones. Also, the holes in the faces always being of different sizes is peculiar. Then there's the icosahedron with balls of different sizes. Reading the wikipedia page only deepens the sense of mystery, but some use in astrological divination or the like seems most plausible to me.
- dennyabraham 1y agoWhile I don't endorse this particular theory, considering that something like a gotshall block or a fizzbuzz is proof of a certain skillset, it is certainly possible the corner balls being cones is not a comparable proof of work
- pegasus 1y agoStill doesn't make sense to me. Those programming tasks have to be a certain way because they have a very specific use outside of the testing. If that's what you imply, then we're none the wiser, still having left unexplained what that use might be.
- paleotrope 1y agoMaybe it was used in some sort of ritual
- mrbluecoat 1y agoHundreds of years into the future: "Researchers uncover many examples of US fidget spinner: 3-sided object has baffled archaeologists"
- pinoy420 1y ago[dead]
- doublerabbit 1y agoI saw them in Singapore before they went viral, I wish I had grabbed a box and milked that fad. I wonder when the YoYo will roll back in to popularity again.
- Loughla 1y ago>I wonder when the YoYo will roll back in to popularity again. About three years ago. Every kid that exists in my area had to have a butterfly yoyo. Some convinced their parents to spend hundreds on trick yoyo's. That fad died after about 10 months, though.
- altairprime 1y agoI still think it’s a coin-toss drinking game.
- dvh 1y agoThey have no wear
- drsopp 1y agoMaybe one shop made these in a big city. Adventurous men bought them, brought them home and gave them to their wife. A great novelty noone has seen at home. So precious they bring them to their grave.
- bee_rider 1y agoIt is particularly confusing because, of course, Romans famously used short swords in battle. They’d have needed this if they used something like a great axe, but a short sword is just 1d6 damage… as everyone who’s played DnD knows.
- smogcutter 1y agoObviously someone was playing a barbarian
- 6177c40f 1y agoI mean, > Because these dodecahedrons have been found in Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Great Britain, Hungary, Luxembourg, the Netherlands and Switzerland — but not in Italy — Guggenberger views them as "Gallo-Roman products" with a possible origin in the Celtic tribes of the Roman Empire. Sounds like you might be right!
- bee_rider 1y agoGiven the overlapping areas of interest, I wonder if this is a surprisingly widely gotten “joke” that coincidence has played on us.
- aspenmayer 1y ago> Guggenberger views them as "Gallo-Roman products Oh my, I’m getting flashbacks to this absurd Meeple copyright (edit: trademark) case for some reason due to the arguments that were used. It’s a really weird case if you’re into copyright (edit: trademark) law, which if you’re here on HN to read this, I’ll take the odds that you might be. Something about discussing stuff that may or may not be dice made me primed for that perhaps? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meeple#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meeple#History > Over 40 games with the word meeple in the title had been published as of 2024. Several games published by large game companies, like AEG and Asmodee, have even published games with the term in the titles, as well as adopting the token design commonly associated with the term, including such games as Mutant Meeples (2012), Terror in Meeple City (2013), the Meeple Circus series (2017-2021), and Meeples and Monsters (2022). This continued until 2019, when "MEEPLE" was registered as an EU trademark owned by Hans im Glück. The 2019 trademarking was objected to by, among others, gaming company CMON. The critics argued that the term has been used in common parlance, and the very shape of the meeple became commonplace in the industry. This resulted in the EU trademark exempting the category "toys and games"; however, Hans im Glück has since registered the term as a trademark in Germany for usage which does include toys and games, and the company also acquired the EU trademark for the shape of the ‘original’ meeple figure as used in Carcassonne. In 2024, the company Cogito Ergo Meeple received a cease and desist for unsanctioned use of the trademark, and decided to change the name of their upcoming game from Meeple Inc to Tabletop Inc, and the name of the company itself to Cotswold Games. It goes on. I would try to shorten this but it’s just so silly that for it to make as little sense as it’s supposed to, I had to quote that much to be fair to the issue and how silly it is. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izDgyd2tDmY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izDgyd2tDmY
- Covzire 1y agoWhat if it was a primitive form of identification? "Oh you're a Roman citizen you say? Can you prove it?" "You know I can't prove it, you'll have to take my word for it" nonchalantly fidgets with their dodecahedron "You know, I'll just take your word for it, be on you way" wink
