4 ms·
[stub for offtopicness]
by dang 1y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
- zkmon 1y agoThis is probably the slowest branch of the sciences, not able to get out of labs even after a century. The fundamental problem appears to be that we are trying to control probabilistic nature using concrete real world things. I suspect this is not allowed, at least at an industrial scale. At some point humanity might need to stick what they need instead of what they can.
- mr_mitm 1y agoWhat do you mean? We have been profiting massively from the fruits of QM for the last five decades easily. Transistors, LEDs, Lasers, MRT imaging, solar panels, CCD cameras, etc. have arguably changed the world and would not have been possible without QM. It came out of the lab a long time ago.
- colechristensen 1y agoNot to mention the entire science of chemistry and everything made from it. Quantum mechanics started with the description of electron orbitals around an atom; how they work is the foundation of chemistry.
- kqr 1y agoI think GP was thinking of quantum computers, maybe?
- colechristensen 1y ago[flagged]
- novaomnidev 1y agoThat’s engineering not science
- kgwgk 1y ago>not able to get out of labs even after a century It got out of labs in a quite spectacular way in the summer of 1945, eighty years ago.
- isolli 1y agoThought experiment: did we really need quantum mechanics to build an atom bomb? Couldn't we have built one with a model of the atom based on classical particles (with protons leading to a chain reaction)? Is either the quantized or the uncertainty aspect of QM necessary for this?
- adastra22 1y agoThe very idea of matter and energy being quantized into particles and photons is the starting point of “quantum” mechanics.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoNucleon orbitals rely a little on Pauli exclusion principle, which you need to add as an ad hoc hypothesis every time in classical physics.
- perihelions 1y agoMost of the science going into the Manhattan Project was experimental measurements and phenomenological models, not fundamental physics at the QM level. There were no usable quantum-mechanical models of nuclear physics at that point. No; they didn't really need it.
- andrepd 1y agoWhat has physics ever done for us? Apart from computers, satellites, planes, communications, sensors, and health... What has physics ever done for us? The roads? Well obviously the roads go without saying!
- the-mitr 1y agoNature is probabilistic. And we know how to calculate those probabilities, that is one of the core ideas of quantum mechanics. Why is it "not allowed"? By whom? Since you are commenting on HN, you are already are using the very mature applications of QM out of laboratory. The proverbial cat (is it Schröedinger's?) is out of the bag!
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoTheory is probabilistic, nature isn't.
- IAmBroom 1y agoNature doesn't obey your opinions.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoThat's an argument against solipsism at best, not much else.
- nathan_compton 1y agoI don't know dog, that is a pretty bold statement given everything we can presently firmly say about the universe. Like we can imagine some kind of purely deterministic thing going on but when the rubber meets the road the best ways of working stuff out seem to very strongly imply some fundamental indeterminism. No one likes it, but thats the way it is.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoWhen the rubber meets the road the best ways of working stuff out is to shut up and calculate, you don't figure out anything by assuming unobservable fundamental indeterminism.
- nathan_compton 1y ago
- chermi 1y agoWhat a take. All of modern technology, materials, solid state, semiconductors, transistors... And uhhh did you forget chemistry itself?
- zkmon 1y agoJust came back from work to see all the battering and downvoting. Clam down. I meant Quantum computing using qubits. Apologies for not being specific. Quantum computing itself is also a century old (almost)? Where are we with this? Jeez - HN is brutal. Even a bot could have understood the context I meant.
- wasabi991011 1y agoQuantum computing is very much not a century old
- dave333 1y ago[flagged]
- thyristan 1y agoIt was known at the time that elliptical orbitals or even more complex shapes are necessary, because certain atoms and molecules exhibit axes and binding angles. Water for example. That excludes spheres.
- dave333 1y agoAccording to BLP for a molecule like water the electrons don't form distinct bonds or lone pairs in the quantum sense. Instead, they form a single, shared, physical electron shell (a prolate spheroidal orbitsphere) that encompasses all three nuclei. The bent shape and specific bond angle are the direct, deterministic result of the nuclei and this orbitsphere arranging themselves into the most stable, lowest energy configuration dictated by classical electrodynamics and mechanics, without any reference to quantum uncertainty, probability, or abstract orbital shapes.
- thyristan 1y ago> The bent shape and specific bond angle are the direct, deterministic result of the nuclei That then contradicts the fact that ions form orbitals according to their number of electrons, not according to their nuclear properties. That was also known before quantum mechanics.
- dave333 1y agoNot just nuclei - "result of the nuclei and this orbitsphere arranging themselves into the most stable, lowest energy configuration" - you cut off your quote too early.
- thyristan 1y agoIn that case it could have worked maybe. But not every idea is known to every scientist, and often things are skipped or forgotten. I guess this is one of those instances then.
- randomNumber7 1y ago[flagged]
- thyristan 1y agoWhen a "bang" takes 30 years and costs 100 billion units of money, progress will be slow. "Something different" will have to be within the margin of error of all the successful "bangs". So this something won't likely be cheaper or faster. Physics is just at a state of sophistication where the scale of things to look at is so small or so vast that quick and cheap isn't possible anymore. At least for the last 100 years or so.
- kgwgk 1y agoIf this is the definition of offtopic then 90% of HN comments are offtopic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law at work!
- dang 1y agoHard to respond to this unless you say specifically why! Which comment do you think should not have been treated as offtopic?
- kgwgk 1y agoIn the context of a submission about “A century of QM” that says things like “To celebrate 100 years of quantum mechanics, the CERN Courier looks back at the impact of this theory and examines how it keeps delivering new puzzles, experimental ideas and technologies.” the following comment may be completely misguided but I didn’t find it offtopic (maybe offreality): “This is probably the slowest branch of the sciences, not able to get out of labs even after a century.” But now I see that the author says that he meant quantum computing so the comment makes even less sense and is indeed slightly offtopic.
- dang 1y agoThere are degrees of offtopicness, of course. In this case I moved the subthread because it was a generic tangent that had little to do with the specific article. Good on-topic subthreads usually show some sign of contact with the body of the article—not just the title, and certainly not the most generic phrase (in this case "quantum mechanics") that can be abstracted from the title. But one can always argue particular cases either way and I agree that the counter-argument was stronger for that one.