3 ms·
Immigration raids leave crops unharvested and California farms at risk
- tom89999 1y agoThat was so crystal clear ...
- netsharc 1y agoWrecking the agricultural part of California's economy is probably part of the plan... > One, age 54, has worked in U.S. agricultural fields for 30 years and has a wife and children in the country. He said most of his colleagues have stopped showing up for work. > "If they show up to work, they don't know if they will ever see their family again," he said. > The other worker in the country illegally said, "Basically, we wake up in the morning scared. We worry about the sun, the heat, and now a much bigger problem — many not returning home. I try not to get into trouble on the street. Now, whoever gets arrested for any reason gets deported." Heh, heck of a job Donnie, creating an opressive regime. Anyone remember the 1990's Claire Danes/Leonardo DiCaprio "Romeo and Juliet", which is the Shakespeare play but set in the modern era, with cars and guns? Maybe somewhere out there is a little Latina girl doing a reimagining of "Diary of Anne Frank", but the book will be called Diary of Ana Franco?
- chronoc7394 1y ago> That was so crystal clear .. Yeah, people just don’t care. Myself included. If you want to come to america, come here legally. We all want a better life for ourselves and family. Illegal immigrants “dreamers” are no different in this regard. Well, except the fact, they snuck into a different person’s home (country) while hundreds of thousands are waiting in the legal line.
- wrs 1y agoWell, I enjoy having food available, so I do care about the effect of throwing a bomb into the agricultural workforce without any apparent planning or regard for the consequences.
- cinntaile 1y agoPeople care about their wallets though and this whole situation isn't exactly fattening them.
- 2muchcoffeeman 1y agoDepends on the wallet …
- nitwit005 1y agoThey, presumably, meant the side effects for the farm owners. A lot of people voted to have their business ruined, and seem upset that it happened.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI support your right to your position, but also support doing nothing as rural america infrastructure is rapidly evaporated, first healthcare and then whatever else remains (because what will when the closest medical provider is hours away). It’s the only way people who think this matters (“do it the legal way” even though it’s borderline impossible and extremely expensive) will then understand food supply infrastructure is more important than residency status of the only people who will do these jobs, but maybe not. Unless you’re a Native American, you’re an immigrant too.
- bookofjoe 1y agoNative Americans are also immigrants. https://imgur.com/a/QVyCeRo https://imgur.com/a/QVyCeRo
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI stand corrected.
- bookofjoe 1y agou ROOL!
- toomuchtodo 1y agoI appreciate you!
- foogazi 1y ago> Well, except the fact, they snuck into a different person’s home (country) Not true - false analogy > while hundreds of thousands are waiting in the legal line. Again - the legal line is fake too
- jcranmer 1y agoFirst, the plurality of illegal immigrants in the US are people who entered the country legally but have overstayed their visas. There's not a lot of sneaking into a different person's country to do work. Second, there is no "legal line" for immigration. The closest you get is that some visas where conversion to a permanent residency (green card) has an annual quota that is so heavily oversubscribed that there is a permanent backlog which stretches, in the most extreme cases, to over 20 years long. Third, even when you're dealing with the legal immigration processes, that process is a bureaucratic hell that I don't wish on anybody. If you don't have anybody willing to descend into paperwork hell for you, then there is no way for you to immigrate to the US.
- Ucalegon 1y agoThis is just ignorant to how Congress has dropped the ball when it comes to funding a functional immigration system which provides for a speedy process. It is almost as if there is an economic interest to keep labor cheap via undocumented workers which is not alleviated at all through these raids, but does increase costs while undermining the US economy.
- beej71 1y agoIt'll be interesting to see how this "screw the farmers" tactic plays out in the midterms.
