5 ms·
The Scourge of Arial (2001)
- kqr 1y agoWell-written. I learned a lot! Would have been interesting to also see a note about Verdana, and know if Microsoft shifting away from Arial as the default sans serif has changed its popularity as much as one might think.
- simondotau 1y agoFor a while IKEA used Verdana as their corporate typeface, to the howls of despair from font aficionados everywhere. Personally, I loved it. I think it really encapsulated the idea of it’s so bad that it’s good and really suited the “assembled at home“ vibe.
- duskwuff 1y agoI don't understand the Verdana hate. It's a decent screen font, especially at low resolutions. It may not be ideal for print, but that isn't what it was designed for.
- qu1j0t3 1y ago1) Overexposure. Same problem that Georgia has: Otherwise a very serviceable Matthew Carter design. 2) It's a screen font. In print and display applications, it really does look gross. Source: A Friendly neighbourhood typographer
- Cockbrand 1y agoTwo very relevent XKCD comics: https://xkcd.com/1015/ https://xkcd.com/1015/ https://xkcd.com/3113/ https://xkcd.com/3113/ Source: someone who picked up a bit of knowledge about typography, but never used it professionally
- rbanffy 1y agoNo curse is worse than having a fine taste for kerning.
- criddell 1y ago> It's a screen font. With the pixel density of typical displays these days being as high as they are (phones are often 300-400+ PPI), I think this distinction isn't what it used to be.
- elevation 1y agoThese days, Verdana is generally an indicator of either organisational decay or incompetence, especially when used in print, which it wasn’t designed for. It hasn’t been a default in tools for decades, so it suggests either the organization hasn’t been able to afford to refresh the design for 25 years or the designer is incompetent. Hate is a strong word, but Verdana is almost certainly the wrong font for your business branding in 2025.
- simondotau 1y agoSometimes, something that seems like an "obviously terrible decision" to subject matter experts turns out to be inconsequential, or perhaps even good. Ask a corporate identity expert in 1998 if you should name your big important company "Google" and they'd vomit in your face. Of course it looks very different in hindsight. Contrary to your claim, approximately nobody with a professionally designed corporate identity used Verdana in a printed context like IKEA did. It was a "wrong" choice like Google was the "wrong" name for a search engine. It's a perfectly serviceable font, like Times New Roman. And that font was good enough for The Times of London, for goodness sakes.
- elevation 1y ago> approximately nobody with a professionally designed corporate identity used Verdana in a printed context like IKEA did Exactly my point. Verdana gives unprofessional vibes because a pro wouldn’t use it. In a Midwest town you’ll see a few sun faded signs, printed menus, and service vehicles emblazoned with Verdana. In every case, my assumption is that “the owner made our logo in PowerPoint in 1999 and won’t let anyone change it” or “the technician at the vehicle decal shop pick a font for us”. IKEA having used the font for a season isn’t enough to override the sense of neglect. If you’re designing print media for business, or a logo of all things, avoid Verdana.
- simondotau 1y ago> Verdana gives unprofessional vibes because a pro wouldn’t use it. Exactly my point. The name "Google" gives unprofessional vibes because a brand identity pro would never approve that name. And because of those unprofessional vibes, nobody ever took Google seriously. In reality, font choice is a very surface level analysis. Ever since quality fonts became commoditised, it stopped being a significant signal of professionalism. A top designer could put Comic Sans next to Trajan and make it look like a million bucks; a bad designer could typeset in Gotham and still look like a high school student project. "Unprofessional font" is a dead meme.
- musicale 1y agoVerdana is underrated. It's a legible screen font, and I greatly prefer it to the dreadful spindly font (Segoe UI?) that Windows 11 uses.
- lynguist 1y agoWhich was recently replaced by Aptos!
- currysausage 1y agoAptos replaced Calibri in Word and Excel.
- RedShift1 1y agoA terrible mistake.
- Y-bar 1y agoWasn't this exactly what people were hating it for? IKEA used it for print and lots of large prints at that, not just pixel displays? I never said or wrote anything about it as far as I can remember, but I do think it looked worse than their previous typeface. Verdana is quite okay, if not good even, for body text. But it looks like they have changed or customised their typeface recently, the digits and letters like "y" do not look like standard Verdana any more.
