3 ms·
I think you overestimate the extent of Author Services' involvement. It's near nil; there's no back-and-forth; you just send them your article and they send ba
by A_D_E_P_T 1y ago
I think you overestimate the extent of Author Services' involvement. It's near nil; there's no back-and-forth; you just send them your article and they send back a version with fewer grammatical/textual errors and correct formatting for the journal. It's a lot like an LLM, just slower and considerably more expensive.
Also, you severely underestimate the ability of the authors to edit and verify the correctness of their own work. They wrote it in the first place, after all. They know, better than anybody else, what's important to convey.
What's more, this editing step happens before peer review, so if the paper is junk or has glaring errors it'll probably be turned down by most respectable publications. Even the marginal publications won't publish stuff that's really bad.
- leakycap 1y agoYou're pointing out issues with one departmental service provided by one publishing company. I'm pointing out issues with using any LLM. If you don't like Author Services, use someone else. Involve a coauthor. This is not even a remotely hard problem to solve.
- auggierose 1y agoYes, it is not hard at all to solve. Just use an LLM.