9 ms·
Effectiveness of trees in reducing temperature, outdoor heat exposure in Vegas
- hervature 1y agoGenuine question for people in the field. My understanding is that the cooling effect of trees is primarily driven by evaporative cooling. That is, the shade effect only really exists because the plant does not shrivel up and die due to storing water. How much more effective are trees vs. big swamp coolers? Even in this article, they admit that daytime cooling of half a degree requires 3 times more water.
- idbehold 1y agoSwamp coolers can't generally provide shade.
- jetru 1y agoI got a great business idea now.
- zamadatix 1y agoThere is something to be said for the parts about shading the surface too though. You're unlikely to cool an entire desert a significant amount with water you bring in but if that's something that happens as part of keeping the actual surfaces in the city cooler during peak heat times on top of the air cooling effects of evaporation then the sum result is greater than the parts in terms of effect. Of course it's Vegas, I wouldn't be surprised if we decided to make the downtown completely indoors so we could just run AC in the streets too. It's not exactly the city of practicality.
- trhway 1y agoThey do outdoor AC in [some places in some] parks in Qatar.
- firesteelrain 1y agoSounds like Qatar. Innovative and expensive.
- saagarjha 1y agoQatar is basically Vegas if it had more money.
- chrisweekly 1y agoUnder the sand on the beach, too!
- sandworm101 1y ago>> the downtown completely indoors so we could just run AC in the streets too. So ... a shopping mall? Many cities do this already, linking various public indoor spaces by walkways/tunnels. Also those cities where the air outside is too cold. A few canadian universities link buildings with tunnels so students can avoid going outside.
- lmz 1y agoAlso: Toronto's PATH - https://www.toronto.ca/explore-enjoy/visitor-toronto/path-torontos-downtown-pedestrian-walkway/ https://www.toronto.ca/explore-enjoy/visitor-toronto/path-to...
- zamadatix 1y agoCooling the streets is nothing like a mall or growing tbe walkway connections, those are much too sensible.
- sneak 1y agoIf you cover the roof in solar, it will generate more than sufficient power to air condition it.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y ago>on top of the air cooling effects of evaporation I think you meant to say *on top of shade* because blocking the sun is the main effect here (the geometry makes more sense too!) Less confusing phrase from abstract which implies that the 0.5deg evaporative cooling is almost a rounding error: during the day, trees provide significant shade by intercepting solar radiation, reducing mean radiant temperature (up to 16 °C)
- bmacho 1y agoduring the day, trees provide significant shade by intercepting solar radiation, reducing mean radiant temperature (up to 16 °C) Sadly they work the opposite way at night, they don't allow SPACE to cool the ground. A textil/plastic plate moved automatically can provide more cold, if that's the goal.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoTo me what seems too good to be possible is the triple combo of shade, radiative cooling, and water harvesting Only ambient sunlight needed here, but they'd have to make the panels horizontal (indeed, curtained at night like you say) somehow: https://www.thebrighterside.news/post/mits-high-tech-hydrogel-window-pulls-clean-drinking-water-from-dry-desert-air/ https://www.thebrighterside.news/post/mits-high-tech-hydroge... Edit I guess the low-maintenance option might be some kind of giant variegated Madagascan succulent
- bobthepanda 1y agoIt really depends on how broad and high the tree canopy is; you don’t need super high tree density to provide a lot of shade. The main benefit over other solutions is that properly selected trees require very little upkeep from humans, unlike anything mechanical or requiring movement. Though I imagine that is less the case in Vegas.
- cyberax 1y agoThere is literally no difference. Water is water, and its specific heat of evaporation doesn't depend on the way it's evaporated.
- cryzinger 1y agoThe increased water usage is tough because we're serious about water reclamation here in Vegas, but you can't reclaim water lost to evaporation, which is why there are policies (and serious fines) around excessive landscape watering. It might not be a worthwhile tradeoff, especially if there are alternate cooling methods that don't involve water loss.
- photonthug 1y agoTrees are great, but ultimately a pretty ridiculous idea if the goal is to create shade, even if you're not worried about water consumption. Avoiding concrete walls or overhangs is smart because you don't want the thermal mass.. but of course you can build these things out of fabric or thin metal. The funny thing is, if you build a wall or canopy to avoid the water consumption plus literally waiting a decade for a tree to get tall.. now you're probably in violation of your HOA height restrictions, etc. Desert cities need to basically drop the idea of conforming to the typical expectations of visitors and newcomers by trying to add greenery. It's better to add shade, dig underground, build wind-catchers[1], salsabils[2]. There's tons of basic things like making sure roof surfaces are more reflective, and more strategic architectural things[3] that can be done to improve things and the techniques have been used forever [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windcatcher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windcatcher [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salsabil_(fountain) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salsabil_(fountain) [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_cooling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_cooling
- cryzinger 1y agoYou know how a lot of classic midcentury modern houses (which you can still find in downtown Vegas!) have those kind of lattice-y decorative walls and panels? Are those actually functional for reducing heat and not just cool-looking?
