5 ms·
XAI data center gets air permit to run 15 turbines, but imaging shows 24 on site
- davidguetta 1y ago[flagged]
- pyrale 1y agoI know right, why do people care so much about air pollution? It’s not like it kills anyone, right? What’s smog anyway?
- rbanffy 1y agoBesides that, who would imagine Elon Musk, of all people, would be breaking laws?
- spectre9 1y ago- person who has never in their life checked an aqi map of earth
- msgodel 1y agoI live somewhere that's never had a smog problem so I'm not super familiar with it but do gas turbines actually generate smog? I feel like of all the classes of heat engines they'd produce the fewest particulates. Is this actually a problem out there in the West?
- perihelions 1y agoBurning of methane (natural gas) produces oxides of nitrogen (NOx) (several types), which are a major driver of smog. See, as a starting point, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOx https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NOx While natural gas is cleaner than coal in some obvious ways (i.e., no particulate solids), it has a specific problem with NOx, because of the super high temperatures inside internal-combustion gas turbines. The upside is higher thermodynamic efficiency (highest of any thermal source); the downside is, this.
- msgodel 1y agoMethane has no Nitrogen in it. All of that would have to come from the air. It's famously very very hard to react Nitrogen that way, I'd be surprised if gas turbines produced it in noticeable quantities. EDIT: didn't see your edit until now. Heh it shouldn't be too hard to scrub out if it were really a problem. That seems like a better way to handle it than this weird exemption process that seems to be in place now.
- rini17 1y agoAll diesels produce enough of NOx that catalytic reduction is needed.
- msgodel 1y agoDiesel has a lot of impurities. Methane is just one molecule.
- rini17 1y agoIf it were so easy just better refine the fuel why would Europeans bother to add these converters and adblue injectors? No it's not impurities, but high pressure/temperature combustion. The higher the more efficient and more NOx comes out.
- msgodel 1y agoEurope does all kinds of things, basing your understanding of chemistry around what a state does rather than the other way around is literally insane.
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoHowever, it's not insane to look at what experts put in place and consider that there are reasons why they have done that. Yes, experts can be wrong or are forced to make sub-optimal decisions, but it's worth examining their thinking behind the decisions.
- pyrale 1y agoIt is not a problem if the plant respects regulation and industry standards... which in this particular case doesn’t seem to be a priority.
- jasonjayr 1y agoMany investors use imaging to see how many customers visit a store -- they count the cars in the parking lot at certain times of day.
- davidguetta 1y agothat's actually an interesting point. Like people using sat imaging on steel depot in australian to evaluate the demand
- dotancohen 1y agoI drive an electric car and I've been advocating against carbon based energy sources for decades. I'm the first to take a stance. That said, this piece is an obvious hit piece on Elon Musk. Not only do they mention xAI is Elon's company right at the beginning, they also throw the race card in right after. They claim that the xAI air pollution disproportionately affects black neighbourhoods. I'm no Elon fan, but I can not think of a single human who has done more to reduce dependence on fossil fuels. This is not reporting. This is a hit piece.
- DamonHD 1y agoMany people seem to discount pollution etc that only affects brown-ish people far away that they personally don't know. And guess in which places these kind of stunts are commonly pulled? You wouldn't plonk an illegally fume-belching data centre in a rich white 'hood even if there was plenty of electricity, because political power is the key lever. (I am a 'rich' white western man, FWIW.)
- rbanffy 1y agoYou make a great point - pollution sources are often located on cheap land that's occupied, predominantly, by poor people, which, in most of the world, correlates with non-whites. Would something like Flint have happened in Scarsdale or Los Altos? Of course not.
- dotancohen 1y agoSo this is an economic issue, not a race issue. The two are correlated (everything is correlated to something in a complex system), but to reduce the issue the actual economic factors are to be considered. Not the racial factors. Or would it be fine if xAI were polluting a poor white neighbourhood?
- DamonHD 1y agoWe shouldn't be dumping pollution selectively in poor places at all. But it is not coincidence: there is a lot of systematic racism (and other discrimination) in the world and in the US on top of that, that keeps not-white (and not 'Christian', not het, not male, not English-speaking) people not rich. The variables are not independent. Skin colour is prominent in treating some humans as less than human.
