4 ms·
> Senders pay a small fee to send a message. • Relaying devices earn a micro-payment (could be tokens, sats, etc.) for carrying the message one hop further. Th
by Aurornis 1y ago
> Senders pay a small fee to send a message. • Relaying devices earn a micro-payment (could be tokens, sats, etc.) for carrying the message one hop further.
The Helium Network tried something like this, but with a fixed infrastructure: People were incentivized to run Helium network nodes and could earn micropayments for running nodes and handling traffic.
It revealed a lot of problems with structures like this, such as the incentive to cheat through various loopholes that were discovered.
It also became apparent that the monetization/tokenization aspect overtook the network functionality as the primary motivator for the project. After a while, people started looking at the traffic and payouts and realized that almost nobody was using it for real communication, it had become one big shell game for collecting the payments designed to incentivize nodes to come online and relay traffic. Then the token itself had become a speculative commodity that people used for trading more than anything.
I think it would be interesting if someone could invent a stable coin cryptocurrency with low overhead that enabled some of these use cases, but it seems the allure of generating a new token that the founders can sell into a speculative market to raise funds for the project is always too alluring, so every project goes from having good intentions to becoming a veiled pump and dump. Maybe some day there will be a stable coin that escapes these issues, but I haven’t seen it yet.
- repeekad 1y ago> I think it would be interesting if someone could invent a stable coin cryptocurrency with low overhead Like the US dollar and Postgres? For like $200 anyone can start a business entity in the US with a tax ID and a bank, I’m still yet to understand how crypto is better other than for circumventing regulators
- deweller 1y agoCryptocurrency transfers are irreversible, publicly verifiable and pseudonymous. For a privacy focused application, these attributes make crypto a better choice than USD and the traditional banking system.
- pizzafeelsright 1y agoHow? Irreversible is bad because mistakes happen. I lost ~$1,000 in a bad transfer because of a typo. Publicly verifiable -- not good because I don't want the public knowing what I buy. Pseudonymous is the worst of both. Is it or is it not me? them? I am thinking digital cash using pub keys on a network run from space on something like starlink sats.
- johnisgood 1y ago[flagged]
- dylan604 1y ago> I lost ~$1,000 in a bad transfer because of a typo. Was the option of doing a much smaller amount available to validate the account before following up with the full transfer? I've never understood not doing a test transfer first.
- MangoToupe 1y agoYou can still make a mistake after the test transfer.
- tshaddox 1y agoOr you can mistakenly think the test transfer worked as intended.
- buzzerbetrayed 1y agoNot to mention that the necessity of "do a test transfer" already shows how massively broken the process is
- akimbostrawman 1y agoOr maybe that "broken" design is just the result of the actual goal of decentralized P2P...
- altruios 1y agoMost crypto, no. The one to look at for that is Monero: the closest thing to private(anonymous) digital cash that I've found (so far).
- immibis 1y agoCircumventing regulations is like half the point of crypto... either you use it to circumvent regulators, or you hold it while the price goes up because of the people who are circumventing regulators. I think Bitcoin has become a typical fiat asset ouroboros now, because the people who actually want to circumvent regulators are using Monero (which is why Monero is banned in most countries), while the Bitcoin price is supported almost entirely by speculation and a little bit by people doing only-slightly-shady things with crypto who haven't noticed everyone else moved to Monero.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoWhere's the API for sending and receiving USD?
- greyface- 1y agohttps://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/wires https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/wires https://achdevguide.nacha.org/ https://achdevguide.nacha.org/
- 0xOsprey 1y ago[dead]
- clarkmoody 1y agoMany such cases with crypto. Moderately good idea powered by a token becomes a Ponzi.
- miketery 1y agoIn helium there was no input revenue. OP mentions payment to send. This is a very different scheme.
- rtkwe 1y agoIt's the same scheme. You had to purchase Data Credits to send on Helium too, there was no input revenue because no one was choosing to use it but it's largely the same as the scheme behind the Helium network. 1 DC/24 Bytes sent and successfully delivered.
- 0xOsprey 1y ago>>I think it would be interesting if someone could invent a stable coin cryptocurrency with low overhead that enabled some of these use cases We are thinking about this and building in this direction with Paygo.wtf https://x.com/0x_Osprey/status/1925299005191577921 https://x.com/0x_Osprey/status/1925299005191577921
- beAbU 1y agoI legit did not know helium was intended for communication. I thought it was a way to mine crypto via the airwaves or something. The OP's idea is an improvement: if you have to use crypto, then the only way a token is generated is when a sender buys one with fiat, so that they can transmit their message on the network.
- wkat4242 1y agoYes Helium was a terrible net negative for IoT protocols. It only caused a ton of very wasteful useless traffic that interfered with real purposeful networks like The Things Network. I'm glad it's mostly gone now. Personally I think everything gets perverted when monetisation becomes the primary goal.
- PovilasID 1y agoCheating may not have helped but it was doomed to start with. I did the math for my local city and to have full coverage you needed 5 nodes there were thousands. Also the main customer: utilities companies would risk getting rates of transfer hiked. While startup cost would be around 500-600 to keep the control.