6 ms·
Orwell Diaries 1938-1942
- farts_mckensy 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? It's not what this site is for, and we ban accounts that keep doing it. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- farts_mckensy 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- latentcall 1y ago[flagged]
- lostlogin 1y agoHe literally fought fascists. And during that time became anti-communist. He was a socialist in the end and against both extremes. I think he was involved with The Labour Party after the war - can you explain your view?
- cogman10 1y agoUnless we are literally doing Orwellian doublespeak, he was pretty much the polar opposite of a fascist/authoritarian. He was against strong central governments and was quite critical of his own government (In one of the diary entries even lamenting that the germans failed to jam one of the British propaganda broadcasts). > Nehru, Gandhi, Azad and many others in jail. Rioting over most of India, a number of deaths, countless arrests. Ghastly speech by Amery, speaking of Nehru and Co. as “wicked men”, “saboteurs” etc. This of course broadcast on the Empire service and rebroadcast by AIR. The best joke of all was that the Germans did their best to jam it, unfortunately without success.
- robobro 1y agowhat is the difference between socialism and communism
- dokyun 1y ago[flagged]
- robobro 1y agothe nazis where?
- moron4hire 1y agoI mean, they claimed to be. It was in the name, "Nazi" was a contraction of "National Socialists". But that's kind of the problem with much of these conversations online. They figure way too much on the naming of things and not enough on the outcomes of things. I think anyone with an honest understanding of the Nazi party would admit it was much, much more about the "Nationalism" then it ever intended to be about the "Socialism". Much like how the modern "Republican" party doesn't seem to care too much about republics.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoThe original ones, in Germany. It was short for "national socialist" - that is literally where "Nazi" comes from. They were different from the communists in that they were national rather than international socialists. At least, that's what it said on the tin. Not sure, once they got into power, how actually socialist they were. (On the other hand, once the communists got into power, I'm not sure how communist they actually were.)
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoArgh. I totally missed the point of the GP to this (a snarky comment on a typo). Worse, I missed it until after the edit window closed...
- hydrogen7800 1y ago
- techright75 1y ago[dead]
- kurthr 1y agoI suspect we'll never know, but it's somewhat typical of blithe idealists who would rather hear supportive platitudes than confront hard decisions or tradeoffs. Painting complex individuals who are a product of their time (pretty much everyone) with a broad reductive brush makes life decisions easy and forces others to deal with reality. It was a fairly effective trope from the 60s to the 2010s (the end of history), and even Chomsky failed to really spot the turning point for the Manufacture of Discontent until 2020, a solid 4 years too late. Now they seem lost in the old narrative, fighting old inconsequential battles in a new world.
- roywiggins 1y agoGeorge Orwell wrote a lot, and not just novels. It's actually pretty easy to know where he was, politically: he wrote political columns in the newspaper and you can read them.
- tristramb 1y ago[flagged]
- rufus_foreman 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- vodou 1y agoI remember this blog! It was posting diary entries 70 years after they were written. This was a good time in the history of Internet and the diary/blog ended at the dawn of the golden era of the "blogosphere". George/Eric paid a lot of attention to how many eggs his hens laid. It almost became somewhat of a joke in the comments. But good content! https://orwelldiaries.wordpress.com/2008/12/01/11238/ https://orwelldiaries.wordpress.com/2008/12/01/11238/ Lots of great quotes (quite a few hen related): > This morning a disaster. One hen dead, another evidently dying. I am pretty sure he wrote more about hens and other birds than the ongoing world war.
- IAmBroom 1y agoMy neighbor, who raises chickens for eggs, and has lost many to predation, has expressed grief over losing some of them. She does not spend her time grieving the dead in various conflicts currently ongoing, although we both are saddened by them. Proximity amplifies emotion.
- kleiba 1y agoThe combination of reverse chronological order and infinite scroll is a little silly, no? (Note that there's also an index on the right-hand side.)
