9 ms·
The author of this piece, Minxin Pei, has been writing about national policy in China for a long time for a variety of publications. I get the sense, from what
by tokenadult 14y ago
The author of this piece, Minxin Pei, has been writing about national policy in China for a long time for a variety of publications. I get the sense, from what I remember of his earlier writings, that his own views on issues have been updated by observing the path that China's development has followed since the end of the Cultural Revolution (back when I began studying the Chinese language and Sinology). There are an increasing number of observers who think the current governance and policies of China are unsustainable. I too think much of the gee-whiz reporting about China's "inevitable rise" in the last few years is very reminiscent of overoptimistic predictions of "Japan as Number One" back in the 1980s. Most likely, the more entrenched democracy and ability to criticize the government openly that the United States has as compared to China will help the United States muddle through and continue to be the world's sole superpower. First-generation immigrants from China like Pei will help that process of the United States adjusting to new world realities of the twenty-first century.
- 001sky 14y agoChina is of a order of magnitude larger than Japan. 1200m vs 120m people. If china modernizes along the lines of Japan pre WWI, it doesn't really matter if they "stall" at some stage. Chineese construction sites look like something out of the movie Contact. The game has been changed. US needs to be paying attention. Technology has increased the ability to "play catch up." On the other hand, its had minimal impact ability to differentiate amongst the more advanced economies.
- wisty 14y ago$7 Trillion GDP, 1344 Million people. $15 Trillion GDP, 312 Million people. When China only catches up to 25% of the US GDP per capita (where Brazil and Russia are), it will overtake the US. The the US will have to boast about its per-capita GDP, which really isn't that good (compared to many other OECD countries, most importantly Canada). I get the impression that a lot of US things go unchallenged (by most Americans) because they are "number 1", so they are obviously doing everything right.
- 001sky 14y agoTake a look at the data as single metro-region. Las Vegas has long been considered the world’s top gaming destination. Is that still true? Gaming revenue in Macau [China] this year probably will exceed $20 billion, which is a little over three times the size of Las Vegas ... Las Vegas still has more diversity in its various offerings, but it’s hard to say that it’s king of the hill in gambling. Edit: For Brevity List of countries GDP/Cap $USD Note: Macau =#6 (tie), USA =#16 1 Monaco 172,676 (2009 data) 6 Switzerland 80,391 (2011) — GuernseyJersey Channel Islands 76,413 (2007) — Macau 65,550 (2011) 16 United States 48,442 (2011) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28nominal%29_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28nom...
- RivieraKid 14y agoGDP adjusted for purchasing power parity is better for comparing countries: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_... But what matters most is quality of life per capita. In that aspect, the US is IMHO slightly behind most of western Europe, Canada, Australia, New Zeland, etc. Mostly because of wealth inequality.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 001sky 14y agoDuly noted, but "precision" in this sense is a red-herring. The point of the Macau example is 3x. In 2006 it was 1x. I will trade you $20B for $6B, and then worry about PPP. :D Edit: Your link also ranks Macau at #3 > Us #7.
- bwanab 14y agoIt would help your argument to get your facts right. The only OECD countries ahead of the US in GDP per capita are Luxembourg, Norway and Switzerland. Canada's is about 85% of the US (source http://stats.oecd.org/ http://stats.oecd.org/). It's true that many things go unchallenged by most Americans and there's no question to this American that we don't do everything right, but facts need to be respected. Edit: these are purchasing power parity numbers.
- eevilspock 14y agoBut China is still a fraction of the world (<20% pop, <6.5% land). Also, the collection of democratic countries put together is much larger than China. Also, India is a dark horse: democracy is inefficient in the short run but I believe does better in the long. I believe America is the last hegemony. Today's world is so much more intertwined economically and culturally than it ever has been in history. Borders are ever less relevant as cross-border commerce and communication between citizens increases (airplanes, then phones, and now the Internet). No single country will be able to dominate. That America does is an artifact of history. China, India and Brazil won't so much as displace it as pull it back down to everyone else's level.