4 ms·
The reason for this is that iOS allows an app to opt-out of video AirPlay, but not opt-out of AirPlay audio [1]. HBO has opted out of video AirPlay most likely
by js2 14y ago
The reason for this is that iOS allows an app to opt-out of video AirPlay, but not opt-out of AirPlay audio [1]. HBO has opted out of video AirPlay most likely to satisfy its cable provider partners who provide the vast majority of its income[2].
1. http://developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/AudioVideo/Conceptual/AirPlayGuide/Introduction/Introduction.html http://developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/AudioVi...
2. http://dcurt.is/hbo-forbes-journalism http://dcurt.is/hbo-forbes-journalism
- fredwilson 14y agoaha. thanks for that explanation. makes total sense to me now. but they really shouldn't include the button if they haven't fully implemented the feature
- FixThisPOS 14y ago"Satisfy" meaning "pander to their stupidity instead of forcing them to think things through." Software patents. This shit. Every avenue of consumer product delivery is now pervaded by crippling stupidity. Remember NBC's lies about its Olympics streaming: http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/08/nbcs-olympic-lie.html http://goldmanosi.blogspot.com/2012/08/nbcs-olympic-lie.html
- mikeryan 14y agoThis restriction likely comes from the studios which provide the content (these deals usually contain DRM restrictions on how the content can be distributed), not the cable operators.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoLikely comes from cable companies as well, they don't want you watching television except through their boxes (hence cableCARD never taking off).
- mikeryan 14y agothey don't want you watching television except through their boxes This is entirely untrue. Most cable companies have apps which allow you to stream content via iPad or even Xbox apps. The whole HBO Go thing is part of a cable wide initiative called TV Everywhere which is entirely about letting you watch your TV content on alternative devices as long as you have a cable subscription. Streaming content is actually a win for the cable operators because it offloads a lot of work from their cable infrastructure. They're actually fine with you streaming content via their network's services as long as you're paying your cable bill.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoExcuse my lack of clarity; when I said television I mean the television screen. They are perfectly fine with you watching HBO Go on your iPad but they don't want you watching things on your television except through their cable boxes. Because the cable box contains advertising for other channels you don't currently have and HBO Go does not.
- krallja 14y agoPlease explain the existence of the HBO Go app for XBox 360.
- mikeryan 14y agoI know, but this info isn't correct. The cable operators are fully allowing the networks to stream to "Over-The-Top" boxes gaming consoles and connected tvs. The two requirements are: 1. Full DRM Solution, this mostly means Widevine or PlayReady DRM. This support is lacking on some notable platforms. The most recent Roku devices don't support full DRM the best they provide is encrypted HLS which can fulfill the DRM requirements for some operators but not all. 2. Authenticated Users, Users must be authenticated with their cable operator. This usually means also having the necessary infrastructure for limiting the number of registered devices etc. These present is a fairly complex infrastructure component from the operators and HBO Go has been leading the way in meeting these two requirements. This is why you can stream right now to HBO Go on the Xbox and on Samsung SmartTV connected TV platform. I don't say this as an interested observer, but an active participant I run a services company that actively works with Broadcast Networks on streaming to these platforms. We're literally doing this work right now with large broadcasters. EDIT: I apologize, I edited this to remove some snark.