- thaumasiotes 1y agoThey had sumptuary laws. https://acoup.blog/2021/07/23/collections-the-queens-latin-or-who-were-the-romans-part-iv-the-color-of-purple/ https://acoup.blog/2021/07/23/collections-the-queens-latin-o... > We have what looks to be a man, perhaps in middle age. A few things are notable. First, he wears a white toga (the standard formal Roman folded cloth garment, draped from the left shoulder) and a white tunic with a purple stripe (two, in fact, the other is concealed beneath the toga). When I show my students this picture, I joke that the man might as well have worn his, “I AM A ROMAN CITIZEN” t-shirt; the impact of the clothing here is similarly blunt. While a fellow might wear a toga in a variety of colors for fashion’s sake, this solid-white toga is the toga virilis: the distinctive formal dress of a Roman citizen. Meanwhile, that purple stripe on his tunic is the angustus clavus (or angusticlavius, literally ‘the narrow stripe’). That too was a bit of clothing reserved as a marker of status – whereas the toga virilis says “I am a Roman citizen” the angusticlavius says “I am of the equestrian order” (nothing to do directly with horses by this point, it merely indicates wealth and that the individual isn’t involved in politics in Rome). In short then, this man – or more correctly, his surviving family who commissioned the portrait – is telling us, in no uncertain terms, “I was a wealthy Roman citizen.” I want to stress that point: there was no real distinctive national appearance that indicated a Roman – no particularly Roman hair color or what have you – but there was a distinctive dress that indicated citizenship, which only citizens were entitled to wear and which was so important the Romans went so far as to call themselves the gens togata (‘the people of the toga’). > of course that fact about clothing is really very handy for us if we want images from the provinces in color where we can know with a high degree of certainty that the subjects are Roman citizens, since anyone wearing either the toga virilis or a tunic with that clavus is declaring their citizenship (in a way that would get them in rather a lot of trouble if they were lying!) This wasn't the space for subtlety; it was the space for strict formal legal controls. If the dodecahedrons were serving that purpose, we'd know about it.
- brador 1y agoThese are used in the Middle East for holding flowers bouquets on graves. They make a nice bloom. So that’s my guess.
- realo 1y agoI guess my ignorance shows here but I can only be impressed by their perfect symmetry, the perfect round little balls etc... I understand skill was certainly required, but how were those made, exactly 2,000 years ago?
- qoez 1y agoWouldn't you just have to make a mold and pour in molten metal? Plenty of talented sculptors around at the time.
- Beijinger 1y ago"For the time being, the most likely interpretation of the dodecahedron is as a cosmic, all-encompassing symbol," Guggenberger wrote, with "a function comparable to an amulet." Great theory. But as you can see in the picture: 1. This thing is very carefully crafted. 2. The holes have different sizes. I don't think this is by chance. There must be a reason for this and the explanation, be it coin counting, knitting or whatever, has to take this into account.
- fiedzia 1y agoKnitting - specifically knitting jewellery - explains that. Different holes allow you to create chains of different sizes, which in case of jewellery, also does not need to be standardised (lack of any standard or markings makes theories of some measurement device unlikely). That also explains regional popularity and proximity to gold (several of those items were found close to places were gold coins were produced or stored).
- Beijinger 1y agoNo, knitting of gloves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76AvV601yJ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=76AvV601yJ0 And none were found in Italy or in the South. Guess what, you don't need gloves there in the winter.
- Macuyiko 1y agoA coin measurer is still my goto explanation. Especially with most models having an inset for the coin to rest on / fit in. The hole itself is then just to quickly/easily get the coin out again with your finger. With so many different coin sizes and types in the empire, I think this makes most sense. Wikipedia also mentions this: > Several dodecahedra were found in coin hoards, suggesting either that their owners considered them valuable objects, or that their use was connected with coins — as, for example, for easily checking coins fit a certain diameter and were not clipped.
- meindnoch 1y agoIf you look at ancient coins, you'll see that they didn't have identical sizes. They were minted from a standard weight of metal, but the manual minting tools of the time couldn't guarantee precise thickness and shape like we have today with machine-made coins. So a dodecahedron with precisely cut circular holes is not a good way to check your coins.