- bigbacaloa 1y ago[dead]
- 1y ago
- obblekk 1y agoIn the abstract it discusses that most of the effect (16deg Celsius) is from reduced radiative heating and only a few degrees from evaporation. Mostly the benefit is instead of having the concrete under you absorb and emit the sun, the leaves above you do. This dramatically reduces the heat we feel at human height.
- wyldfire 1y ago> the effect (16deg Celsius) Did I read that right? 16°C seems like an enormous effect. Seems like trees would be a small investment to effectively get "outdoor AC-ish"? EDIT: for those of us who are more comfortable with Freedom Units, that's like going from 104°F to 75°F!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- BLKNSLVR 1y agoObligatory response to 'Freedom Units' for those who haven't seen it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYqfVE-fykk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYqfVE-fykk
- manmal 1y agoYes, and cities with lots of trees are way more livable due to this. Planners in our town seem to hate trees with a passion, thank god we‘re moving away from this concrete desert.
- jandrese 1y agoTrees in cities are expensive to maintain, which is why they're often on the chopping block when budgets get tight. This is especially true in places like Las Vegas where there is little natural tree cover due to the climate. You have to have a staff of arborists to keep the trees alive in such a harsh environment.
- 1y ago
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe point of that article is that in many places the evaporative cooling is the main thing but in Vegas the water situation is such that it's more about the shade so the optimal tree is something that gives shade but doesn't need a lot of water. Right where I am sitting now I have an LED strip above my desk and when I have my shirt off (right now) I can very definitely feel the radiant energy when it is on, so if it is really hot I either turn it off or switch it to green because the eye is most sensitive to green light. In fact, as I'm writing this, I just set the backlight on the 55-inch TV I use as a computer monitor down so I'd feel more comfortable.
- sidewndr46 1y agoSo an umbrella?
- PaulHoule 1y agoYeah, but like an umbrella made by something like Drexler's nanotechology.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoHow about something more ... Realistic https://www.thebrighterside.news/post/mits-high-tech-hydrogel-window-pulls-clean-drinking-water-from-dry-desert-air/ https://www.thebrighterside.news/post/mits-high-tech-hydroge...
- bmacho 1y agoThat's the opposite of a tree, which turns drinking water into nothing
- PaulHoule 1y ago"Water harvesting" has been around for a long time. I think I first saw a water harvesting device in the U.S. Army Survival manual in the 1980s. It's an active research area and devices continue to improve.
- metalman 1y agopart of the cooling effect that trees produce is from photosynthesis, the percentage of light converted to plant matter can be as high as 1.5% more will be reflected, and the shaded area will of course,be shaded, and then there is transpiration of water, which varys greatly with species.other effects will be due to the built environment, where a lot of asphalt and concrete could mostly obliterate the real effects of a few trees. from wiki "The average rate of energy captured by global photosynthesis is approximately 130 terawatts, which is about eight times the total power consumption of human civilization" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthesis
- sandworm101 1y agoTrees are also vertical structures. Any vertical structure will absorb some of the light, turning it into heat, then be cooled by rising air. This keeps the heat from getting to the ground, with or without evaporation. In other words, instead of the sidewalk getting hot, something 20+ feet in the air get hot. Hot air rises and the air near the ground stays cooler.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoIt's confusing phrasing. Increasing *evaporative* cooling by 0.5deg requires 3x more water, but shade alone is the *main* mechanism,it doesn't require water. >during the day, trees provide significant shade by intercepting solar radiation, reducing mean radiant temperature (up to 16 °C)
- kkfx 1y agoTrees acts for their little thermal mass and large surface exposed to air, essentially IR radiation from the Sun can't much reach the ground or humans under trees (if they are large and dense enough) and the part of the radiation touching trees get quickly dispersed in the air (climbing the atmosphere). The limited effect is that cities are dense and can't be made as forest so trees can't do nothing for buildings taller them them.
- ninalanyon 1y ago> trees can't do nothing for buildings taller them them. Plant trees on top!
- kkfx 1y agoStill not useful: facades remain exposed and so the largest thermal mass of the building.
