6 ms·
A Century of Quantum Mechanics
- beckthompson 1y agohaha I remember taking my quantum mechanics class. I thought I finally had "finished" old physics and was finally doing "newer" stuff. In the library there were some old physics books, looked at one that was like 70 years old and it was covering the stuff we learned that quarter... Guess I have a LONG way to go until I learn "new" things xD
- sampo 1y agoThere is no new foundational physics. The standard model of particle physics is from the 1970s, and the lambda-cmd model of cosmology is from late 1990s. Of course there is lots of new speculative ideas being produced, but it's really difficult to get anything confirmed.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoIs standard model confirmed? Then what is dark matter?
- thyristan 1y agoIn physics, there is never confirmation. At best there is "measurement agrees with the model as exactly as it is currently possible to measure". The standard model is confirmed in that sense. Dark matter is a problem from cosmology and astronomy, that maybe has a solution in an extension to the standard model. Maybe it hasn't and that solution will come from elsewhere, maybe there is a totally cosmological explanation after all. In all cases, the dark matter problem is not a contradiction to the standard model in our current experiments. If there were a particle-physics explanation to dark matter, it would be a sufficiently small alteration to the standard model that our current experiments couldn't tell the difference, to within experimental error. That's how confirmation and new models in physics work.
- ks1723 1y agoOne of the major problems with dark matter and dark energy is, that the standard model has been experimentally confirmed to such high precision. All possible extensions proposed so far which tried to explain dark matter /dark energy have been basically falsified by the experiments. The standard model is so descriptive and accurate, there is just no room for extensions which predict new physics but are still consistent with existing data.
- dave333 1y agoSo likely dark matter is a different flavor of something already in the model. Dr. Mills' Hydrino theory presents hydrogen with the electron in a lower orbit that does not radiate as a candidate for dark matter. These states are stable like the ground state. Transition into or between hydrino states emit light in the UV or soft X-ray wavelengths that is not seen in optical telescopes. https://brilliantlightpower.com/atomic-theory/ https://brilliantlightpower.com/atomic-theory/
- jojobas 1y agoObligatory https://xkcd.com/2035/ https://xkcd.com/2035/
- IAmBroom 1y agoWhy isn't this mysterious state of hydrogen detectable in tests? The page you link to is essentially a big list of links. Useless. I am immediately suspicious of anyone who generates buzzwords to describe their theory. Heck, he even registered "hydrino" as a trademarked term. I'm not saying he's wrong. I'm saying he walks like a duck, sounds like a duck, wears feathers and swims all day in a lake.
- dave333 1y agoThere are many ways Mills claims to have experimentally verified the existence of hydrinos but the most obvious one is the faster than hydrogen transit through a gas chromatograph.
- 1y ago
- pantalaimon 1y agoIIRC there has been no confirmation yet that dark matter actually exists - it might as well be true that our model of cosmology is wrong.
- DebtDeflation 1y ago>what is dark matter? I suspect in the end it will turn out to neither be exotic new particles nor modifications to gravity, but rather that there is something fundamental about large scale structure formation in the universe that we just do not understand at the present.
- mr_mitm 1y agoHow can insights into large scale structure formation help explaining galaxy ration curves, lensing observations or barionic acoustic oscillations?
- vadansky 1y agoDark matter is the worst model, except for all those other models that have been tried from time to time.
- adastra22 1y agoQuantum mechanics is not the standard model. Quantum mechanics is the stuff developed in the 20’s and 30’s. It is really useful for solving real world problems, and for that reason is what is taught to undergraduates in a “modern physics” class. It is not a correct or complete description of reality, however, and is about 50ish years out of date.
- andrepd 1y agoWhat do you mean? It's not "out of date", as Kepler's laws or the ideal gas law or whatever is not out of date. It's just incomplete. Also, "modern physics" is a term of art, vs "classical physics".
- thyristan 1y agoEvery physical description of reality is correct to within some error bars. Quantum mechanics is still useful and correct, there are just more precise theories that provide refinement. And in that sense are the "current" theories if they are the most precise ones currently known.
- IAmBroom 1y agoNot true at all. Blackbody radiation goes to infinity with Wien's distribution; error bars aren't going to get you there. Likewise, our 1/r^2 understanding of forces goes to infinity as distance goes to zero, but we currently can't resolve that problem with error bars for the nucleus of an atom, where Heisenberg tells us any two protons can sometimes appear closer to each other than the "radius" of the nucleus. You can't make Schottky diodes using Maxwell and error bars. That is the entire problem: the classical models weren't merely inaccurate; they predicted completely absurd (and provably wrong) results at extreme scales.
- GoblinSlayer 1y agoInfinite error bars.
- chermi 1y ago
- volemo 1y agoI think "new foundational [science]" is a bit of an oxymoron: theories need time to become established as foundational. There may well be ideas (currently hypotheses) that will someday be considered foundational, but we lack the hindsight and experimental validation to claim that status now. And if you try to present your theory as foundational from the outset — like S. Wolfram does — you’ll be laughed at, much like he is.
- griffzhowl 1y agoHmm, I don't think so. General relativity and quantum mechanics were acknowledged as fundamental (relative to previous theories) more or less immediately, because they provided a coherent theoretical scheme that accounted for the observations which were problems for previous theories, and they also made many new predictions which were experimentally confirmed within a few years. The problem for theoretical physics now is that all experiments from the LHC and so on are consistent with the standard model. So there are no recalcitrant observations that can guide new theory formation. The regime where we might get new physics, where gravity and QM are both significant, is so far experimentally inaccessible, though see here for a nice talk by Carlo Rovelli on one such experiment that might be plausible in the coming years: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgieRctZ4dE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tgieRctZ4dE The problem with Wolfram/Gorrard's model is that it doesn't relate to any experiments. As far as I know the most that can be said for it is that Gorrard showed that in some limit the model is able to replicate some features of GR and QM, so that by definition doesn't go beyond the predictions of GR nor QM.
- volemo 1y agoFair point. Thanks for the link!
- GoblinSlayer 1y ago>The problem with Wolfram/Gorrard's model is that it doesn't relate to any experiments That's because quantum gravity regime is so far experimentally inaccessible?
- 1y ago
- pantalaimon 1y agothe late 1990s is actually fairly recent
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- HPsquared 1y agoI remember thinking calculus was this modern high-tech thing in high school.
- jebarker 1y agoI also remember excitedly telling my friends about derivatives when I first learned of them thinking that this really was cutting edge math
- dang 1y ago[stub for offtopicness]
- zkmon 1y agoThis is probably the slowest branch of the sciences, not able to get out of labs even after a century. The fundamental problem appears to be that we are trying to control probabilistic nature using concrete real world things. I suspect this is not allowed, at least at an industrial scale. At some point humanity might need to stick what they need instead of what they can.
- mr_mitm 1y agoWhat do you mean? We have been profiting massively from the fruits of QM for the last five decades easily. Transistors, LEDs, Lasers, MRT imaging, solar panels, CCD cameras, etc. have arguably changed the world and would not have been possible without QM. It came out of the lab a long time ago.
- colechristensen 1y agoNot to mention the entire science of chemistry and everything made from it. Quantum mechanics started with the description of electron orbitals around an atom; how they work is the foundation of chemistry.
- kqr 1y agoI think GP was thinking of quantum computers, maybe?
- colechristensen 1y ago[flagged]
- novaomnidev 1y agoThat’s engineering not science
- afunk 1y agohaha. the same year the moving assembly line was invented.