4 ms·
Is there a vast decrease in time/waste product/investment when this is compared to something like a CNC mill? I've seen those things turn down 3-dimensional obj
by Loughla 14y ago
Is there a vast decrease in time/waste product/investment when this is compared to something like a CNC mill? I've seen those things turn down 3-dimensional objects inside of other 3-dimension objects with only the slightest holes, so shapability (is that a word?) is not an argument.
- nickpinkston 14y agoSo you do get part complexity for free with 3D Printing, but you sacrifice speed, surface quality, material properties, and tolerance - at least currently. As far as waste, laser 3DP probably wastes a lot of energy compared with CNC milling. The laser is probably several kW for many hours - where's a similar, but less complex, part in a CNC would take minutes - like everything it really depends on the application.
- damoncali 14y agoThe bigger problem is the vast decrease in mechanical properties.
- krschultz 14y agoAlthough you can make most shapes with a CNC machining center, there are definitely optimal shapes and non-optimal shapes. Seemingly simple things like the ratio between inside corner radius and depth of a pocket can drive the cost up. (eg. a small pocket radius forces the machine to use a smaller/weaker cutter, at depths the tool deflects/chatters and becomes less accurate). It's basically the core of design for manufacturability/lean design thought process. 3D printing avoids a lot of those concerns, but for most metal things I still think it's more trouble than it's worth.
- shabble 14y agoI know modern CNC toolpath generators can be pretty complicated beasts, but I'm not sure to what extent they can use the sorts of constraints or tradeoffs you mention to optimise their flow. The optimiser for a deposit-then-machine type workflow sounds even more interesting (and difficult). Is it worth printing those extra structures you're going to need to remove later? Maybe, if it means you can do some finicky machining operations in a different order later...