- OskarS 1y agoVerdana isn’t terrible, it’s just that it’s so much worse than fonts like Frutiger and Gill Sans that inspired it (similarly to Arial/Helvetica). It’s screams ”free font that kinda rips off really good ones”, and for a giant company like IKEA, you’d expect them to do better. Especially since their previous typeface was Futura, an all-timer.
- dist-epoch 1y agoI'm sorry, but since when do we hate on HN free alternatives to proprietary ones? "free Linux which rips off really good UNIXes" "free IDE which rips off really good IntelliJ" "free music production app which rips off really good Logic Pro"
- OskarS 1y agoFirst off all, these fonts are not "free" as in "free software", they are owned by Microsoft and to use them you have to agree to a Microsoft EULA (technically, though this isn't enforced). They're "free as in beer", not "free as in freedom" (this is my understanding at least, welcome to be corrected on this point). Second: the objection isn't necessarily just that Verdana is free, it's that it's not a very good-looking font. Certainly in most people's opinion, it's nothing like as cool as Futura. IKEA, a massive multi-national company and an iconic brand, can and should do better. They say they did this to "align print and web", presumably meaning they wanted to use a font that was guaranteed to work in all browsers, but that's such a shame for print, really sacrificing great typography on the altar of browser support. Third: font design is an art and a craft just like graphic design, photography, furniture design, script-writing, music production, whatever. There are certainly people who think literally everything should be free (as in "every Hollywood release should be Creative Commons"), but that's a rather extreme position. If you think it's a good thing that IKEA pays graphic designers to design their catalog, and furniture designers to design their furniture, you should think it's a good thing that IKEA pays typographers for their typeface design. There are certainly issues with licensing in the world of typeface design (the emerging Monotype monopoly is really disturbing, for instance), but expecting giant companies to pay for good typography instead of using bad free typography is not some "anti-free software" stance.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 1y agoI appreciate how Slack stuck to their guns (so to speak) with the "swastika made of dicks" controversy. https://x.com/ItsBadvertising/status/1085972315094044672 https://x.com/ItsBadvertising/status/1085972315094044672 https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/nicolenguyen/slack-new-logo-design-backlash https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/nicolenguyen/slack-new-... I'll never be able to unsee it. At least it doesn't spin.
- DonHopkins 1y agoAs an old school font snob, I'm a huge fan of Zapf Dingbats, especially those elegant pointing hands. None of the modern brutalist hand emojis can hold a candle to them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zapf_Dingbats https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zapf_Dingbats https://web.archive.org/web/20220705073411/https://www.inverse.com/article/3680-dingbats-creator-dies https://web.archive.org/web/20220705073411/https://www.inver... Zapf Dingbats’ little pointing hands are less mere bullets than distilled manicules: their sleek, tapering wrists and attenuated index fingers fuse medieval marginalia’s flourishes with mid-century modernism’s rigor, transforming a humble signpost into a compact, almost fetishized arrow of attention. They're sleek and minimal enough to function as crisply hard modern bullets, yet they retain a soft, calligraphic, Victorian flourish (the very essence of the medieval manicule, digitized by Hermann Zapf in 1978), making them perfectly at home in a vintage Beagle Bros Apple ][ Software Catalog. http://asimov.applefritter.com/documentation/advertisements/beagle_brothers/Beagle_Bros_Bulletin_and_Software_Catalog_volume%200_number%2010_1987.pdf http://asimov.applefritter.com/documentation/advertisements/... https://beagle.applearchives.com/ https://beagle.applearchives.com/ How would you like to buy a new pair of hands? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQVgg_yUN20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQVgg_yUN20
- WillAdams 1y agoFor another reason for this, look up the Linotype trademark case where Microsoft was sued for the pixel font names "Tms Rmn", and "Helv" --- it was to say the least, unpalatable for MS to do business with a company which had trounced them in court.
- NaOH 1y agoPreviously: The Scourge of Arial (2001) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10538384 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10538384 - Nov 2015 (26 comments)
- Spooky23 1y agoIt’s very refreshing to read something about typefaces that isn’t glazing the magnificence of Helvetica!
- simondotau 1y agoHelvetica is like vanilla. Often mischaracterised as plain and “default choice”, when done well it’s a distinct taste all of its own. In the hands of a master chef, it can be spectacular. But the majority of it is low effort and low quality.
