4 ms·
> be angry at those who didn't follow through with promises to severely reduce funding to their police departments in 2020 This was tried. It generated a gener
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> be angry at those who didn't follow through with promises to severely reduce funding to their police departments in 2020
This was tried. It generated a generational backlash against the left as petty crime and visible homelessness rose.
To the extent police reform has historically worked, it’s been by rebooting a police department. (Think: replacing the Mets with the NYPD.) Not replacing police with a hippie circle.
- panic 1y agoWhere was it tried? My understanding is that even Minneapolis didn't follow through with it.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Where was it tried? Chesa Boudin. New York with cashless bail and non-prosecution of petty crimes. That fuck in Chicago. Defund the police was a marquee policy and messaging failure that underlined why radical minorities capturing the Democratic Party cause it to lose elections.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> New York with cashless bail and non-prosecution of petty crimes. What does that have to do with "defund the police"? Bail money doesn't go into their pockets.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoIt was part of the police reform initiative. I supported it. But it massively increased the street population of recidivist bastards in a way I didn’t expect.
- ceejayoz 1y agoConflating "police reform" and "defund the police" is disingenuous.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Conflating "police reform" and "defund the police" is disingenuous In New York they were one and the same. The latter simply representing the most extreme expression of the former. I remember dropping into a leftist conference in Philadelphia years ago where several folks who would become the face of post-Covid police reform were there, including Boudin. At the end of the day they all conceded that their goal was abolishing this, that and the other thing.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> In New York they were one and the same. As a NY resident: lol. I don't doubt you'll find activists espousing both "defund the police" and "end cash bail" policies at the same time. That doesn't make them the same policy.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> That doesn't make them the same policy Oh, they’re totally different policies. But they’re basically the same politics. And they both generated a backlash, one against messaging (because it was too stupid to implement) and one against policy (because it created more visible crime).
- sapphicsnail 1y agoA leftist conference? I don't think actual leftists have much say on policy.
- potato3732842 1y agoIt was never about the recidivist bastards and always about the normal guy with a job he doesn't want to lose not losing that job when he can't come up with bail for a DUI. At least where I was it was considered kind of a given the recidivist bastards would get out on bail and that the bondsman getting paid really doesn't affect outcomes.
- jahewson 1y agoBail bonds exist.
- ceejayoz 1y agoAnd yet, there are plenty of people who can't rustle up a couple hundred bucks for them, and wind up in jail for months/years awaiting trial.
- ghushn3 1y agoIn fact, 70% of jail population is not convicted of a crime. Seven-Zero. Roughly half a million people are in jail despite not being convicted of anything. That's roughly 25% of the incarcerated population in the US. 1/4 people behind bars are (presumed) innocent right now, even if they may later be found guilty. That's a problem. Being in jail for a few weeks or even a few days can totally fuck someone's life over, costing them a job, a relationship, their health, or worse.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> It was never about the recidivist bastards and always about the normal guy with a job he doesn't want to lose not losing that job when he can't come up with bail for a DUI And that’s why I supported it. But for every one of the latter there are many of the former because they started cycling through arrests so fast. Keep the recidivist bastard in jail, on the other hand, and they are incapacitated for the time being. I’ll admit I didn’t see the utility of that until it was too late.
- ribosometronome 1y ago>>> be angry at those who didn't follow through with promises to severely reduce funding to their police departments in 2020 >>This was tried. It generated a generational backlash against the left as petty crime and visible homelessness rose. >Chesa Boudin. Chesa Boudin is not a police budget, that's a completely unserious nonsequitor. SF's police budget rose throughout the defund the police movement, just not as high as initially allocated. https://abc7news.com/post/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-department-funding/12321818/ https://abc7news.com/post/sfpd-budget-defund-the-police-depa...
- supplied_demand 1y ago==That fuck in Chicago.== Not sure what this is adding to the discussion, but eliminating cash bail has been a success in Illinois. That’s why you don’t hear the right talking about it anymore. Crime in Chicago has fallen every year since it went into effect. https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/cash-bail-illinois-one-year-later/ https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/cash-bail-illinois-one-...
