4 ms·
Brazil's Supreme Court clears way to hold social media liable for user content
- owebmaster 1y agoIf this is enforced, Meta would see a huge cut in their revenue as a good % of their ads inventory is scam. I don't think they will give up serving them tho.
- wblackfield 1y agoI don't get it. Our supreme court is going to make bad posts go away, making social media a little less of a toilet, and people are talking about ads? Somebody can help me out?
- matheusmoreira 1y ago"Bad posts" as defined by you, right? It's gonna be very funny when they start coming after whatever brand of thought crime you engage in.
- infotainment 1y agoI'd rather just a full blanket ban on social media, but I guess it's something. Social media is basically what cigarettes were in the 50s: everyone uses it, and seemingly no one is aware of how it is almost entirely bad.
- russdill 1y agoAll this does if make things worse. Things like banning the sale of personal information would be a step in the right direction.
- andrekandre 1y ago> Things like banning the sale of personal information would be a step in the right direction. it really seems like its the business model that is the real issue. especially with regards to algorithms favoring "engagement" which leads to promotion of rage-baiting and concern-trolling among many other pathological contents.
- infotainment 1y agoI suspect social media's biggest problems (engagement bait, brainrot, echo chambers, etc), would generally not be fixed even with a ban on sale of personal data.
- 123yawaworht456 1y agoyou're on a social medium right now.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- IAmBroom 1y agoMadge: "You're soaking in it."
- gjvnq 1y agoA big issue here would be defining social media. Are forums social media? What about reddit? What about YouTube? I think what we really need is a ban on algorithmic recommendations that seek to encourage engagement or total time spent on the app.
- infotainment 1y agoI think this is a reasonable take; a good start would be banning all forms of algorithmic "discovery" recommendations, and things like "for you" feeds.
- Spivak 1y agoYes, yes, and yes. You picked basically the three most obvious examples of social media. Is it a site that hosts user generated content and makes that content available to others in any 1-n fashion? Great, you have social media.
- t-writescode 1y agoIs a group chat? Is Discord? What if the Discord invite link is public?
- terribleperson 1y agoMy take would be something like this: Any public or public-ish website, or website with more than x user which presents algorithmically sorted or curated content must make readily available the source feed for their algorithms as well as any other information they use. On any page where algorithmically sorted or curated content is presented, they must fully describe the algorithm used. Ditto anywhere you select an algorithm or navigate to an algorithmically curated or sorted page - it must be described fully in the button or selector, or adjacent to it. If that is impractical for space reasons, it should be described as best as possible with footnotes expanding on the explanation. Furthermore, the explanation, source feed, and additional information should be complete and clear such that someone could reasonably recreate a page or sorting given the algorithm, source feed, and additional info. This would be the test used in court if someone alleged infringement. My hope is that such a law would heavily bias sites towards simple, less manipulative algorithms.
- Vilian 1y agoIt's based on the European one
- IAmBroom 1y agoIronic that you're effectively dragging on a cig as you type that. Metaphorically speaking.
- anitil 1y agoI will be interested in how this plays out. I believe it's Section 230 [0] that allows US platforms to not be held liable. I'd be keen to understand whether this effectively bans social media (and comment sections?) from Brazil, or whether people need to click an I-promise-I'm-not-Brazilian button to access them. [0] Not a lawyer so wikipedia is the best I have - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230
- gjvnq 1y agoBrazilian here. We still don't know if small things like comment sections and personal blogs will be under the new rules as our supreme court hasn't made any explicit exemption but their debates on the topic focused only on big techs. There is a chance an appeal will be filed to seek this kind of clarification. As for buttons "I promisse I'm not Brazilian", that wouldn't really fly if the company in question has a lot of users in Brazil. I suspect that we will see government enforcement only against big techs (especially Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube). I genuinely doubt there will be many lawsuits targeting small websites because there isn't money to be made off them. So any litigation here will probably be restricted to personal revenge cases or something like it. I really wish this had been settled in Congress with more cleat rules and language instead of decided by the courts.
- ameixaseca 1y agoYou are mistaking geographical location with citizenship. Laws from Brazil apply to you while you are in Brazil - even if temporality - regardless of your nationality.
- wblackfield 1y agoRight on the spot, bro (I'm Brazilian and not a lawyer too). I really like the shape it's taking. Somebody is finally going to watching the kids playing.
- mastotoot 1y agoUS Social Media should just cancel service to that territory.
- wblackfield 1y agoAgreed. Yes, please.
- owebmaster 1y agoYes, please. Where do I sign this petition?
- mastotoot 1y agoWhat is the difference in cost to provide the service?
- owebmaster 1y agoare you replying to yourself? Who are you expecting to answer?
- triceratops 1y agoIt would help Brazil a lot.
- paxys 1y agoDon't threaten them with a good time
- tumsfestival 1y agoYou say as if that's a bad thing?
- andrenth 1y ago“Brazilian Supreme Court suddenly deems 11-year-old law unconstitutional after their own corruption is exposed on social media”
- matheusmoreira 1y ago"Fake news", they call it...
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoPreviously: Brazil's Supreme Court makes social media liable for user content https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44256169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44256169
- Frieren 1y agoSocial media is NOT sharing user created content. They are pushing for "engaging content", they have editorial styles, etc. And it makes sense, nobody wants nor can read all posts if they were not curated. But that means that social media companies are just content companies like news papers or TV. And they are responsible of what they publish. Even more important, social media companies should be responsible for the Ads that they show. Scams are too prevalent in social media. Big social media sites profits from the ads, and the users are the ones that pay for it.
- vitorgrs 1y agoMeta seems to be the worst with ads. So many scam ads... Even AI ads, showing a famous person and saying product X is from them, or just straight up asking for money.
- taskforcegemini 1y agothere are a lot of scam ads on youtube as well