3 ms·
Strawman. He wants a process to dispute them unilaterally holdin on to your money, not to do business with you.
by tomjen3 14y ago
Strawman. He wants a process to dispute them unilaterally holdin on to your money, not to do business with you.
- CamperBob2 14y agoI agree. Holding my money for 180 days with no appeals process amounts to a tort, and should be considered unconscionable and unenforceable when it appears in a contract. They shouldn't even be allowed to ask for that, because once one player creates such a policy, the rest will follow. Thought experiment: why not make it 5 years, instead of just 180 days? If a 5-year term were to become "standard industry practice," to paraphrase Dan, who could argue otherwise? They simply should not be able to exercise that kind of arbitrary power, at least not without being subject to standard banking regulations that can be modified as needed to balance the interests of financial institutions and their customers.
- dangrossman 14y agoThis is the same hold policy at every regulated bank. It comes down from Visa and MasterCard's operating agreements. Its presence in standard merchant contracts predates PayPal's very existence. It's not arbitrary, either; it's the period in which the people that paid that money can file a chargeback or bank reversal to recover it.
- CamperBob2 14y agoIt comes down from Visa and MasterCard's operating agreements. Thus illustrating one of my favorite pet sayings: "Any sufficiently dominant corporation is indistinguishable from a government." Nothing you are saying actually makes this policy right; you are simply reiterating its existence.