4 ms·
I believe there are some studies showing that the risk of doing any jail time, as a binary measure, is the main way jail time deters crime, with length of sente
by _delirium 14y ago
I believe there are some studies showing that the risk of doing any jail time, as a binary measure, is the main way jail time deters crime, with length of sentence not being a particularly effective deterrent. If there's perceived to be a 1% risk of arrest for some crime, then whether the sentence is 6 months or 6 years tends not to matter a lot, because people tend to optimistically assume they won't be caught anyway and block the other possibility out of their mind.
Partly, iirc, because people are emboldened once they've successfully done something a few times and not gotten caught; they start convincing themselves that they've figured out how to beat the system, as opposed to just having gotten lucky so far. Hence I believe one of the most effective ways to deter shoplifting, for example, is just to catch a larger percentage of attempts, even if the punishment is nominal: if someone's caught on one of their first few attempts, many will be deterred from trying further, because getting caught becomes an observed reality rather than just a theoretical possibility that can be rationalized away. Basically, some percentage of people test the boundaries but will stop trying if they get some evidence that the boundaries are really there.
- wtvanhest 14y agoFurther, I think most HN readers when giving the opportunity to make $10,000 cash by stealing a bike would not risk it if their total possible punishment was a misdemeanor and 5 days in jail. I personally want to avoid ever having to step foot in that place for any length of time.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI've spent 24 hours in a holding cell right after high school. It was cold, my seatmates weren't particularly polite, sleeping was an awkward proposition at best. But if I was paid $2k to do it? Sure. Aside from the toilet situation, it's not significantly worse than being on a intercontinental flight. (In fact, I'd rather spend 24 hours in that cell than three hours on a turbulent flight.)
- wtvanhest 14y agoYou were in a holding cell, not jail. 5 days in jail, you would be with everyone else. Not just some guys going through processing. My friends that have done both describe the later to be a completely different experience.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoMy friend who was transferred out of the holding tank into jail actually said it was much nicer once he was processed, and assigned a cell.
- wtvanhest 14y agoI wish I had an extra $10k so I could pay you to get arrested and go to jail for 5 days to see if you would actually agree to it.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI do, too - I think I have five vacation days saved up, and I could use the $10k.
- citricsquid 14y agoI think you're underestimating how a lot of people live and what they value and then people are also underestimating what's bad about jail. If we assume that death and sexual assault are not going to happen in this 5 days I would guess most people would do it and from what I've read it's pretty rare for either of those things to happen in the short term jails, it's prison that's the bigger risk -- and even then apparently sexual assault is way exaggerated in the media. Can you describe what your friends have described happening in jail that makes you so against it? From the AMAs people have done on reddit about jail and prison it seems jail is something anyone with the ability to enjoy their own company can get through with ease, although I guess it could be that your country uses jail and prison as an interchangeable term?