7 ms·
CO2 sequestration through accelerated weathering of limestone on ships
- tocs3 1y agoI thought for a moment ht this could be an argument for global trade. as it only reduces the CO2 output it is good but not carbon negative.
- Joel_Mckay 1y agoIn general, green-washing never truly confesses the scale of the problem. The data driven conclusion is exhausting every mine on every landmass would only buy another 5 to 7 years at most. Geoengineering is currently mostly BS idealism. The planet will be fine again in 30 thousand years or so, after the current population of psychotic primates go extinct. It is ultimately a self-correcting problem regardless of what humans collectively choose to do. =3
- milesrout 1y ago[dead]
- rkrisztian 1y ago[flagged]
- Joel_Mckay 1y agoIt is a solar energy retention problem on a global scale, and has a complex physics model with around 14+ different contributing primary causes. Calling it "global warming" just confused people. CO2 is the lesser of green house gases, but again it is the scale that makes it the primary issue. Please see microbial fossil records, fossil fuel radioactive isotope ratio confirmatory evidence, and thousands of years of ice core trapped-gas sampling data. Best of luck, the world needs more comedians. =3 ( Seriously, why down-vote the guys karma if he honestly thinks his theory is true. Please let people discuss things, as we both may learn something new. )
- defrost 1y ago> Seriously, why down-vote the guys karma if he honestly thinks his theory is true Good point, I'm not in favour of downvoting common errors of AGW denial, rather addressing them instead. That said, I suspect some may recognize the account from past examples of doubling down on Milankovitch cycles: eg: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44289415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44289415 and not engaging. Others may simply be tired from decades of addressing solar variation, orbital variation, rising geological heat, urban heat island bias, et al. for the N^N th time.
- rkrisztian 1y agoIt's still what I consider true, and I stated my sources, then you flagged it. The Earth is coming out of an ice age. This time, I properly stated my sources from the start, and you still attack me with your sense of truth. Which may not be the truth. Edit: Mods, please flag this commenter!
- Joel_Mckay 1y agoThe ice core gas samples go back thousands of years, and cover ice ages. The algae fossils taken from core samples of the earths deep ocean sediment go back even further. There is data that reaches back to a pre-human time where the world was indeed very different, and if you go far enough into the past CO2 levels were extremely high. However, the planets environment also looked very different in that period. The reason people know fossil fuels are primarily responsible is the radioactive isotope mix of carbon versions differ from what should normally be seen on the earths surface. If it was a natural process, than this would not have occurred or matched the industrialization trend data in the ice core and recent direct atmospheric data. The world is full of folks that cherry pick data sources to obscure reality. Yet there are scientists that present verifiable facts, and only PR companies seem to think there is some sort of argument over the implications. =3
- rkrisztian 1y ago[dead]
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoI've seen better villain speeches written on bathroom stalls
- Joel_Mckay 1y agoGood and evil don't really apply to inescapable facts. The earth was fine without humans before we arrived, and will likely continue on after our species is gone. Have a great day =3
- energy123 1y agoGeoengineering should probably happen even if we achieved net zero tomorrow. We have already had about 1.4C of warming, which is too much for humans near the equator given how hot it already was. It's either that or migration away from the equator, pick one.
- Joel_Mckay 1y agoIn general, renewable carbon free energy sources are the only practical options, and have even proven economically beneficial in many places. There is a cascade failure point that likely will arrive in a few decades based on our current trajectory. Geoengineering, planting trees, and or carbon credit systems does nearly nothing about long-term carbon cycles driving the issue. In general, migration won't happen much as resource constraints can't relocate nor feed 12 Billion people. Maybe something like "The Silo" fiction will become popular, or Elon and his 1600 passenger (based on current designs) company will make it off planet. lol =3
- comrade1234 1y agoWould have been better if they put a few barrels of aquavit on deck.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- briandw 1y agoNuclear Explosions for Large Scale Carbon Sequestration: https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.06623 https://arxiv.org/abs/2501.06623 seems more promising, I love that there is more research and interest in accelerated weathering
- joegibbs 1y agoCould there be any possible negative effects from an 81 gigaton nuke exploding though? A 100 megaton Tsar Bomba would wipe out all of New York, a thousands times more than that might have some adverse impact.
- colechristensen 1y agoThis is a very shallow analysis, feels like an undergrad wrote that. You just wouldn't build a bomb that big, if it were a uranium bomb you'd need on the order of 100 tons of highly enriched uranium and one of the problems would be "how do I get that much uranium close enough together to even build a bomb". The damn thing would be the size of a small to medium ship. And the guy is talking about burying it under kilometers of seabed. When it went of it would be (not cause, be) a 8+ scale earthquake.... one could go on but you get the point. It's a silly napkin math idea that someone decided to put on arxiv. If you wanted to blow up the seabed with nukes to sequester carbon practically, you could do it, but it would take a lot of them and there would be a lot of effects to the local ocean.
- trhway 1y ago>(iii) ships moving at ~15 knots are water pumps themselves, overcoming the limitation of high energy demand in AWL i think there is a flaw in that logic. Btw, if doing it on ships is that great, why not build(repurpose) large [old] ships/barges by making them solar and/or wind powered and set them just to follow tradewinds and/or to just loiter in the tropical belt, mostly [semi]autonomously.
- moralestapia 1y agoThat's a lot of power, you'd need a lot of solar/wind. "Then just use batt..." Yeah and then you have grid loss, more carbon emissions and a bunch of other issues.
