3 ms·
The problem is easy to state -- we're teaching mathematics in the wrong order. Where would we go to find a real-world example of mathematics being taught in th
by tokenadult 14y ago
The problem is easy to state -- we're teaching mathematics in the wrong order.
Where would we go to find a real-world example of mathematics being taught in the correct order to elementary-age pupils? There are many different schools (and many different settings for learning outside school) in many different countries. What is a good place to look for examples of demonstrably successful practice?
AFTER EDIT: Thanks for the reply. The thing I would want to look at in such intervention studies is how the teaching effectiveness is measured.
AFTER FURTHER EDIT: Oh, I see the video "Teaching Math Without Words, A Visual Approach to learning Math from MIND Research Institute" is one I have watched before, and have discussed among other mathematics teachers. Similarly, the publication Mathematics Teaching in the Middle School is a publication I subscribe to as a member of NCTM. I should start out in my reaction to both of these links you've kindly shared by pointing out that my own bent in thinking about mathematics is to think visually, and indeed that is why I like Sawyer's book Vision in Elementary Mathematics (which leads off my longer reply in this thread) so well.
But although I like visual approaches to teaching mathematics very well, and use them in the mathematics classes I teach, I also like studies of educational interventions to check results. So far, I can't find a publication by independent researchers (after searching Google Scholar and the new Microsoft Academic Search) that verifies the educational effectiveness claims made in the video for the proprietary intervention described there. The company's own website
http://www.mindresearch.net/cont/research/re_publications.php http://www.mindresearch.net/cont/research/re_publications.ph...
provides only a very sparse set of links to published research on the issue.
Plainly, a more visual approach along the lines of the typical school textbooks used in Taiwan, Singapore, and Japan would be a better presentation of mathematics content than is found in typical United States textbooks. That should be possible to deliver without any computers at all, as it was delivered to pupils in Taiwan in my wife's generation, when Taiwan was still a poor, Third World country.
- lutusp 14y ago> Where would we go to find a real-world example of mathematics being taught in the correct order to elementary-age pupils? Good question -- and it seems this idea is being put into practice. Here are some examples: "Using Art to Teach Fraction, Decimal, and Percent Equivalents" : http://mason.gmu.edu/~jsuh4/math%20masterpiece.pdf http://mason.gmu.edu/~jsuh4/math%20masterpiece.pdf (PDF) "Teaching Math Without Words, A Visual Approach to learning Math" (TED talk) : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7odhYT8yzUM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7odhYT8yzUM "Teaching with Visuals: Students Respond to Images" : http://www.edutopia.org/visuals-math-curriculum http://www.edutopia.org/visuals-math-curriculum There are many other similar examples. Here's one from an article I wrote ("each member of the running sum of odd numbers is a perfect square"): http://arachnoid.com/example/index.html#Math_Example http://arachnoid.com/example/index.html#Math_Example The graphic says it all. > The thing I would want to look at in such intervention studies is how the teaching effectiveness is measured. That will take much longer and is fraught with measurement difficulties (as with all social science questions). We might end up with people possessed of self-confidence about their math skills, but who can't balance a checkbook. (I say this as the devil's advocate, not because I actually believe that will be the outcome.) > But although I like visual approaches to teaching mathematics very well, and use them in the mathematics classes I teach, I also like studies of educational interventions to check results. Yes, a perfectly legitimate concern, and one especially important if one is to openly advocate a change in public school curricula. It is equally clear that there are no reliable data on outcomes at this time.