- jfengel 1y agoI'm betting it'll turn out pretty well. There aren't all that many farmers. Americans love the idea of them, but they aren't actually a significant voting bloc. If they had been, we'd have had a more realistic position on migrant farm workers. Any complaints the farmers may have will be drowned out by the sound of how happy people are with the raids. Those farmers are mostly in deep-red districts. Even if they're unhappy, they're not going to vote for the Democrat -- if there's even one on the ticket. The few who cross party lines won't suffice to to change the outcome in the district. For the rest of the country... if it results in higher food prices, that might make a difference. Though perhaps less than you'd think. People's perceptions of inflation are only loosely correlated with the actual cost of things. Inflation of "only" 5% doesn't result in massive sticker shock, by itself. It's filtered through people's expectations. If people are generally happy, even substantial inflation will be passed off as merely trying times (for which we must double down on our bootstraps). If people are generally unhappy, it's easy to single out some specific item that has gone up in price and make it the be-all and end-all of consumer budgets. The balance is close enough that at least one house will likely turn next November. But I've seen nothing to suggest it will be any kind of landslide. It's just enough to nudge a few 51-49 districts to 49-51 instead.
- acjohnson55 1y agoIt would be one thing if it were some kind of sacrifice to have immigrants, but if all the undocumented immigrants disappeared, we would be substantially worse off as a country. We would have a shrinking, aging population. The system of rules they are breaking is kept slow, arbitrary, and complex so that we can benefit from their labor without granting all the rights of being US citizens. This is so that they can be illegally exploited, but also because of the anxieties Americans have about the dilution of their culture (and to some, their bloodlines) by other ethnicities. We didn't always have a system like this. It evolved into what it is, and now people feel morally righteous about upholding laws their own ancestors never were subject to. And not a small number of people who did navigate the system but want everyone to have to pay the same dues. It's reminiscent to me of the folks with 4 year engineering degrees feeling salty that other folks have gotten into the industry through bootcamps, for a fraction of the time and money.
- OkayPhysicist 1y agoOkay, so let's make it a lot easier to immigrate legally. Except that's not what the Right is doing at the moment. They're simultaneously attacking legal, "the right way" immigration, and illegal immigration, because they don't care about "fair and legal" anything, they're just racist.
- acjohnson55 1y ago> "In the fields, I would say 70% of the workers are gone," she said in an interview. "If 70% of your workforce doesn't show up, 70% of your crop doesn't get picked and can go bad in one day. Most Americans don't want to do this work. Most farmers here are barely breaking even. I fear this has created a tipping point where many will go bust." Presumably, there will be bigger pocketed entities waiting in the wings to snap up some distressed assets.
- appleaday1 1y agodo they have a source on many americans dont want to do this type of work part?
- readthenotes1 1y agoThere's a funny video associated with this campaign from 2010 https://ufw.org/allvoices-colbert-says-always-wanted-a-farm-worker-job-now-s-your-chance/ https://ufw.org/allvoices-colbert-says-always-wanted-a-farm-...
- kersplody 1y agoLook at UC Davis Gifford Center’s April 2024 “Farm Labor Issues in the 2020s” summary report: https://gifford.ucdavis.edu/events/past/april-4-2024-farm-labor-issues-in-the-2020s/farm-labor-issues-in-the-2020s-summary-report/ https://gifford.ucdavis.edu/events/past/april-4-2024-farm-la... Very few U.S.-born workers respond to job ads for seasonal crop work, Show up when work begins, or Stick around through the harvest season. "Even when wages reach—or exceed $20–$30 per hour, seasonal U.S. workers overwhelmingly opt out of field labor. That persistent gap is why American agriculture depends so heavily on immigrant and guest‐worker programs, and why mechanization continues to accelerate."
- aksjsnxkkxx 1y agoThe simple counter is to offer higher wages. We absolutely have the capital and tech to ensure people can make a decent living doing farm labor. It would require less billionaires and less chatgpt wrappers with billion dollar valuations.
