4 ms·
In the past you had organized shysters from India who took their business to the West like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prem_Rawat https://en.wikipedia.org/wik
by PaulHoule 1y ago
In the past you had organized shysters from India who took their business to the West like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prem_Rawat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prem_Rawat
Today you have more interest in the literature of the East. I'm somewhat surprised at how little important Chinese literature is available in translation.
In a time when many people are cut off from the ancient history of the West for various reasons (look at the 'bro veneration of Rome and the knee-jerk anti-Romanism it engenders) I think we need as large a cultural database to work from as we can get.
Educated-but-ignorant progressives find most of the people who ever lived are dead to them because they don't accept 100% of the ideas that were fashionable in the last 30 seconds. Go to India and the sinosphere and they might find something that bypasses their defenses.
Cultural conservatives need to realize they'll hit a ceiling so long as they remain stuck on a book that claims God made the world 6000 years ago (God is not great!) and cares about a few people on a postage stamp in the Middle East more than the rest of us -- Confucius could put them on a rational basis that people will listen to.
- cindyllm 1y agoGod _is_ great. Time Cops, arrest this man!
- alganet 1y agoI'm like "don't buy snake oil" and people answer like "did you know oil does not mix with water? There is canola oil, and linseed oil, soy oil..." Sounds like you're actually trying to help the snake oil salesman to make his case. Sure, bro.
- PaulHoule 1y agoI'd rather be the guy who leaves offerings at his fox altar and gets trolled by CindyLLM for it than be the 'rationalist' who says they are an atheist but isn't. https://mastodon.social/@UP8/113975613016164927 https://mastodon.social/@UP8/113975613016164927
- alganet 1y agoYou missed the point. I made an analogy, you missed the point about the analogy. -- It seems that you're interpreting the oil analogy as a reference to belief, or culture more generally. But I said right there at the top, it's not about the contents, it's about how a western audience could potentially react to the way a selection of commented quotes of an ancient chinese thinker is presented. The cultural facts you mentioned are relevant culturally but irrelevant both to the blogpost and my critique of it. They are related, and share similar words and concepts, and it is even nuanced, but talks about another subject. While your subject is related to cultural identity, mine is about charlatanism. I don't think the blogpost is trying to appropriate chinese culture, in the same way Häagen-Dazs is not trying to undermine the scandinavians. However, in both cases, we have a case of deception. The deception is not against a culture, but against a possible victim that does not know the target culture. I'm not talking about migration, I'm not talking about culture appropriation, I'm not judging nations or cultures by value. I understand this is difficult for most audiences to grasp, and I'm not saying you don't understand it. Think of a cloud of different subjects related to culture. Matters of identity, belief, appropriation, all share a similar group (talk about culture, mainly). My critique is more closely related to another group of ideas (critical thinking, avoiding cult-behavior, manipulation of perception, cold reading). It is true that these both clouds of subjects intersect, but briefly. Some people say religion or certain cultures are manipulative, and they also describes themselves as skeptics. Through that intersection, you could have derived a reply that confuses a lot of audiences, and it would appease to these kinds of religious skeptics (militant atheism), moving the discussion towards a more easy to navigate terrain (it's easy to point out the mistakes of militant atheists, and hard to spot the difference between a secular-type and an atheist-type). Again, not that you don't know (on the contrary, you demonstrate quite an ablity to select subjects). --- Your reply (possibly accidentaly?) hits a combination of notes around the subject that is curious. It doesn't pass scrutiny. For example, if it was part of a larger corpus of text on culture, both of our comments should have been left out (mine for not being about culture, yours for being a continuation of mine. you broke the chain, man). In another example, my comment would be perhaps be in a larger corpus about secular though, but your reply woundn't (from there, you started talking about culture as the main subject. breaking the chain again, man). Makes sense?