- martin-t 1y agoThis seems to be a Wordpress thing and I hate it. We have supercomputers in our packets and websites can't even do a thing as basic as showing a list of posts, all the posts, on one page.
- perihelions 1y agoI guess this is the key biographic context, > "In August 1941, Orwell finally obtained "war work" when he was taken on full-time by the BBC's Eastern Service.[111] He supervised cultural broadcasts [sic] to India, to counter propaganda from Nazi Germany designed to undermine imperial links.[112] " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Orwell#Second_World_War_and_Animal_Farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Orwell#Second_World_War... There's quite a visible gap between his nominal role as a propagandist for Britain in India, and his private views expressed here. I mean: "quite truly the way the British Government is now behaving upsets me more than a military defeat"—wow! (Meta: the part where Wikipedia's obviously very not-neutral editors inserted that exemplar of newspeak, "cultural broadcasts" for "propaganda", into the biography of Orwell himself is just... doubleplus).
- lukan 1y agoIn 1984, the office rooms for the ministry of lies were directly inspired from his work for the BBC ..
- robocat 1y ago> ministry of lies Winston worked in the Ministry of Truth. By doublethink, internally you know there are two meanings although you can never actually do the crimethink of believing or saying any ungood connotations. Edit - added quote: Doublethink means the power of holding two contradictory beliefs in one's mind simultaneously, and accepting both of them. ... To tell deliberate lies while genuinely believing in them, to forget any fact that has become inconvenient, [and remember it if necessary]. To deny the existence of objective reality and all the while to take account of the reality which one denies.
- lukan 1y agoMy bad. You are of course correct. Also I never said anything about a ministry of lies. I only spoke of a ministry of truth of course. (That is, if the 2 h edit window would not have been already over now)
- 1y ago
- submeta 1y agoReminder to myself: My journal entries on my computer in Obsidian won‘t survive even a year after I die. My child probably won’t look into the thousands of files to find my journal entries. Whereas my paper diaries from 30years ago will be perfectly fine in a few decades from now.
- Aperocky 1y agoprint and staple it.
- drfuchs 1y agoBut will your grandchild be able to read handwriting?
- Retric 1y agoI’ve already used a computer to interpret old handwriting.
- e40 1y agoThis is why I use markdown. I figure that will be easily viewable for as long as the files are around.
- jjice 1y agoObsidian is all markdown. I assume OP was referring to no one keeping that data preserved post death.
- regularization 1y agoAbout seven years before he was sending letters to the British Foreign Office of who to blackball during the UK's version of the Red Scare - people like Charlie Chaplin. He even wrote a book a year before this (1984) denouncing societies that had people denouncing each other for political heresy. Psychological projection. What a htpocrite.
- rhcom2 1y agoPretty interesting, I had no idea about this: The George Orwell Paradox: From Spy Target to Informant https://spyscape.com/article/surveillance-state-how-british-soviet-spies-targeted-novelist-george-orwell https://spyscape.com/article/surveillance-state-how-british-...
- skinnymuch 1y agoYeah. Western hegemony has an interest in presenting the Animal Farm guy a certain way.
- mathiaspoint 1y agoI think most people stop at 1984 or animal farm and have no idea what Orwell really thought about society and politics.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- skinnymuch 1y agoYes very much so. Thankfully someone in this thread (even if only you) saying the correct context.
- thomassmith65 1y agoThe Germans announce over the wireless that as the inhabitants of a Czech village called Lidice [...] were guilty of harbouring the assassins of Heydrich, they have shot all the males in the village, sent all the women to concentration camps, sent all the children to be “re-educated”, razed the whole village to the ground and changed its name. [...] It does not particularly surprise me that people do this kind of thing, nor even that they announce that they are doing them. What does impress me, however, is that other people’s reaction to such happenings is governed solely by the political fashion of the moment. [...] In a little while you will be jeered at if you suggest that the story of Lidice could possibly be true. And yet there the facts are, announced by the Germans themselves and recorded on gramophone discs In our age of social media, that phenomenon is no longer surprising.