- dvh 1y agoIt looks like a tool to make those little things with the sort of raffia work base, that has an attachment
- Pxtl 1y agoThe things that make it tricky: 1) They're not found with wear-marks, so they couldn't have been done for anything laborious like wire-weaving. 2) They've got no size markings and don't match each other, so they couldn't have been used for anything standardized. The holes of opposing sides don't have matching sizes. 3) Platonic solids have religious significance, so they may have been deliberately impractical (but if it's a tool where's the practical peasant version of it? Like a series of plates?) 4) They're found primarily in and around Rome's Celtic holdings, not Rome itself. 5) They're expensive so they're probably not just measuring grapes. So the first question is, beyond cultural significance, why make them a platonic solid? It guarantees the distance between the opposing sides is consistent, while allowing you to carry 6 different hole-pairs all with that same "distance" in a single object. But it can't be a measuring tool because of fact (2). And if there's no good reason for it to be a platonic solid, why haven't they found any non-platonic-solid versions of them? Maybe it's the gamer in me but I think it's some kind of gambling game based on the irregularity of coinage. Roll the thingamajig, drop in a coin that goes through the top but not the bottom. I mean it was found around military camps and caches of coins, right? Casino game.
- sparkie 1y agoNot being standardized doesn't necessarily rule out being a measuring tool. They could've each been crafted for a specific purpose, but using the same technique for measuring. Would be nice if there were a database of precise measurements of those discovered so far. The paper suggesting they may have been a dioptron[1] has a small sample data, but not enough to make any conclusions. [1]:https://arxiv.org/pdf/1206.0946 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1206.0946
- Pxtl 1y ago> Would be nice if there were a database of precise measurements of those discovered so far. I was thinking same. At least if we knew the side-lengths and radii of the circles (particularly the opposing circles) we could see if there are any consistent ratios.
- 1y ago
- MarcelOlsz 1y agoIt's so obviously for measuring pasta. Case closed.
- ibaikov 1y agoSomeone suggested they were used to estimate distance which might be true since some modern guns like mp5 have rotating drum sights of same principle. Another good suggestion was that it was used for knitting, there was a very cool video of this on YouTube somewhere. And the last I like is it’s just a game. I think it was one of the earliest multi-tools and all of these were what it was used for
- al_borland 1y agoI watched something recently that showed it was for knitting chainmail, specifically tubular shapes. Someone demoed it and it seemed to work really well.
- lubujackson 1y agoYeah, the metal knitting solution makes the most sense for all use cases - in military camps, buried with women, etc. What sold me was the story of a woman who saw one and immediately knew how to use it. It explains the different sizes of the pegs and the holes in the middle, as well as why they never showed up in historical documents. The shape is clearly a nod to mathematical/religious values, but not required for its actual purpose.
- sethrin 1y agoThe only problem is that knitting wasn't invented until hundreds of years later.
- Timwi 1y agoBut chainmail was a thing, so how did they manufacture it without knitting? Maybe “knitting” is just a way of describing this, while the knitting you're thinking of is specifically knitting involving textiles.
- Ekaros 1y agoChainmail is made from individual rings. Romans made it from punched out metal rings alternating with rings made of wire and then ends of those rings made out of wire together. Not really too much riveting you can do with textiles. Well maybe plastics, but they did not have plastics.
- lowplow 1y agoI love how this mystery has captured the imaginations of this generation. I've started to see this object appear in various media, like sitting on a desk behind a professor, or in a studio of a Roman intellectual when time traveling to that era.
- jumploops 1y agoMy favorite theory so far is that the dodecahedrons were used to create metal chains. A stay-at-home mom/pattern maker whose "eureka moment was visiting the Met in New York and seeing Roman jewelry with knitted chains" created a video confirming her theory was possible[0]. The glove theory is also good (and maybe the device was just multi-use?), as I seem to recall that the majority (all?) of these devices were found in colder/northern Roman settlements. It seems the "wear pattern" on this example[1] from the UK matches what one might expect if you were to repeatedly wrap wire around the corner knobs. With that said, its unclear that we'll ever know! (unless we find a grave with dodecahedrons and their products) [0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lADTLozKm0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lADTLozKm0I [1]https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1325774111601067&id=100025054717260&set=a.979714866206995 https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1325774111601067&id=...
- Cthulhu_ 1y agoHave you got a mirror for the FB link? It requires a login.
- layer8 1y agoPress the X to close the login modal, then you can still read the post and its comments.
