3 ms·
Ironically, I think you've managed to meet my cynicism about DNS security with something even more reductive. I think it's more true than not that a browser mon
by tptacek 1y ago
Ironically, I think you've managed to meet my cynicism about DNS security with something even more reductive. I think it's more true than not that a browser monopoly reformed the WebPKI. That doesn't mean I think a browser monopoly is a good thing, only that it did one good thing, and losing that good thing would be, uh, bad.
You're accusing me of "throwing my hands up". But you're also writing a comment that suggests maybe it's not a big deal if TLS certificates can get spoofed by state adversaries; how could it be worse than how things are now?
I mean: in a sense, I get it, because I don't think any of this is the high order bit of Internet security, which has a lot more to do with xnu and Android kernel security decisions than with all this protocol ceremony.
As I keep saying, the fact that DNSSEC is essentially a key escrow system run by world governments is just one of my objections, and not the one I personally care most about. What I care most about is spending hundreds of millions of dollars in a forklift upgrade of a core Internet protocol, all to take several steps backwards in Internet security.