- qingcharles 1y agoIt also allowed those with petty crimes to be released, while those with say, homicide charges, to be held. Previously, if you had lots of liquid money, you could bail out for murder no problem. I was locked up in Chicago with guys that had $50 bail and nobody to pay it for them.
- tptacek 1y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to argue here, but if your premise is that people charged with homicide are given pretrial release in the current no-cash-bail system, no, that's not the case. It's possible that's what you're saying too: that the current system, based on risk assessments rather than liquidity, is better than what preceded it (I'd agree).
- qingcharles 1y agoI might have worded it badly? I was trying to say that the system was previously unfair as it allowed violent crimes with long potential sentences bail (if you were rich), while those with petty offenses would be held (because they were poor). I'm not sure if there is a perfect system, since everyone should be given the benefit of potential innocence, and jailing anyone who might end up being acquitted is a problem.
- tptacek 1y agoChicago did not defund its police department.
- mlinhares 1y agoCrime did not rose, crime has been in a downward trajectory for decades, this is likely one of the reasons the crackdown on illegal immigrants is so bad, prison owners are noticing they might lose their cash cow and needs a new population to imprison.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Crime did not rose Murders didn’t rise. Petty crime and open-air drug use absolutely did. > prison owners are noticing they might lose their cash cow This is nonsense.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoIn addition to what JumpCrisscross said, illegal immigrants are not going to be long-term prison population; they're going to be deported. (At least, that's the campaign promise.) So I don't see how that benefits prison owners.
- ceejayoz 1y agohttps://www.npr.org/2025/06/04/nx-s1-5417980/private-prisons-and-local-jails-are-ramping-up-as-ice-detention-exceeds-capacity https://www.npr.org/2025/06/04/nx-s1-5417980/private-prisons... > Nearly 90% of people in ICE custody are held in facilities run by for-profit, private companies. Two of the largest, Geo Group and CoreCivic, are working to increase their ability to meet the administration's demand. CoreCivic used to be called the "Corrections Corporation of America". GEO Group used to be "Wackenhut Corrections Corporation". It should be unsurprising that the folks who make money building and running large, secure facilities to detain people would be interested in doing the same for ICE.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoOh yeah, they benefit. What I’m calling nonsense is the idea that Geo Group is the reason Stephen Miller is in charge. There are more fundamental roots to the anti-immigrant agenda than a convenient corporate bogeyman.
- stouset 1y ago> This was tried. It generated a generational backlash against the left as petty crime and visible homelessness rose. Crime has been on a downward trend for a generation, outside of a few areas. In San Francisco specifically, crime also increased due to police officers quietly going on strike against policies they disagreed with. Now that police officers are actually doing their jobs again, shockingly, crime is rapidly falling. What has actually increased is sensationalist coverage in the media, which you're right, has created a significant political backlash.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> In San Francisco specifically, crime also increased due to police officers quietly going on strike against policies they disagreed with If I recall correctly it was the DA refusing to prosecute just about anything.
- myvoiceismypass 1y agoNot sure if "recall" was a pun or not... But the recall campaign for DA Boudin started a month after the 2020 election, so he was effectively DA for 10 months at that point, including during the heart of the pandemic. Interestingly, it was also right after he started trying to implement police accountability reforms in response to the Floyd backlash that year. He did de-prioritize drug prosecution right at the time of major fentanyl spikes in SF, so not a good look.
- stouset 1y agoThis was the sensationalist media narrative, yes. Chesa got kicked out. Brooke Jenkins took over to much fanfare. Aaaand nothing material really changed, either with enforcement or with prosecution. The media stopped talking about it though. SFPD hadn’t been doing their jobs for far, far longer than Chesa’s tenure. I moved here in 2013 and their non-enforcement practices were already legendary. Blaming Chesa for being in office for like 10 months in 2019-2020 is a hell of a cop out (pun intended). Even if it were true, it wouldn’t in any way excuse the police for choosing not to do the job they’re paid to do.
- Ar-Curunir 1y agoDon't speak bullshit. There was more media outrage hullabaloo around the idea of reducing cop funding than there was any actual reduction. Especially because the cops went on strike to ensure that no cuts would happen. Police forces across the US have never seen higher funding rates.
- rightbyte 1y ago> It generated a generational backlash against the left as petty crime and visible homelessness rose With "the left" you mean the SF DA?
