4 ms·
I'm curious as to US attitudes to unions. I get the feeling they are viewing more positively (although ambivalently in Europe/UK) whilst anti-union sentiment is
by andybak 14y ago
I'm curious as to US attitudes to unions. I get the feeling they are viewing more positively (although ambivalently in Europe/UK) whilst anti-union sentiment is more deeply ingrained in the US.
(The UK is probably an interesting middle-ground as it is in some other areas)
- pytrin 14y agoMost professions in the U.S have unions. The most publicized are their sport player unions, which have perfected the art of collective bargaining. Worker unions are a part of U.S culture.
- aaronbrethorst 14y agoNot true[1], and despite the current, small uptick in numbers, I suspect that union membership will continue to fall due to the rise right to work laws around the US[2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_unions_in_the_United_States#Membership http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_unions_in_the_United_Stat... [2] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/03/what-are-right-to-work-laws http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/03/what-are-right-t...
- pytrin 14y agoNot sure what you refer to as not true - most professions in the U.S have a union. I didn't say most workers are a part of it.
- 001sky 14y agoThe word 'profession' and the data are both leading you astray. In 2010, the percentage of workers belonging to a union in the United States (or total labor union "density") was 11.4%, compared to 18.6% in Germany, 27.5% (Historically,"professions" were medecine, law, and accountaincy etc...as opposed to the "trades" It was only the trades which had unions. US, we have public sector unions (very large), including teachers, etc. Public sector = "Bureaucrats"!= professions.
- FJim 14y agoWhat does that even mean?
- pytrin 14y agoA profession is a vocation founded upon specialized high educational training (Wikipedia). For example, you can have a doctor union - it doesn't mean that every doctor is a member in it.
- 001sky 14y agoPart of this was also structural, if you think about it. the professionals were typically self-employed or partnerships. The professionals, in other words, were the bosses/upper management. The need for a union, somewhat redundant. Notice, that changes when the State becomes involved. Then you do see, say teachers unions. Hope this helps.
- pytrin 14y agoI said professions, not professionals.
- 001sky 14y agoHistorically, professions = Upper/Ruling Classes. Members of the ruling class don't (at least historically want/need) form unions precisely because they are/were the ruling class. [Edit: Professional Associations i believe were fairly common, as a vehicle to further the interests of a specific profession.]
- lutusp 14y ago> Historically, professions = Upper/Ruling Classes Perhaps within the last 100 years, but not "historically" in a general or broad sense. The historical ruling class didn't have professions, they had power.
- 14y ago
- scarmig 14y agoIncreasingly not, though. The US has always lagged behind other Western countries in union membership, and although most countries have seen a decline, in the US it's been particularly severe. Perhaps worse, that decline has been much stronger in the private sector: the only places unions really have seen any even moderate victories in recent decades is either public workers or in artificial markets created by the State (such as California's homecare workers). Culturally there's a big difference, too. While in Europe unions and corporations tolerate and even co-operate with each other (German companies have, I believe, half of their board members controlled by labor unions), in the USA they are very antagonistic. Either because of that or causing that, most unions in the USA are effectively nominal with no real power.