- fuzzbazz 1y agoCan't verify from the low quality photo in the article. This [1] press release from the Southern Environmental Law Center hints to a possible reason - they may be migrating from small to bigger turbines: > Aerial images obtained by SELC revealed 35 turbines at the site in March (...) while the company has removed some smaller-sized turbines, it has recently installed three larger turbines [1] https://www.selc.org/press-release/elon-musks-xai-threatened-with-lawsuit-over-air-pollution-from-memphis-data-center/ https://www.selc.org/press-release/elon-musks-xai-threatened...
- perihelions 1y agoFrom a different perspective: the fact US businesses can assemble massive power plants on demand, in weeks, is quite an illustration of the economic dominance of the country.
- hnthrow90348765 1y ago[flagged]
- smartmic 1y agoIf you mean the financial power to pay for such power plants, then I agree. But the technical capabilities to quickly provide stationary or mobile power plants can be purchased from a few large, international companies; noteworthy suppliers can be found in the USA, Europe and Asia. And they will build it for you in almost any country in the world, as I said, provided you pay accordingly. Of course, the delivery time of turbines is often a bottleneck, but this applies more to the very large ones than the smaller ones that should actually be installed here (and it also applies equally to all manufacturers).
- ben_w 1y ago16.48 MW each: https://www.shelbytnhealth.com/DocumentCenter/View/7174/01156-01PC-070225Permit?bidId= https://www.shelbytnhealth.com/DocumentCenter/View/7174/0115... They're big, by the standard of a domestic source such as a car, but they're not what I'd call "massive" in an economic dominance sense. About the size of a large shipping container, give or take, eyeballing from other photos that tell me which objects the turbines even are: https://www.capacitymedia.com/article/musks-xai-data-centre-allegedly-running-illegal-gas-turbines https://www.capacitymedia.com/article/musks-xai-data-centre-...
- perihelions 1y agoIt's a large power plant (400+ MW and rising), rapidly assembled from small, modular components. That's a remarkable thing from any point of view. The other threads on this topic (powering AI hyperscalers) are usually about nuclear fission, which most of the large players are investing in. Those power plants often take 10+ years to build. One could imagine small reactor modules akin to these 16 MW shipping containers, built in factories and shipped on demand like these, to be assembled into a full power plant in weeks. If someone were to get that business model working, they'd dominate the industry. (Just how big of a premium did xAI pay their vendor, to have all this shipped halfway around the world on a priority schedule?)
- danpalmer 1y agoMusk's playbook is to do the thing that he feels is obviously right, and figure out the consequences later, and because he's enough of a bully and rich enough, the consequences rarely end up being that big a deal. I believe it's ideological, and from that perspective have a hard time disagreeing with his motivations – I disagree with him, but think he's doing what makes sense to achieve his goals which he believes are good for the world. He's done this with SpaceX many times over, bullying the FAA and the local council in Texas. He's done this with Tesla again and again with crash data and even selling products that don't exist to consumers. He's going to keep doing it until there are actual consequences because it's hard to say it's not a good business decision if you never actually have to pay for the issues you cause.
- sReinwald 1y agoYou've nailed the pattern. And the regulatory environment actively enables it through what amounts to a pricing model for violations. When the EPA or county eventually fines xAI for running unpermitted turbines for a year, it'll be what - a few hundred thousand? Maybe low millions if they're feeling particularly spicy? For a company chasing the AI gold rush with Musk's billions behind it, that's not a penalty - it's a rounding error. It's cheaper to violate now and pay later than to wait for permits while competitors build capacity. And unfortunately, this isn't a bug in the regulatory system - it's the feature. When fines are pocket change relative to potential profits, "ask forgiveness not permission" becomes optimal strategy. The only things that actually change behavior are existential threats (criminal charges, shutdown orders) or catastrophic reputational damage - and Musk has proven immune to both. Until penalties scale with company valuations or include mandatory shutdowns, this playbook will keep printing money. Memphis residents get respiratory disease, xAI gets compute capacity, and regulators get a check that wouldn't cover a week of Musk's jet fuel.