- cluckindan 1y agoIn my mind, a better explanation is that they were templates for personally fitted non-metal gloves. The template could be given to a knitter to receive exactly fitting gloves each time. Metal chain would have been difficult to detach from the template, but knit natural yarn would have stretched. Of course, the end products would not have survived to our time. This theory explains many things about the object: - the dodecahedrons have been found all around Europe, but particularly in the north - they are not in one standard size - the hole sizings are a good match for fingers - the same template can be used for both left and right hands, leaving one set of holes for some sort of stick to stand on Gloves would have been very important clothing items in the northern parts of the empire, and in military use, they would have fallen apart quickly, necessitating their replacement from local sources. Fingered leather gloves would have been prohibitively expensive if they were available at all, and fur gloves would not have been nimble enough for handling a sword and a shield, or for any other task requiring finger dexterity. Since they would have been personal items, soldiers would have carried them wherever they were stationed, and kept them after their military careers. This would explain why they were also found in temperate and warm parts of the empire.
- NHQ 1y agoThis is a solved case, they were used for textiles. But to admit this would break history, so instead it is constantly rattled academically. Put one next to the Voynich Manuscript in the Museum or Jurassic Technology. The cause behind this narrative hustle is the industrial historical arrogation which teaches that knitting was not invented until 1000 years after "The Romans". They had textiles, weaving, but no knitting. This is early mere patent protection during the capitol rush of industrialism, claiming devices which were not actually invented as pretended, and therefor should have no claim to copyrights. The cotton gin was not invented in 1793. Moreover it is a supremely ignorant and abstract notion, showing how detached academia is from reality. Anybody with time on their hands and some vines may invent weaving, knotting, knitting, and with metal slivers many ways to make pins. There has never been a people without this technology.
- harimau777 1y agoMy understanding is that this would be equivalent to loom knitting (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spool_knitting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spool_knitting). Is it possible that loom knitting was invented earlier but needle knitting was not?
- ameister14 1y agoThe cotton gin was not invented in 1793, but the claim wasn't a narrative hustle. The short staple cotton gin was invented in 1793.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mjanx123 1y agoWhat is the matter with the Voynich Manuscript?
- meindnoch 1y agoYou have to admit, this is a pretty unhinged conspiracy theory.
- 1y ago
- ltbarcly3 1y agoIts obviously for surveying, different sized holes allow it to be aligned a precise distance from the eye, then some reference object (probably a wide rod or board) can be sighted. Different sized hole pairs allow for different reference distances with the same reference object. This seems completely obvious to me, but apparently its not? If someone can find precise measurements of one of these I will bet that when you compute the distances for a reference object when sighted through different hole pairs it makes simple integer ratios.
- windowshopping 1y agoGiven that the sides of the dodecahedron aren't parallel to one another and you therefore cannot look through it from one side to the other (only two side are parallel), your "completely obvious" theory falls pretty flat. Kinda seems like you arrived at this "completely obvious" conclusion without actually examining one. If this is "completely obviously" what it's for, why would they go to the trouble of putting little balls on every corner? Why would they make them consistently of bronze instead of other materials? You should think a little harder before pronouncing things "completely obvious."
- JKCalhoun 1y agoThere are holes in the sides of the dodecahedron of various diameter giving you six ways to look through the shape (from smaller-to-larger diameter hole). The balls you mention are another interesting point — why they would even be there for a "range finder".
- windowshopping 1y agoYou're correct about the parallel faces, my examination of the model was wrong. So that part I take back. The balls remain.
- ltbarcly3 1y agoHave you ever seen a dodecahedron?
- 1y ago
- water-data-dude 1y agoAny time I see something like this, I'm reminded of a tongue-in-cheek* post I saw of someone showing off the fancy "egg separator" they found at a thrift store (it was a chastity cage). *I hope
- LouisSayers 1y agoIt's a Roman mailbox. Paper was rolled into scrolls, and that's why you find them everywhere, because just like today people communicated with one another. If you need to leave a message you write it on a scroll and insert in a hole. You could have different sized holes for different sized messages / documents. You could basically leave the mailbox on your desk and have people put messages there for you to read (or the other way around) The bits on the corners simply keep it a bit off of the surface - important incase of any moisture, spills etc.
- sandworm101 1y agoAs opposed to hole in a block of wood? Given these were metal and hard to craft, that would be like leaving a thousand-dollar pencil holder on one's desk all day.