- comrade1234 1y agoMaybe Americans will finally understand that their cheap food and lifestyle has been dependent on essentially illegal slave labor with no rights. You can harvest your crops with legal migrant workers with legal temporary visas and minimum wages and labor protections but you'll have to pay a few cents more for those strawberries.
- e40 1y agoIt's not even that. Most Americans would not do that job for $25/hr ($52k/yr). It's hard, backbreaking work.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> essentially illegal slave labor California’s farm workers are not slaves…
- burningChrome 1y agoUsed to stay and work in ND during my Summers in college. One of the businesses I worked for was a bin sealing company. The owner was a successful farmer and during the Summer, he would have two large families get work visas and would come up and help from Mexico during the Summer harvest. It was basically three months of sun up to sun down work. At the end of the Summer, the family would celebrate and put on a huge fiesta and cook food for everybody. The farmer paid them extremely well and they would leave and go back to Mexico in August, fondly talking about coming back again the following Summer when the farmer needed them again. This was my first exposure to migrant labor. It was clear the farmer took the appropriate steps to get visas and paid the family well for their efforts. Likewise, the family was thankful for the work, good pay and with the relationship. When I moved back to Minnesota after college, I started playing hockey again and two of my teammates had done something similar and worked on poultry and cattle farms in the southern part of the state. Their stories were the complete opposite of what I had experienced. Illegals were used all over the operation. They were paid roughly $3/hour cash to work 12-16 hour shifts. If they spoke up about safety issues or the pay, a supervisor would pick them up, buy them a ticket back to the border and drop them off at the bus station. The stories they had were pretty eye opening to say the least. I felt dumb for being so naive to think farmers just did everything legally.
- tosser0001 1y agoI know little about farming or harvesting, but I’m curious what types of crops actually require manual harvesting? Do we really need to rely on stoop labor to hand-pick crops, or has a relatively cheap labor pool allowed farmers to avoid the costs of automation? If labor is to be in perennial short supply in the future, I wonder if American farmers will simply be forced to turn to crops that allow machine harvesting.
- comrade1234 1y agoThere are some crops that they've been trying for years to harvest robotically but they just require too many input variables that a human can see in seconds but a robot just can't do it yet. Do a search on harvesting cabbages with robots, for example they're close but not yet there.
- korse 1y agoThings that are grown on trees and bushes and are also delicate. Most cereal crops and plenty of ground/root vegetable cultivation is already mostly automated.
- analog31 1y agoAnything that's processed into something else is likely to be more readily automated, such as grains and canned or frozen produce.
- yahoozoo 1y agoWhy doesn’t the government subsidize wages/salaries as an incentive for “Americans who don’t want to do this work for such low pay”? Or I guess they could just automate more.
- comrade1234 1y agoAmericans don't have to do it. You can have legal seasonal workers on temporary visas. We do it every year here in Switzerland for the wine harvest and for the ski resorts with workers from Portugal for example.
- yahoozoo 1y agoI think overstaying visas is a significant issue in America and one of the reasons they have so many illegal immigrants.
- Ekaros 1y agoWhy subsidise? If the plantation owners want the crops to be picked, they just have to pay enough to find willing worker. And then increase the price of food to still make same overall profit margin. It is how free market capitalism should work.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoNon-syndicated source: https://www.reuters.com/business/immigration-raids-leave-crops-unharvested-california-farms-risk-2025-06-30/ https://www.reuters.com/business/immigration-raids-leave-cro...
- tzs 1y agoI heard a report on the radio about a similar situation with cherry farmers in Washington. Many farmers are in a cycle where they have to take out loans to pay for maintaining their orchards during the off-season, and then make enough during cherry season to pay those loans off but not enough that they won't need a loan for the next off-season. So far there have not actually been any mass raids on farms in Washington, and not many cases of migrants being arrested when driving from California to Washington for the cherry harvest but the workers know what is happening in California and are afraid it will happen in Washington so many are staying away. What was baffling is that many of the farmers put the blame for this is on bad actors on the left spreading fear among the workers.