23 ms·
I think Hacker News readers underestimate how sticky the typical customer is. The average subscriber to these services isn’t following a constant stream of LLM
by Aurornis 1y ago
I think Hacker News readers underestimate how sticky the typical customer is.
The average subscriber to these services isn’t following a constant stream of LLM news and jumping from platform to platform every time the leaderboard changes slightly. The average customer signs up and then inertia and familiarity take over. They stay signed and comfortable.
- ketzo 1y agoI mean — the person you’re describing is just a ChatGPT user and essentially nothing else, though, right? It explains OpenAI’s valuation but no one else
- martinald 1y agoI'm astonished at the stickiness of chatgpt though. It's clearly not the best platform/model but all my none tech friends just equate LLMs = ChatGPT (4o as well).
- DaSHacka 1y agoIt just benefitted from the Kleenex/Google effect due to being the first real mainstream breakthrough of GPT tech among average users ("normies"). I expect, whether OpenAI is even still around in 15+ years or not, that my grandparents will continue telling me about "that ChatGPT" well into the future.
- A_D_E_P_T 1y agoo3/o3-pro is probably the best model, or very close to being the best model, overall. It beats Grok 4 in writing/composition and analysis tasks. [1] Performance is a toss-up between o3 and Claude 4 Opus, but I find o3 easier to interact with and more trustworthy. (Less likely to push back against requests and more likely to attempt to fulfill them in good faith.) 4.5 is also great for certain things. Of all models, it's the second best writer. (DeepSeek R1 is the best prose stylist, surprisingly!) [1] - This is Grok 4: https://x.com/i/grok/share/e51O9rK0W7UaIN81nFBQoJDSs https://x.com/i/grok/share/e51O9rK0W7UaIN81nFBQoJDSs This is o3-pro, same question: https://chatgpt.com/s/t_68710185cf04819185dc25233280e46b https://chatgpt.com/s/t_68710185cf04819185dc25233280e46b o3 made fewer mistakes and drafted a more neatly structured and better written output.
- xnx 1y agoNo criticism, but I'm continually surprised how many comparisons leave out Gemini.
- Analemma_ 1y agoDoesn't that suggest a 200B valuation in xAI is stupid, though? Nobody is using Grok except Elon's fanboys, where do they imagine these sticky customers are going to come from?
- alexnes 1y agoPlease check google trends in regards to Grok (on a worldwide scale, and compare to openai, claude and deepseek). The winner is not clear at all. And grok is surprisingly popular.
- c-hendricks 1y agoHuh? I see pretty clear winner with chatgpt https://imgur.com/a/a5oUldD https://imgur.com/a/a5oUldD
- jowea 1y agoYeah, I think grandparent has a point, but at the same time, Google Search also didn't have a strong moat, or at least not one that couldn't be replicated in a few years, and it still positively dominated the market for decades.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Retric 1y agoDominated market sure, able to charge any kind of subscription fee no. If winning the LLM’s game long term means the product needs to compete on cost and be the best to win, that’s not going to be nearly as profitable in the near term.
- bryanlarsen 1y agoWhen the price is $0, the competitor has to be substantially better for consumers to switch. Bing reached quality comparable to Google, but never noticeably exceeded it. So people didn't switch. OTOH, the switch from Netscape -> IE6 -> Firefox -> Chrome did happen. But when the price is non-zero, that gives another dimension to compete on, and monopolies without significant barriers are much less common. It looks like good LLM's are going to have a price tag, so a monopoly is going to need a moat.
- rs186 1y agoCustomer of what, model? In terms of AI coding assistant, almost every product out there allows you switch to a different model with a single click. If Gemini is not giving you the answer you want, what do you do? Switch to Claude and bang you have it. The only thing that has some stickiness is products like ChatGPT. But that's so much more than just a model -- it's a product with many features smoothly integrated. xAI does not currently have any product that is sticky for the average user.
- bee_rider 1y agoIs the average consumer stuck to an LLM provider at this point, though? I guess the first one that normal people get attached to will be the one that gets into the Windows Start Menu, Siri, or whatever the Android equivalent is. Machines with LLM acceleration hardware are barely coming out at this point. I think it is early to expect people to really be stuck to anything.
- Gigachad 1y agoSure, until it starts to cost money. The average consumer will have a look at alternatives once their current one starts asking for $20/month.
- mercer 1y agoAlso don't forget the 'memory' feature. As LLM providers get better at tailoring the LLM to the user, and probably obfuscating the details on how this user-specific memory works, it will be harder to switch to another provider.