- forgotoldacc 1y agoWood stuff from the era is basically all disintegrated. Metal lasts a long time. And there are people on this planet with solid gold pens in their pocket. People today love flaunting their wealth, and so did people 2000 years ago.
- meindnoch 1y ago>Wood stuff from the era is basically all disintegrated. False. >Archaeologists have unearthed a 2,000-year-old, perfectly preserved wooden toilet seat at a Roman fort on Hadrian's Wall in Northumberland. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-tyne-28956328 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-tyne-28956328
- detaro 1y agoThat some individual artifacts in lucky conditions have survived does not invalidate the statement that most don't
- 1y ago
- sohenflez 1y ago[dead]
- utf_8x 1y agoHas anyone considered that it might've just been a novelty? A fancy paperweight? I wonder if, in a couple thousands of years, archeologists will wonder why some people owned a 10x10cm cube of tungsten...
- lou1306 1y ago> Has anyone considered that it might've just been a novelty? A fancy paperweight? This just got me thinking, it would likely take us hours to explain an ancient Roman what a "paperweight" is. The fact that paper a) exists, b) is our main writing support, and c) can be made so lightweight that a slight breeze can blow a stack of it away would be mind-blowing
- Ekaros 1y agoPaperweights would be even greater use for Romans. As often they were wound up on scrolls which means that some item stopping them from wounding up again when unwound would be rather useful.
- adrian_b 1y agoLong scrolls were normally read by unwrapping them from a stick, while wrapping them again on another stick, i.e. like magnetic tapes are read now. So the two sticks kept the scroll unwound around the reading position.
- griffzhowl 1y agoThey had papyrus so I don't think paper would have been that mind-blowing
- mr_toad 1y agoThey also used vellum/parchment.
- colechristensen 1y agoArchaeologists do have a bias towards "if we don't know what it was, it was a religious artifact".
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deknos 1y agoi would assume it has to do with thread, sewing and knitting. :D
- ohdeargodno 1y agoIt's quite obviously a krangled resonator (https://i.redd.it/e9wy316rqws41.png https://i.redd.it/e9wy316rqws41.png), the romans were massive path of exile players. Silly archeologists.
- ForOldHack 1y agoPossibly used for knitting? How parochial. My oldest brother came back with a block with a hole cut in it, with 4 nails, wanting to buy yarn. Soon me, and my two brothers were using all of our nervous energy cranking out red, blue and rainbow colored finger tubes by the dozen. We gave them to someone who knew how to crochet, and were given plastic blocks to knit the hands, each in our size, in a months time, we each had three pairs of warm gloves for the mornings. We gave the blocks to our younger cousins in Canada, and they cranked out enough gloves for classrooms of children. So when I saw these devices, I knew exactly what they were for: 1. Making gloves. 2. Confusing people who never had used a knitting block, and 3. causing un-due speculation. Why no wear on the nob necks? Soft wool. Our blocks used high carbon steel finishing nails, which never wore, but even brass, would at first polish, and then would patina over, leaving no marks. Why no hooks? for finishing? Those would have been made of wood, and like other looms, would have disappeared. what they should be looking for is collections of brass nails. "Wool was the most important fiber in the Roman world." https://sites.google.com/view/dulciasromancloset/roman-textiles/wool-in-ancient-rome https://sites.google.com/view/dulciasromancloset/roman-texti...
- torial 1y agoThis ^ I had seen an article discussing this many years ago, and it seemed as the most plausible of the explanations.
- BoredPositron 1y agoLoved it in the background of and or.
- orefalo 1y agoisn't it obvious.. it was used to fortify the tent structure.
- willtemperley 1y agoThe article didn’t mention the silver one found in Geneva in 1982, which has the signs of the Zodiac inscribed on it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_dodecahedron https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_dodecahedron
- NullRien 1y agoI thought this was solved? Didn't some woman figure out that this was used to knit a left and right glove and something else?
- zach 1y agoThe fact that it has no clearly discernible purpose is evidence for it being something to be enjoyed for aesthetics, spiritual purposes, or, most likely I think, entertainment. Attach some string and it is a durable, highly portable puzzle and even two-player game: https://tinkerings.org/2020/06/17/roman-dodecahedrons-part-ii/ https://tinkerings.org/2020/06/17/roman-dodecahedrons-part-i...
- dooglius 1y agoIs there an English translation of the paper where he "rules out" most of the existing theories?