3 ms·
Originally, I read the first few paragraphs, noticed it was mostly fluff journalism and immediately jumped to the HN comments and posted a question asking about
by malandrew 14y ago
Originally, I read the first few paragraphs, noticed it was mostly fluff journalism and immediately jumped to the HN comments and posted a question asking about the use of lasers to melt the metal either pre- or post-deposition to fuse it to already deposited metal. I then went back to the original article and read to the end of it just to make sure it didn't mention that this was the technique used, since I have made this mistake before. Lo and behold it was exactly the technique used. I quickly went back and deleted the question I posted before I was downvoted with a comment like "didn't you read the article. it said that the process used lasers as you described".
The reason this is interesting is because this is exactly the type of process that ends up being patented. Chances are that the scientists that perfected this stereolithography technique are going to apply for a patent and probably get it, even though it was an obvious approach to use to me, someone who has zero experience with stereolithography. If it is obvious to me, then it is certainly obvious to someone with familiar with the field of stereolithography. Too often people say "Ohh, everything is obvious after the fact", but like this approach using lasers and stereolithography it is very obvious before the fact too. Most things that are obvious in hindsight are just as obvious before sight.
Anyways, sorry to be OT with this comment. It's not meant to be flamebaity, it's just relevant because my original naive question was made on this post.
- slapshot 14y agoThere's a world of difference between saying "I'd use a laser to melt the metal" and actually perfecting the process to the extent that (a) the metal being deposited is adequately fused, (b) the metal underneath is not disturbed every time a new layer is added, (c) the over-shoot of the laser beams doesn't randomly melt holes elsewhere in the piece, (d) it works at all angles, and (e) concerns I can't even think of yet. There are lots of scholarly articles about the laser process dating back to at least the 1990s. No patent would be granted today on the general idea. But if this research team invented a unique way to prevent any of the problems listed above (that nobody had thought of yet and solved a real problem --- maybe they flick the beams on and off in a particular pattern, or use different wavelengths in a novel way, or have a unique mounting system that swings the beams off the work more quickly, etc.) then it would be perfectly appropriate for them to obtain patent protection on that improvement. As somebody said on a different HN patent thread, it's the difference between trying to patent a Star Trek "warp drive" today versus patenting the individual inventions that add up to an actual working warp drive. You'll be laughed out of the PTO if you file on "Step 1: Build a warp drive. Step 2: Profit." But if you can invent the technology to actually make it happen, you can get a patent even though the idea of "warp drive" dates back to 1960s (or earlier) SciFi.
- juiceandjuice 14y ago>maybe they flick the beams on and off in a particular pattern, or use different wavelengths in a novel way, or have a unique mounting system that swings the beams off the work more quickly, etc.) then it would be perfectly appropriate for them to obtain patent protection on that improvement. If it turns out that they use one of those methods, don't you think that would be obvious? I think if the patent was specific down to the actual wavelength, pulse shape, and pulse size, well... maybe then that should be patentable, unless it turns out that those parameters are chosen according to a natural law (parameterized based on material density, melting point, etc...) I think certain things, especially in regards to manufacturing, are more than okay at being patented. But I do think it should be implementation specific, and if an implementation is dependent on a natural law with no alternatives, I'm not sure something like that should be patented, it would really depend on some things.
- ajross 14y agoIt's also important to point out that this is a manufacturing process patent. Those don't work like software patents. Fundamentally this is an improvement in the ability to make metal stuff. It might be faster than CNC machining for low volume production, and as less material is wasted it's probably cheaper. Likewise it's almost certainly faster than making casting tooling for low volume. But fundamentally, it's just making stuff. We already have plenty of ways to make stuff from metal. So anyone who wants to make metal stuff isn't meaningfully impacted: at worst they might be priced out of the market for the new toy, but most likely they just have a new option to investigate. The patent inefficiency impacts only people who want to improve on this obscure technique. What won't happen is that the public will lose access to metal junk. Software isn't like that at all. Everything is built on everything else. If you get a patent on something like "pinch zoom" and refuse to license it, no other devices can use it. The public loses, because all of a sudden important features can't be combined with other important features.
- incision 14y agoYes, the "If it was obvious, someone else would have done it!" argument is a frustrating one. I have a hard time wrapping my head around it. There are an awful lot of supporting developments that go into any sufficiently advanced technology. Patents as they relate to some technologies feel like an odd kind of race, one in which the winner isn't defined by finishing first exactly. Rather it's the act of crossing a non-specific finish line within a very specific window of time then proceeding to tell everyone else that their times will be invalidated if they happened to take the same route.