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoNo, the entire police reform agenda and I’d argue progressive wing of the Democratic Party as a whole. “Defund the police” was a monumental fuckup.
- stouset 1y agoIt was a branding fuckup more than a policy fuckup. The idea that we want types of response units other than armed gunmen available to respond to certain types of emergencies isn’t exactly radical. We don’t send the police for medical emergencies or house fires. We send personnel with dedicated training for those types of events.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> It was a branding fuckup more than a policy fuckup. And frankly, the folks who turned "liberal" into a dirty word can make any branding into a branding fuckup. That's what they have Fox News for.
- soupbowl 1y agoModern liberals made "liberal" a bad word.
- actionfromafar 1y agoMaybe... but something doesn't sit right with that assertion. Anyone against concentration camps now gets the "liberal" slur thrown at them. Why is that?
- stouset 1y agoAs someone who grew up with a dad who listened to conservative talk radio, "liberal" has been used as an epithet for at least thirty years. I was genuinely stunned in high school when I met people who would willingly refer to themselves as liberals. You'll have to pardon me for rolling my eyes at the notion that modern liberals have somehow made the term a bad word given the general path of conservatism over the last several decades, not to mention the last eight years specifically.
- sagarm 1y agoSF did not reduce police funding. They quiet quit anyway.
- cardiffspaceman 1y agoQuiet quitting does not make the position legally vacant, such that the employer knows they need to fill it. The employer has to notice that the employee is not performing, and then replace that employee. Those steps are often harder than you’d think.
- sagarm 1y agoSFPD has plenty of unused budget for hiring; they aren't hiring either.
- loeg 1y ago"Defund the police" was never actually tried. (This is not a defense of defunding -- I agree it would have similarly bad outcomes! But you can't just point at changes that weren't defunding the police and say it was tried.)
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> "Defund the police" was never actually tried Isn’t this a No True Scotsmen problem? Police budges were trimmed. Police forces were cut. Police remit, in the form of decriminalisation, was reduced. No jurisdiction abolished law enforcement (though San Francisco de facto got close). But I’d say those count as defunding the police to an extent. Even then, we got disaster. Shockingly quickly. Shockingly powerfully. There is no threshold theory that suggests you get magical results cutting the police force by 30% instead of 3%; it’s thus reasonable to extrapolate and assume you get more of the bad.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> No jurisdiction abolished law enforcement (though San Francisco de facto got close). What year did that occur on their budget chart? https://x.com/chrisarvinsf/status/1399863666938310663 https://x.com/chrisarvinsf/status/1399863666938310663
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoDe facto, not de jure. SFPD went AWOL for a few months. One can’t complain about that and then claim it would be better if they were fired. (Also, your own chart shows a ‘20 dip.)
- ceejayoz 1y ago“De facto abolition of policing” or “dip”? Pick one! Cops throwing a tantrum over a dip would seem to prove a point, too.
- 1y ago
- lazyasciiart 1y agoIt was not tried, and saying that it was is a fundamentally false claim that is actively pushing public opposition to the idea supported by lies. It’s as reasonable as saying don’t vote for democrats because they have a pedophile office under a pizza store. Are there a bunch of people who were convinced by this lie? Yes. Does that make it anything other than a manipulative lie to say? No.
- gamblor956 1y agoIn Los Angeles, crime on the Metro public transportation system has fallen by almost 70% in the three months since the LAPD was booted off the job and replaced by...security guards. This is pretty good evidence that high crime rates in cities with large police forces are directly related to the police force not actually doing the job it's already being paid to do. (LA Metro was forced to use LAPD for security a few decades ago, at which point crime rates went from very low to skyrocketing. LAPD serviced the Metro contract exclusively with officers that were in overtime hours (1.5x pay) so at best could only provide 2/3rd of the contracted manpower. That changed earlier this year; the contract was terminated for cause and LAPD was replaced with contract security guards. The contract security guards make substantially less than LAPD officers, so Metro is currently able to field a security presence about 5x the size as the LAPD force. Metro reported this that crime has fallen dramatically in just 2 months.)
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoFor what it’s worth, I agree with you. We need different police. Not our existing police reformed. But also not no police. There is a vocal minority of idiots who want no police. At all.