- potato3732842 1y agoThe root problem here is that the regulatory environment has been (in bits and pieces over the years) set up to be a checkbox exercise for those on the inside and exclusionary toward new entrants. The rules and process of that side of things are not subject to serious oversight so they can be as exclusionary and rent-seekey as the lobbyists and the bureaucrats want, potentially preventing any new entrants. Musk has, very rightly, realized that the punishment track is subject to far more political and public scrutiny than the approval track and that if you are doing things that people want like building cars and sending rockets into space the scrutiny will prevent them from doing anything to financially cripple your operation. Ironically, this is playbook that's common at the complete opposite end of the economic activity spectrum where there literally isn't the money to comply. People run unlicensed businesses, do un-permitted work, violate minor regulations, etc, etc, all the time. And by the time anyone figures it out, if anyone ever figures it out, it's too late.
- palmfacehn 1y agoThermal imaging, displaying 24 active turbines would have been more relevant. The article contained one image, none of the alleged turbines were highlighted. As a layperson, I'm not sure what I am looking at here.
- cess11 1y agoPerhaps this article clears things up: https://www.selc.org/news/resistance-against-elon-musks-xai-facility-in-south-memphis-gets-stronger/ https://www.selc.org/news/resistance-against-elon-musks-xai-...
- palmfacehn 1y agoThanks. Here's a direct link to the only relevant image. https://www.selc.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Untitled-design-27.png https://www.selc.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Untitled-des...
- jauntywundrkind 1y agoNotable that there are 8 very large/hot heat sources, ~20 much smaller ones. Presumably these are bigger turbines. Consolidating down lots of small generators to bigger ones might the idea here?
- superjan 1y agoThe article talks about pollution but I’d expect them to be very noisy as well. Gas turbines are essentially redesigned aircraft engines.
- metta2uall 1y agoOne can only hope that after their recent falling-out the Trump administration will re-energise the EPA...
- xg15 1y agoI'm still skeptical this falling out is real and not just promo for his party.
- x187463 1y agoThere has been reporting about this for months. I realize I'm just a pleb, but I really don't understand why a company with, essentially, limitless money, won't simply install the emissions reducing hardware and properly permit the turbines. Like a lot of what's going on around Elon/US politics, it seems like a meaningless fight and is only further torching reputations. Just do the obvious right thing and move on.
- MisterTea 1y ago> I realize I'm just a pleb, but I really don't understand why a company with, essentially, limitless money, won't simply install the emissions reducing hardware and properly permit the turbines. Its about exerting power by willfully defying law. "Catch me if you financially can."
- vorpalhex 1y agoRead the article carefully. They are allowed to run N turbines.. but have N+B turbines on the property. They.. aren't breaking their permit. The article never says they are, it just sets things up for you to have that belief. It looks like they are swapping turbines, thus the extras. They may also be hoping to get more approved. These may also be properly emission reducing. The article never says they aren't - it only includes quotes from people saying they don't think they are with no evidence. The news doesn't lie, but it gets as close as it can.
- msdrigg 1y agoSo being permitted to run 15 turbines and the installing and running 24 turbines is not breaking your permit?
- inemesitaffia 1y agoHow many are running? Having isn't running.
- neurostimulant 1y ago
- blitzar 1y agoI am looking at that roof and thinking how much better it would look as one massive solar panel.
- perihelions 1y agoIt'd have to be a solar farm 3 kilometers on each side to meet a 400 megawatt load (with battery storage). If you take the entire block xAI colossus is on—it's 1.2 by 1.6 km—cut down all those trees, raze the elementary school (the one being smogged right now—did anyone notice there was a school right next to it?)—that, times five, is what you'd actually need. https://www.google.com/maps/search/xai+colossus https://www.google.com/maps/search/xai+colossus The end goal is 2,000 megawatts for this datacenter, so multiply that by five again. This CEO founded a solar power company, and a battery-storage company as well—I'm very certain he considered the all-solar option carefully, and rejected it for actual technical reasons; not vibes.
- blitzar 1y ago> all-solar option Who said it needed to be "all solar". Obvious anyone with a brain would have noticed it is dark at night and there would be no power production so "all solar" is litterally impossible.
- tmaly 1y agoThat this is a thing makes me wonder if Elon opened a can of worms with this new political party. He is not making any friends challenging the established parties. They will show no regulatory mercy.
- josefritzishere 1y agoElon has a criminal history of at best ignoring regulations and at worst deliberately defying them. At Tesla he racked up enormous fines for illegal dumping and then a series of on site OSHA vioations. This is just part of the pattern.