- zmgsabst 1y agoI was curious, so I found random numbers on Google: - a Panmax ship is 8000 sq m (250m long x 32m wide) - using 150w per sq m this is 1.2Mw - a Panmax ship has a 40,000hp engine, which is 30Mw So you’re off by a factor of around 20x using solar power for a Panmax ship.
- trhway 1y agoYes, a solar powered ship would at best do ~3 knots. Which is slow, yet it is practically free. Sail/wind powered would do somewhat better while being more complex/expensive. An autonomous ship/barge though doesn't need speed.
- sandworm101 1y agoNo. 3knots would be moving backwards much of the time. And cargo stuck at sea for an extended period costs money. Air frieght exists for a reason.
- trhway 1y agoI actually meant those ships specifically for AWL discussed in the article and for other similar loitering endeavors, not for cargo.
- rkrisztian 1y ago[dead]
- moralestapia 1y agoGood idea and I do not diminish their creativity, findings and methods. The reason why this and many other CO2 sequestration techniques don't work to solve the carbon pollution problem is that they always measure "gains" on a very narrow context, irl the inputs to the system incur some carbon emissions as well. If you account for (just off the top my head): * Grinding the limestone down to dust * Limestone transport from whenever is sourced to the ships * Extra weight of limestone on the ship (they say 12 TEU for a 10k container ship, small but not insignificant) * Any difference in propulsion efficiency due to this change in the fluid dynamics that has to be compensated by ... burning more fuel (but this one could actually be negligible) You might be emitting much more carbon than the one your system was designed to absorb. You cannot beat the 2nd law of thermodynamics. Smaht[1] people have been trained to quickly and loudly dismiss perpetual motion machines, but also buy the whole "revert carbon emissions" scam which is proven impossible by the exact same principles. Btw, this is an accurate litmus test to see if someone actually understands what's going on or if its just another smaht guy parroting back what xi's been told to. 1: smaht. smart in appearance but actually dumb
- gusgus01 1y agoThis feels like the difference between science and engineering. Although to be fair to you, this paper really feels like somewhere on that spectrum and not fully on the side of science. It's similar to how every battery advancement doesn't always make it to manufacturing. To address the things that you thought of off the top of your head: * Anything done on land will be less carbon intensive as we transition to renewables. * Trains are incredibly efficient at transport, and depending on the quarry might already be established. * Boats are so good at shipping heavy weights because of those hydrodynamics, so as long as some reduced returns are okay (reduced cargo space), there's plenty of space on those cargo ships. The real limiter is stability of steering in canals and depth of ports/canals.
- moralestapia 1y ago>This feels like the difference between science and engineering. I really like that analogy and will adopt it going fwd. Thanks. Indeed, very interesting science, cool paper and much more of this research is definitely needed. This begs a follow up study, perhaps by a different team, where they measure the feasibility of it; including, yes, the points you address.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoIs there any known approach to CO2 sequestration that could reach a scale that would even remotely make a difference for climate change? They either require an enormous amount of energy and/or machinery and/or space.
- deadbabe 1y agoNo. Not even a little bit. And if there was, any sequestration would just be used as an excuse to find ways to conduct more CO2 producing activities.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoIt should be made a crime to mention CO2 sequestration when sane avenues (short of geoengineering) like large scale (night activated) radiatively-cooled floating solar panels, or roads are more likely to help (& even be profitable) However.. climate change is a chiefly a political problem, not a tech problem.
- graeme 1y agoIt is exceedingly likely that any sequestration will take substantially more energy than burning fossils fuels produced. I couldn't explain it properly in physics terms but when you burn fuel you are releasing stored energy and when you sequester carbon you are storing the energy. If we could store energy cheaper than we could use it we'd have a perpetual motion machine, I think? Fairly sure this would be physically impossible. Where this might be wrong is if we found a process to use another energy source (the sun, something that uses the sun, etc) to do it for us, but we haven't go anything that works in that vein either. Trees are actually one of the better options, but to reverse climate change you'd need to reforest the earth AND sequester all the oil we burned. Burning carbon is effectively debt. If we stopped burning carbon right this second, billions would die, as our whole system depends upon it. But if we don't stop burning it, we increase our future problems. This is unpleasant to reckon with so most don't. I don't think it makes the problem intractable, but it gets harder the more we delay. We do need sequestration because simply eliminating all carbon sources wouldn't be enough, we also have to reduce current levels. Also there are some cases where fossil fuel might be the best solution (rocketry?) so we'd need to be able to deal with the waste.
- verisimi 1y agoI don't get it. A solution for co2 is to carry extra stone on a ship for 10 years? It sounds like a bad joke.
- MrBuddyCasino 1y agoI don't understand how people can propose these ridiculous schemes with a straight face. I suspect it is because "climate change" is a good source of grant money right now, so you have to get creative to come up with a new approach.
- black_puppydog 1y agoOn the other hand, if you're in climate science, what are you supposed to do? The science is pretty clear right now, what we lack is political action. Yet when climate scientists stop using the carefully-weighed language of academia to demand actual, effective and efficient action now, they get scolded as activists, emotional, non-objective, etc... This is just to say I can understand that people just want to contribute within their realm of possibilities.
- ricardobeat 1y agoThey propose the equivalent of twelve containers carrying stone, out of ten thousand on the ship - 0,1% extra weight.
- hamaspiker 1y ago[flagged]