4 ms·
Wondering what the opinion is about "Vision Zero." My little town is all over this. I think it's a bad idea. Goals should be realistic, and I think it's unreali
by SoftTalker 1y ago
Wondering what the opinion is about "Vision Zero." My little town is all over this. I think it's a bad idea. Goals should be realistic, and I think it's unrealistic to get to literally zero traffic deaths. There will always be random events leading to accidents and you can spend as much money as you want but you will never be able to prevent them all. At some point you're committing statistical murder by spending money that could be better used on ther things.
- michael1999 1y agoThis post is about ticketing people who run stop signs. Is that the kind of price you consider too high?
- SoftTalker 1y agoNo, certainly there is low hanging fruit. Just that "Vision Zero" isn't a realistic goal. I would have chosen a different name and goals to avoid pedantic debate on whether it's achievable.
- thunderfork 1y ago[dead]
- bryanlarsen 1y agoVision Zero is based on a simple principle: if cars are driving less than 20mph a pedestrian collision is highly unlikely to be fatal. So they set a speed limit of 20mph on any mixed use street, and create separated pedestrian/cyclist infrastructure for any street with higher speed limits. The latter is super expensive, but it's what you need if you want usually zero fatalities and to go faster than 20mph. Actually zero all the time is impossible, of course. It's possible that a 5mph collision with a frail pedestrian will kill them. So Norway and Sweden sometimes have a fatality. But a goal of "zero pedestrian fatalities most years" is actually feasible for polities with fewer than 10 million citizens.
- aljgz 1y agoThere's a verse I like a lot in Tao Te Jing: "One must know when it is enough. Those who know when it is enough will not perish." I think it's good to aim for zero traffic deaths, as in many countries the situation is so bad that a lot of improvement is feasible. The long tail would definitely be much harder to tackle, but I don't expect this to be a serious problem in practice.
- pjc50 1y agoIt may be unrealistic, but it has been achieved: https://urban-mobility-observatory.transport.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/two-european-capitals-cut-pedestrian-and-cyclist-deaths-zero-after-traffic-changes-2020-03-24_en https://urban-mobility-observatory.transport.ec.europa.eu/ne... It's a question of priorities, really. America does not like using public policy to prevent deaths.