7 ms·
I also find these features annoying and useless and wish they would go away. But that's not because LLMs are useless, nor because the public isn't using them (a
by dang 1y ago
I also find these features annoying and useless and wish they would go away. But that's not because LLMs are useless, nor because the public isn't using them (as daishi55 pointed out here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44479578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44479578)
It's because the integrations with existing products are arbitrary and poorly thought through, the same way that software imposed by executive fiat in BigCo offices for trend-chasing reasons has always been.
petekoomen made this point recently in a creative way: AI Horseless Carriages - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43773813 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43773813 - April 2025 (478 comments)
- CuriouslyC 1y agoI am a huge AI supporter, and use it extensively for coding, writing and most of my decision making processes, and I agree with you. The AI features in non-AI-first apps tend to be awkward bolt-ons, poorly thought out and using low quality models to save money. I don't want shitty bolt-ons, I want to be able to give chatgtp/claude/gemini frontier models the ability to access my application data and make api calls for me to remotely drive tools.
- Xss3 1y ago[flagged]
- mpalmer 1y ago[flagged]
- zero_shift 1y agoXss3 is paraphrasing. As CuriouslyC wrote: > "I am a huge AI supporter, and use it extensively for [...] most of my decision making processes"
- mpalmer 1y agoIt's not a paraphrase, it's a misreading. How do you get outsourcing from this? Maybe they're using it to organize their thoughts, explore alternatives. Nowhere do they say they're not still making the decisions themselves.
- Xss3 1y agoNowhere did i say that either. You are misreading. I said decision making process, as did they. Nobody said that they are letting the AI make the decisions.
- mpalmer 1y ago"outsource"
- Xss3 1y ago[flagged]
- mpalmer 1y agoIs it yours? They use it for their decision making process. When you use a pen for your writing processes, are you outsourcing the process of writing to the pen? Or are you using it? When the first thing you say to a stranger is an insult, I wonder, is that a domestically-produced decision? Doesn't seem very high-quality.
- Xss3 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- dang 1y agoCan you please stop posting flamebait comments and crossing into personal attack? Your account has unfortunately been doing this repeatedly, and we're trying for something else here. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- Avamander 1y ago> The AI features in non-AI-first apps tend to be awkward bolt-ons, poorly thought out and using low quality models to save money. The weirdest location I've found the most useful LLM-based feature so far has been Edge with it's automatic tab grouping. It doesn't always pick the best groups and probably uses some really small model, but it's significantly faster and easier than anything that I've had so far. I hope they do bookmarks next and that someone copies the feature and makes it use a local model (like Safari or Firefox, I don't even care).
- i_love_retros 1y agoWas automatic tab grouping missing from your life?
- contextfree 1y agoI always thought there might be a place for some kind of ML in OS file save dialogs, to surface likely destination folders based on context.
- i_love_retros 1y ago> I am a huge AI supporter, and use it extensively for coding, writing and most of my decision making processes If you use it for writing, what is the point of writing in the first place? If you're writing to anyone you even slightly care about they should wipe their arse with it and send it back to you. And if it's writing at work or for work then you're just proving you are an employee they don't need.
- CuriouslyC 1y agoI just wiped my arse with your reply, here it is, enjoy.
- i_love_retros 1y agoDid you have to brainstorm that response with chatgpt?
- dmitrygr 1y ago> and most of my decision making processes Jesus F christ, please tell me you are trolling https://time.com/7295195/ai-chatgpt-google-learning-school/ https://time.com/7295195/ai-chatgpt-google-learning-school/
- southernplaces7 1y ago>and use it extensively for coding, writing and most of my decision making processes, I'm curious, do you find it easier to climb stairs or inclines now that you've tossed your brain in the trash?
- ToucanLoucan 1y ago> It's because the integrations with existing products are arbitrary and poorly thought through, the same way that software imposed by executive fiat in BigCo offices for trend-chasing reasons has always been. It's just rent-seeking. Nobody wants to actually build products for market anymore; it's a long process with a lot of risk behind it, and there's a chance you won't make shit for actual profit. If however you can create a "do anything" product that can be integrated with huge software suites, you can make a LOT of money and take a lot of mind-share without really lifting a finger. That's been my read on the "AI Industry" for a long time. And to be clear, the integration part is the only part they give a shit about. Arguably especially for AI, since operating the product is so expensive compared to the vast majority of startups trying to scale. Serving JPEGs was never nearly as expensive for Instagram as responding to ChatGPT inquiries is for OpenAI, so they have every reason to diminish the number coming their way. Being the hip new tech that every CEO needs to ram into their product, irrespective of it does... well, anything useful, while also being so frustrating or obtuse for users to actually want to use, is arguably an incredibly good needle to thread, if they can manage it. And the best part is, if OpenAI's products do actually do what they say on the tin, there's a good chance many lower rungs of employment will be replaced with their stupid chatbots, again irrespective of whether or not they actually do the job. Businesses run on "good enough." So it's great, if OpenAI fails, we get tons of useless tech injected into software products already creaking under the weight of so much bullhockety, and if they succeed, huge swaths of employees will be let go from entry level jobs, flooding the market, cratering the salary of entire categories of professions, and you'll never be able to get a fucking problem resolved with a startup company again. Not that you probably could anyway but it'll be even more frustrating. And either way, all the people responsible for making all your technology worse every day will continue to get richer.
- Eisenstein 1y agoThis is not an AI problem, this is a problem caused by extremely large piles of money. In the past two decades we have been concentrating money in the hands of people who did little more than be in the right place at the right time with a good idea and a set of technical skills, and then told them that they were geniuses who could fix human problems with technological solutions. At the same time we made it impossible to invest money safely by making the interest rate almost zero, and then continued to pass more and more tax breaks. What did we expect was going to happen? There are only so many problems that can be solved by technology that we actually need solving, or that create real value or bolster human society. We are spinning wheels just to spin them, and have given the reins to the people with not only the means and the intent to unravel society in all the worst ways, but who are also convinced that they are smarter than everyone else because they figured out how to arbitrage the temporal gap between the emergence of a capability and the realization of the damage it creates.
- pera 1y agoAt work we started calling this trend clippification for obvious reasons. In a way this aligns with your comment: The information provided by Clippy was not necessarily useless, nevertheless people disliked it because (i) they didn't ask for help (ii) and even if by any chance they were looking for help, the interaction/navigation was far from ideal. Having all these popups announcing new integrations with AI chatbots showing up while you are just trying to do your work is pretty annoying. It feels like this time we are fighting an army of Clippies.
- 827a 1y agoCouldn’t agree more. There are awesome use-cases for AI, but Microsoft and Google needed to shove AI everywhere they possibly could, so they lost all sense of taste and quality. Google raised the price of Workspace to account for AI features no one wants. Then, they give away access to Gemini CLI for free to personal accounts, but not Workspace accounts. You physically cannot even pay Google to access Veo from a workspace account. Raise subscription prices, don’t deliver more value, bundle everything together so you can’t say no. I canceled a small Workspace org I use for my consulting business after the price hike last year; also migrating away everything we had on GCP. Google would have to pay me to do business with them again.
- skeptrune 1y agoThere's nuance in that the better ways to add AI into these projects make less money and wouldn't deliver on the hype these companies are looking for.
- dwayne_dibley 1y agoBut my real frustration is that with some thought the AI tools shoved in those apps could be useful but they’ve been rushed out and badly implemented.
- fehu22 1y agogoogle is sending pop-up sonyliv open emails suggesting that they will use our data and help us with a. i. which should not be accepted at all the pop-ups even don't disappear this is a real cheating and fraud
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 1y agoA "solution" looking for a problem.