4 ms·
> China's advantage is always communicated as cheap labor but it's also the ability to almost infinitely scale production lines in a short period of time. Ameri
by parineum 1y ago
> China's advantage is always communicated as cheap labor but it's also the ability to almost infinitely scale production lines in a short period of time. America has mostly lost the muscle memory and tooling to do this.
...
>There are incentives that would benefit domestic producers and companies but those take time and don't make good soundbites for politicians.
I heard a very compelling argument (at least to me), that the difference, as you say, isn't the labor. The labor cost difference is something like 5% in the China vs 8% in the US. The difference is ramp up time. If you have a product ready to be built, you can get it to market much faster manufacturing in China than the US.
As an example, the Tesla Gigafactory in Nevada took about 2 years (June 2014-July 2015)[1]
Tesla Gigafactory in China took 168 days to construct (January 2019-October 2019)[1]
The cost of the factory construction, materials and labor, isn't the biggest loss when deciding where to build your factory. The biggest cost is the opportunity cost of not manufacturing your product for 15 months and the potential of losing any first to market advantage if you have competition.
The time to get your product to market, especially if you're a new company with no income operating on investor money, the time spent trying to manufacture in the US can sink your company. The cost difference is much more manageable and, depending of the product, can often times be overcome by the price of shipping.
[1] https://manufacturingdigital.com/digital-factory/timeline-teslas-construction-gigafactories https://manufacturingdigital.com/digital-factory/timeline-te...
- danans 1y ago> The labor cost difference is something like 5% in the China vs 8% in the US. Those percentages don't make sense to me. 5% and 8% of what? Final assembly? Labor costs are also built into all material costs in the supply chain.
- dmurray 1y agoI don't know if you're wrong in general, but your dates for the factory construction show 9 months in China vs 13 months in the US, not the 5 months vs two years you claim.
- usui 1y agoBased off the cited article, it was a typo and it's supposed to be "July 2016", not "July 2015".
- fragmede 1y agoThere's an attitude shift, too. US manufacturing is stuck in the past. If you want to build a widget, you want it finished, welded assembled and painted. you've got to do a bunch of work and take it to four different places before you're done. China's got a one stop shop attitude to get your widget made. https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTjEVB5p2/ https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTjEVB5p2/