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- throwaway41597 1y agoTrees excel at harvesting water. When you water a tree, there is evaporative cooling like an artificial cooler but during the night, the dew falls back on the leaves and the ground where some of it finds its way back to the trees (possibly via an invertebrate first). Also the reflectiveness of leaves helps. Then there's the soil where layers of dead leaves, wood and others accumulate, sequester CO2 and create a sponge. Finally, by virtue of making the region cooler, rain is more likely to fall. Humans can probably engineer something better but the bar is high.
- thimkerbell 1y agoFor reader clarification: accumulating carbon in soil from decaying plant matter still leaves it part of short term carbon cycling, not to be confused with geological-time carbon sequestration. As you know.
- throwaway41597 1y agoNot that simple. When carbon in the soil rises beyond a certain percentage (a tree falls) it'll convert back to CO2 because of the bugs eating it. But if the percentage starts at zero (in a desert) and an ecosystem settles there, the percentage will rise and stay above zero for as long as the ecosystem survives. Basically the plants generate matter as fast as wildlife eats it. This sequestration can be long term if things go well or it can be short term if plants die in large numbers (because of climate change, diseases...).
- gsf_emergency_2 1y ago>Trees excel at harvesting water. Specifically, some kind of giant succulent would be best for arid climes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloidendron_dichotomum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aloidendron_dichotomum
- flakeoil 1y agoBut they probably don't evaporate water and cool as much as other plants and trees.
- antman 1y agoSome of it is converted to chemical energy used for the tree’s growth etc chatgpt says 30-40%
- _cenw 1y agoThat captcha sure reduces the effectiveness of me reading that by 100%.
- defrost 1y agoRelated: Las Vegas is embracing a simple climate solution: More trees (npr.org) 21 days ago | 143 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44231151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44231151 Nights in Las Vegas Are Becoming Dangerously Hot (nytimes.com) 10 months ago | 1 comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41223831 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41223831
- gerdesj 1y agoI've just been presented with a captcha thingie asking me to select all things that can be picked up by a pair of chopsticks described as "the tool in the image" Fuck off. Then that vanished and another even more vapid effort appeared. Fuck off. If you need to piss around with this sort of nonsense, you probably shouldn't be entrusted with a website.
- out-of-ideas 1y agoi clicked the url and saw that first very weird looking captcha - then immediately closed the tab looks like the archivers have trouble with it too; reminds me of the behavior of a virus with all the redirects lol edit: for those with custom filterlists via ubo: - ||iop.org
- defrost 1y agoArchivers work fine for myself: https://archive.md/qUlES https://archive.md/qUlES There's also a direct PDF link https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/2752-5295/ade17d/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/2752-5295/ade17d/... that also prompts for captcha (unless you arrive there via the web version) Looping redirects on archive.XX urls often traces back to the use of Cloudflare DNS resolver .. the archive folk have some beef with Cloudflare over (?) handling privacy (?) and loop redirects on connections that arrive via that path. It's a new captcha type for myself also. Interesting as it requires spatial reasoning and a bridge of understanding between text request and objects in images - although it falls to the usual farm of human captcha solvers.
- out-of-ideas 1y agonice, well i am using quad9; archive.org had 503's too (edit: lol i wonder if it did complete for me but somehow something else caused a loop - i never went to the search prompt afterward)
- petesergeant 1y agohttps://www.radware.com/products/bot-manager/ https://www.radware.com/products/bot-manager/ This seems to be the offending product being used, although the captchas themselves are standard hCaptcha.
- EGreg 1y agoIs it just me, or has anyone also noticed that trees in southern climates closer to the equator (not jungles) have very few leaves and shade as opposed to trees in climates away from the equator (not tundras)? What happens if you import northern US trees, the ones that produce a lot of shade, into southern states? Has this been tried? It is also why there is very little shade in, say, Florida. Only occasional parts of the Martin Grade “scenic” highway look like a regular scene in the north.
- shayway 1y agoFlorida has plenty of shade, though you wouldn't know it considering our city planning. Anything that isn't too dense for humans is pure urban hellscape.
- lantry 1y agoThe short answer is, they would die. The trees are the way they are because they've adapted to their environment. At a high level, trees in hot sunny areas will have smaller leaves because they can get enough sunlight from a smaller surface area, and smaller leaves lose less water. But it is more complicated than that, of course. It's not just "how hot does it get", but also how much water is available, how windy it is, how cold it gets, and a million other environmental factors. That's why there is such a wide variety among the plants on earth. (and yes, it has been tried. Check out the youtube channel "crime pays but botany doesn't")
- jgord 1y agoany group strategy to push back against the overuse of whole-page captchas ? Do we all need to run an AI browser plugin now that auto-fills cloudflare captchas ?