- gleenn 1y agoScrewing the other side is far easier to sell than having things be good for the average person. Some pretty gross displays of greed and hypocrisy.
- mc32 1y agoSometimes it’s just ideology ploughing through as in the cases that happened in Ukraine before WWII but after Lenin died.
- throwawayoldie 1y ago"Ploughing through". I see what you did there.
- Joker_vD 1y agoDo... you refer to the "korenizatsiya" [0] effort during which the Russian language/culture/tradition was heavily penalized and the local ethnic languages/cultures/traditions elevated to the official and mandatory status? There are enough of open letters from the local Russian-descended population to the central papers that complained about such policy, and even more articles in those papers as the response that declare that yes, the Party absolutely wants to stamp out the Russian cultural influences from the national republics because otherwise there is no chance to build the socialism, so if the not quite politically correct workers would please stop complaining so much and keep in with the Party line, thank you — or else. Thankfully, until the mid-30s that "or else" was mostly sacking from the current place of work and expulsion from the Party. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korenizatsiia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korenizatsiia
- ivape 1y agoI was actually looking into reading some of his other candid works: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_Paris_and_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Down_and_Out_in_Paris_and_Lond... Semi-autobiographical about when he was nearly homeless and living in poverty in Europe. He also went after how hospitals mistreat patients and poor people in Paris.
- specproc 1y agoI picked a book of his diaries up recently, it's been great to pick at. The copy I have has _a lot_ about his garden and the countryside around him, which has been fun to read whilst working on mine. Lots of very terse household entries like, "July 11: 12 eggs".
- jongjong 1y agoIt's strange why Orwell gets so much more attention than Aldous Huxley. I feel like modern reality is a lot closer to 'Brave New World' than '1984'. Brave New World describes a world saturated with endless streams of information and entertainment and yet almost everyone basically acts the same way; everyone chooses to engage in the same kinds of 'pleasure seeking' activities; they all think the same and they all want to watch and experience the same things, despite the fact that many alternatives exist. Ironically, it might be partly because BNW is becoming real that those in charge are drawing attention towards 1984; this form of subtle attention manipulation is very BNW-like. Another thing though is that as the world becomes more like BNW, the book itself becomes less interesting to read for younger people. For example, I remember being surprised when characters in the book asked each other if they had watched a 'Feelie' (a Movie with sensory experience) about 'Swimming with whales'. I remember thinking that the way the characters kept asking each other about their opinions on the same boring things and expecting them to answer in the same predictable way as some kind of status symbol was weird... But nowadays it's basically the reality; people praise each other for compliance. Basically for being boring and having predictable boring thoughts. I suspect young people reading BNW wouldn't pick up on that... It would go right over their heads that things were once different and expressing compliance with the mainstream ideology didn't earn you any social status (at least not in the west). It was kind of the opposite.
- leoh 1y agoThere’s a lot more in 1984 than the high-level ideas which are held in contrast to Huxley (risks of oppression versus risks of opulence). Both are certainly at play. A few of the things from 1984 that I’ve noticed or have been told about and often reflect upon: * 1984 is a book that is concerned with the physical body and the deprivations experienced in Oceania — ie Winston’s gastric distress is articulated on the first page; many of us experience meaningful bodily distress on account of our food systems, stress, disconnection, and other issues * 1984 is largely about alienation — many of us prioritize our work and other fears over connection in the same ways that Winston and Julia do (engaging in sex is taboo in Oceania); although engaging in sex is not forbidden in our culture, taking the time to really connect with others when so many of us feel so much constant pressure to work can feel “wrong” * stirring up hatred among the populace in 1984 is a common theme; in our culture, on both the right and the left, an insistence on hating others, other political parties, other countries, and injustice (ie as opposed to cultivating love and compassion for those suffering) form the basis of profound issues we face today
- HAMSHAMA 1y agoI really loved “Down and out in Paris and London” and “Homage to Catalonia”.