6 ms·
Bayeux Tapestry Will Return to the U.K. for the First Time in 950 Years
- conradfr 1y agoIt seems anyone involved in this in France are opposed to this except Macron. Although he has authority over them I'm not confident it will be moved there in the end.
- krona 1y agoI, for one, think the French can keep their libelous and manipulative piece of Norman propaganda.
- glaucon 1y agoYou realise it's just a temporary loan for an exhibition ?
- rixed 1y agoThis title is wrong about the when and misleading about the what. A masterpiece.
- glaucon 1y agoIt is a bit weird, like the OP missed out "for the first time" after 'U.K.' but really the underlying article is there for the clicking, it's written at a level 12 year olds could read and it's a two minute read so the headline being a bit wonky is not going to lead to long term confusion.
- stevage 1y agoIt's not the OP's fault.
- conradfr 1y agoThe problem is the transportation, not the length of the loan or even the loan itself.
- metalman 1y agoIt is 3"rd page news, 3 days late, and the orange one stole all there fire. They did pull out all the stops, and the King proposed a toast, flattering France, in French. Though this is only a symptom of how unpopular the governments in both countrys have gotten. Trump has correctly determined that the US has become the arbiter of everything, and it's do as he says, or figure something else out.Theater is not working as a substitue, no matter how you pronounce it.
- arp242 1y agoWhy would people be opposed to this? France loans some world-class exhibits to the UK, and the UK loans some world-class exhibits to France. Seems like a win-win? Who loses anything with this?
- CaptainJack 1y agoAll experts in restoration/conservation have argued that the tapestry is too old and fragile to be moved. Macron has pushed for it (to announce as part of his state visit to the UK), the director of the Bayeux Museum has accepted (he is a civil servant, and more subject to politics). Experts agree that any move is likely to worsen tears in the cloth (a superposition of linen): https://www.latribunedelart.com/bayeux-tapestry-let-s-listen-to-the-restorers?lang=en https://www.latribunedelart.com/bayeux-tapestry-let-s-listen... The museum where it is exposed is supposed to go through renovation, and experts are worried even to move the tapestry within the same museum just for renovation purposes... one can understand their fears when it's about packing and transporting to the other side of the channel (notwithstanding the amazing level of the British Museum conservation team, among the best in the world).
- l0b0 1y agoIt's happening now, not in 950 years.
- topspin 1y agoThat headline is... dysfunctional. "The Bayeux Tapestry will return to Britain for the first time in 950 years in a historic deal between Britain and France"
- comrade1234 1y agoThat's way more boring than the story I was picturing, which was more of a Hong Kong story.
- topspin 1y agoI agree. It's practically click-bait, although likely unintentional.
- slj 1y agoIt’s funny to consider the parallels between the tapestry’s return and the campaigns for repatriation of the British Museum’s many stolen artefacts
- PaulRobinson 1y agoTemporary loans in exchange for other items on temporary loan (which is what this is), is legally the only way the British Museum can let material leave their collections. I realise that there is a lot of meme-age worthy material that the British Museum is full of stolen property, but it's worth remembering that most of the items were donated at a time when legal provenance was virtually impossible to establish (particularly if you have to assume a peer of the realm like Elgin is an honest man, lest you find yourself under attack from the entire establishment), and the Museum is prevented by an Act of Parliament from giving items away regardless of later legal claims. To return the Elgin/Parthenon Marbles to Greece, for example, requires a new Act, which - given the current government's legislative programme - is unlikely to happen in the next 3-4 years, and there's little appetite for it. A temporary loan deal would be more realistic if both the British and Greek governments trusted each other to make the returns. That means the Greeks would basically need to loan out half the museum of Athens to make it work...
- arp242 1y agoPeople did complain at the time and denied that Elgin had the right to take them in the first place, which is why parliament investigated the matter at the time. While the controversy has intensified in the last few decades, it's been controversial pretty much since day one. It's not a "meme-age" thing. Whether Elgin did or did not have permission from the occupying Ottoman forces is of secondary importance. Many people at the time already considered the Greeks to be occupied by the Ottomans, which is one reason why all of this was controversial at the time (Greeks were not viewed with the same racism as the occupied people in Africa or Asia – quite the opposite since many people were huge Greek fanboys). If some official had legally approved removing huge chunks of St. Paul's Cathedral in 1800 then the British would be up in arms about it today, and rightfully so. Nazis had "legal" permission to remove a lot of art works through occupied Europe. No one today would claim that the painting of the Fallen Madonna with the Big Boobies would belong to the inheritors of Herr Flick, no matter how they were acquired in the first place. There are many examples of things done "legally" where today we no longer acknowledge the legality of it. This is also why the British government is often so disproportionally testy about the entire matter, and why that law was passed in the first place. They know that is is clearly and obviously the right thing to return one of the most prominent cultural and historical artifacts to Greece, removed by someone for his private garden, with dubious permission to do so, and even if it did exist it was given by someone who had no right to give it in the first place. They know they're wrong and don't want to talk about it.
- 7734128 1y agoThe automatic headline rewriting is an absolute joke and it has not improved a title a single time ever.
- zaptrem 1y agoDoes HN auto re-write headlines using an LLM or something?
- wizzwizz4 1y agoNo, a regular expression. Generative language models usually produce different kinds of error, and rarely fade into the background in the same way the automatic headline rewriting tool does (when it isn't rendering the titles incomprehensible, at least).
- perihelions 1y ago> "a regular expression" A small language model
- wizzwizz4 1y agoIt compresses exceptionally well, and has highly-optimised CPU implementations.
- daverol 1y agoAt least I will be able to visit the exhibition and count them myself: https://allthatsinteresting.com/bayeux-tapestry-penises https://allthatsinteresting.com/bayeux-tapestry-penises
- trhway 1y agoThe tapestry was made by nuns. I'm not sure what to make of it. May be it was more common occurrence so to speak - because men were basically wearing dresses too, and short ones at that, and even codpieces would appear only centuries later. No fun in Victorian times though: "Interestingly, many of the penises depicted in the original tapestry were not transferred over to the Victorian recreation, as the Leek Embroidery Society, which made the replica, was given censored etchings, engravings, and photos to work from."
- graemep 1y ago> The tapestry was made by nuns. I do not think that is correct. We do not actually know who hade it. The alleged missed penis was spotted by a historian with the surname Monk though :) > May be it was more common occurrence so to speak - because men were basically wearing dresses too, and short ones at that Very likely. They were not that hung up about nudity and accidental exposure.
- nelox 1y agoPerhaps a prophecy of Britain conquering France again?
- stevage 1y ago> Bayeux Tapestry Will Return to the U.K. In 950 Years Hilarious. I was hoping the title was actually accurate.
- Aardwolf 1y agoIf the title were accurate, it'd be returned to the UK roughly 300 years after John Cage's Organ²/ASLSP finishes its last note. The Zeitpyramide, however, will not be completed yet, but be over 80% there
- Kaibeezy 1y agoI was hoping someone had discovered a 950 year old… um… broadsheet? that had been tacked to the… um… alba libellorum? in the Butter Market? And they guessed there would be a UK!
- soegaard 1y agoIf you happen to be in Nordjylland, Denmark then you can also see the recreation: https://www.boerglumkloster.dk/hvad-kan-jeg-se/bayeux-tapetet https://www.boerglumkloster.dk/hvad-kan-jeg-se/bayeux-tapete...
- triknomeister 1y agoGreat, now return stuff to colonies.
- ghusto 1y agoIt's only a loan. I'd like the same "cultural appropriation" rants that we have when the UK et al. are "encouraged" to give back items of cultural significance to the countries of origin.