- 6Az4Mj4D 1y agoI saw video last week in India there was similar experiment done in sun the temperature 45 degrees C and 30 step walk under the tree the temperature 36 degrees C. We need more trees as an easy solution
- gumbojuice 1y agoI hope there would be enforced regulation around this kind of thing in cities in India. In residential areas, it's common that your house takes up almost all of your available plot space, and on top of that mostly constructed from concrete. Air temperature is already high (e.g. 36C at my location just now), and radiant heat from sun and concrete can make the felt temperature more like 60C. It's sad that new real-estate layouts continue to be approved, which will only be good for this type of dense concrete hell.
- Raphell 1y agoI don’t think planting trees is only for cooling things down. Sometimes it’s just about helping people feel like they can go outside. In really hot places, even a bit of shade can change your mind about stepping out.
- sneak 1y agoThe best way to produce shade in the Nevada desert is with solar panels. The sky is rarely cloudy and solar just blasts all day every day here. I covered my backyard in Vegas with ground panels and now I charge my EV off of a 100% off grid solar system. The sun provides enough energy in my small yard for 2-3x my driving needs.
- pfdietz 1y agoSolar panels can be engineered to also optimize cooling, by selectively increasing their reflectivity at wavelengths that are neither useful for electricity production nor for radiation of their waste thermal energy. https://web.stanford.edu/group/fan/publication/Li_ACSPhotonics_4_774_2017.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/group/fan/publication/Li_ACSPhotoni... "[...] we design a photonic cooler made of one- dimensional photonic films that can strongly radiate heat through its thermal emission while also significantly reflecting the solar spectrum in the sub-band-gap and ultraviolet regimes. We show that applying this photonic cooler to a solar panel can lower the cell temperature by over 5.7 °C."
- schaefer 1y agoAs a matter of local trivia, today (2025.07.01) we had a wind storm in vegas that downed many trees. :)
- tomcam 1y agoThere is a place in So Cal now called The Aspens South Coast we lived in 30 years ago. It has (had?) an incredibly dense concentration of trees, something I’ve not seen since in that region, which is of course desert. This time of year when you opened the gate that separated the treed interior from the parking lot you felt like the air conditioning had been turned on. We have very fond memories of the place. Its only disadvantage for me was that spring caused my allergies to go crazy. Totally worth it.
- antman 1y agoI was in a heat wave in Andalusia region in Spain and was visiting Medieval Arabic monuments and gardens. They have very interesting designs in terms of shapes, plant and tree selections and wall placements that produced very noticeable temperature differences. To say nothing of the scent of the lemon trees.
- mycall 1y agoThis? https://maps.app.goo.gl/f1q3wMkoagx2aWtC6 https://maps.app.goo.gl/f1q3wMkoagx2aWtC6 I see some trees but it doesn't seem like a dense concentration.
- konsalexee 1y agoThis is a repeating study, seeing this again and again, so not sure about its novelty. In Europe we even assigned our first "Chief Heat Officer", which makes total sense.
- nunodonato 1y agowhat does he do?
- konsalexee 1y ago*She I have no clue
- nunodonato 1y agoI guess she is... hot
- msgodel 1y agoI recently bought some wooded land and unlike most people I know I've been extremely selective cutting down trees on it. It's actually comfortable to be outside there. Even in the summer it's almost completely shaded. I was kind of surprised how extreme it is. I know trees make it harder to work and if you're hiring people they probably can't tolerate it but since I'm doing everything myself I don't have to clear everything and wait for it to grow back.
- noobermin 1y agoI wish more land owners were as conscious as you. Most see the land as a piggy bank and trees are nuances and cost centres.
- msgodel 1y agoI think they all have something they want to do with it and just don't see how to accomplish that with the trees there. I know some people just don't like how trees feel (my mom is like this for example, something about growing up in the midwest I guess) but I think for most people it's just because hired labor and machinery can't fit between them.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- philjw 1y agoThis needing a study is like the discovery in Idiocracy that soil needs to be watered with water, not Brawndo's soft drink. Plant trees, not ACs... North America's greed for energy resources is just bonkers from an outside perspecive.
- dfxm12 1y agoNo. Different types of trees provide different amounts of cover and different types of trees thrive in different climates. Las Vegas does have a particular climate that will make supporting some trees not worth the effort. Vegas also has a particular layout where most of the pedestrians are expected to be. The abstract does lay this out pretty well.