- qu1j0t3 1y agoYeah basically true; it's described as "neutral" but it absolutely is not. I have to admit, though, the New Haas revival is so amazingly good that it makes me want to like Helvetica.
- bondarchuk 1y agoWould that be Neue Haas Unica?
- WillAdams 1y agoPair this with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helvetica_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helvetica_(film) (though it's marred by Arial being passed off for Helvetica in at least one showing)
- esafak 1y agoAlternatively: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8PdffUfoF0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8PdffUfoF0
- jhbadger 1y agoThey are both grotesque fonts -- and that it isn't an insult, that's a technical term! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sans-serif#Neo-grotesque https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sans-serif#Neo-grotesque
- esafak 1y agoEven in the art department, Microsoft ships a shoddy knockoff...
- musicale 1y agoSo Microsoft's TrueType deal with Apple didn't include the Helvetica TrueType font(s) that Apple included with macOS? Apple's Geneva seems to be another take on Helvetica, though designed to match the Mac's original bitmap font.
- WillAdams 1y agoNo, since Apple had to license the design/trademark rights from Monotype. Geneva is a quite different design as evinced by the result of Bigelow & Holmes vector interpretation.
- musicale 1y agoBitmap New York and Geneva are beautiful - I get the chance to admire them (along with the rest of the original Mac's bitmap desktop interface) every day via the "Macintosh" dynamic wallpaper included with macOS. We may have many more pixels now, but modern Apple could do better at getting the visual details right for its modern UI designs.
- nottorp 1y agoI wonder what font was used on my screen for rendering the article.
- fainpul 1y agoMaybe I'm missing a joke here, but if you're actually wondering: rightlick on text -> inspect -> find the font tab For me it was Proxima Nova.
- nottorp 1y agoI'm not a web dev. Is what is displayed in the font tab (also Proxima Nova for me) what is actually used on screen? Or does the browser do its own substitutions? Tbh i expected Helvetica to be specified :)
- bombcar 1y agoIf you look in Inspect it’ll show “as rendered” somewhere. As a developer you can tell it what fonts to use, in a a particular order: “my font, closest default font, a windows font that’s ok, anything sans serif” is often what is used.
- michalpleban 1y agoBrowsers can download fonts from the web and use them to display text on web pages. You can Google "Web fonts" to get a lot of info, but basically you just put the font file on your server and the browser downloads it and uses it.
- DonHopkins 1y agoThat poor defenseless font Arial needs Mike Lacher to give it a voice, throw down the gauntlet, and go to the mat in defense of its honor, like he did with Comic Sans! https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/im-comic-sans-asshole https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/im-comic-sans-asshole Now it's getting hammered with Papyrus, which has earned two SNL skits for its appearance in Avatar.
- hocuspocus 1y ago> When Microsoft made TrueType the standard font format for Windows 3.1, they opted to go with Arial rather than Helvetica, probably because it was cheaper That's a myth. Microsoft paid a lot of money to MonoType, as I believe they needed to task several full-time employees with the manual hinting of those fonts. The deal probably saved the foundry from bankruptcy. "As to the widespread notion that Microsoft did not want to pay licensing fees, Allan Haley has publicly stated, more than once, that the amount of money Microsoft paid over the years for the development of Arial could finance a small country." https://www.paulshawletterdesign.com/2011/09/blue-pencil-no-18%E2%80%94some-history-about-arial/ https://www.paulshawletterdesign.com/2011/09/blue-pencil-no-...
- rbanffy 1y agoSo, they COULD have used Helvetica and spared us a lot of pain. It doesn’t make me hate Arial any less.
- kazinator 1y ago> After all, most people would have trouble telling the difference between a serif and a sans serif typeface. Surely not after a one minute lecture on what is a serif? Elitist sounding nonsense.
- kazinator 1y agoComputer Modern or GTFO! :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Modern https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_Modern
- Disposal8433 1y agoI'm in love with Concrete Roman (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_Roman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concrete_Roman) used in Concrete Mathematics. Let's fight.
- ygritte 1y agoIronically, the article itself uses an Arial-like font. You cannot distinguish the lowercase ell from the uppercase aye. The scourge continues.