- seemaze 1y agoWhy is Las Vegas, NV referred to as ‘Vegas’, but Los Angeles, CA is not referred to as ‘Angeles’?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jekwoooooe 1y agoBecause it starts with a consonant
- seemaze 1y agoIt just seems unduly informal in the context of technical paper. Not sure why it bugged me.. edit: referencing the HN title, not the paper itself
- achairapart 1y agoNumber of syllables. "Angeles" has 3, and is already too much. So they say L.A. (2 syllables). It's the same reason you call New York in full (not N.Y.), as it's already 2 syllables.
- noobermin 1y agoI've only scanned the abstract but the conclusion seems too weak given the other stated findings. Sure given different metrics (air temp vs radiant heat) may give different stories for different trees, but that wouldn't lead me to conclude it needs to be evaluated on a "case by case basis" more so than the metric depends. That is not the same thing as "case by case basis." They should be more proud of their findings. Why insult it out of the gate?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cgannett 1y agoI think that's why Alabama despite all its flaws doesn't have quite as much projected warming as other southern states: lots of trees.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoDoes it really look different than say MS or georgia or the carolinas though?
- onlypassingthru 1y ago> The selected tree species is Bur Oak, given that it is included in the SNWA Regional Plant (SNWA 2021) list, it is marked as a street tree in the list... Who the hell is planting oaks in Vegas? Oaks are non native and moderately water intensive trees. If this study is based on oaks, it calls into question the validity of the data since this is a tree that absolutely does not belong in the Mojave desert.
- ashoeafoot 1y agooaks are at home in the Levante , syria, turkey Lebanon and spain - all partially desert places now, but oak foerested in the past.
- onlypassingthru 1y agoLas Vegas averages ~4 inches of rain (a little more than 10 cms) per year with less than 2 days of precipitation per month, mostly in very short intense bursts. In June and July, when a tree needs it most because of the ever intensifying heat waves, the rains may not happen at all. Even the desert trees struggle in such an inhospitable environment and can be drought deciduous to conserve water (a notable desert adaptation among many). Without tons of water, an oak doesn't stand a chance.
- matthewfcarlson 1y agoSurprise surprise, vegetation is way better than concrete when it comes to being comfortable in a city
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pvorb 1y agoNot building your city in the desert is also a good idea when it comes to being a comfortable city.
- toast0 1y agoThat's a great idea, but hard for the city of Las Vegas to implement. Clark County doesn't have any ability to build a city not in a desert either. The state of Nevada doesn't have much of anywhere to put a non-desert city either. Very few municipalities are willing to deny new residents, either. It wouldn't be anywhere on my list of viable places to live, but population growth in the Las Vegas metro area has been consistently large since 1910 until recently (only 10% growth from 2010 to 2020). The municipalities should likely invest in livability and comfort where possible.
- davidw 1y agoIt costs less to cool than to heat, by and large. And deserts have a lot of sunshine that can be converted into electricity for cooling...
- pvorb 1y agoBut lack of water will become a huge problem when your city is growing that fast in a heating climate. Edit: And cooling only works inside buildings or cars. Part of a comfortable city is being able to go outside and have a social life outside of a casino.
- AnimalMuppet 1y ago
- b00ty4breakfast 1y agoI'm sure any future endeavor to plant trees in the goddamn desert will have no negative environmental consequences at all. It's not as if the city in the goddamn desert is already in the middle of a regional water crisis as of last year or anything... https://www.knpr.org/show/knprs-state-of-nevada/2024-08-29/what-do-more-water-cuts-in-2025-mean-for-las-vegas-and-nevada https://www.knpr.org/show/knprs-state-of-nevada/2024-08-29/w...
- sorcerer-mar 1y agoAgriculture is the problem, not urban trees
- readthenotes1 1y agoIt's not an either or type situation
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoNo, but it is an 80-20 type situation. 80% of the water use is agricultural.
- Henchman21 1y agoNot people attempting to live in a desert?
- PaulDavisThe1st 1y agoThe earliest human civilizations where all located in deserts. It is not a foreign thing to our species at all. However, large scale commercial agriculture in desert areas without significant ground water - that's a new thing, and it's a problem.
- bigd34lh3r3 1y ago[dead]
- westonplatter0 1y agoI remember seeing similar heat reduction claims in a more tropical, non desert env. https://reasonstobecheerful.world/green-corridors-medellin-colombia-urban-heat/ https://reasonstobecheerful.world/green-corridors-medellin-c...