3 ms·
I find any claim that superintelligence helps with physics to be a hoot. Dark matter is the most notable contradiction in physics today, where there is a comp
by PaulHoule 1y ago
I find any claim that superintelligence helps with physics to be a hoot.
Dark matter is the most notable contradiction in physics today, where there is a complete mismatch between the physics we see in the lab, in the solar system, and globular clusters and the physics we see at the galactic scale. Contrast that to Newton's unified treatment of gravity on Earth and the Solar System.
There is no lack of darkon candidates or MOND ideas [1] what is lacking is an experiment or observation that can confirm one or the other. Similarly, a 1000x bigger TeraKamiokande or GigaKATRIN could constrain proton decay or put some precision on the neutrino mass but both of these are basically blue-collar problems.
[1] I used to like MOND but the more I've looked at it the more I've adopted the mainstream view of "this dark matter has a galaxy in it" as opposed to "this galaxy has dark matter in it". MOND fever is driven by a revisionist history where dark matter was discovered by Vera Rubin, not Zwicky [2] and that privileges galactic rotation curves (which MOND does great at) over many other kinds of evidence for DM.
[2] ... which I'd love to believe since Rubin did her work at my Uni!
- alganet 1y agoThat's not the point of the article though.
- PaulHoule 1y agoAltman claimed superintelligence would revolutionize physics. This is one of many bullshit statements attributed to Altman, just one I feel qualified to counter. I could say plenty about software dev too.
- alganet 1y agoLots of things were said about AI. I could take this sort of discussion to any subject I want. The article tries to put these personalities into a "master manipulator" figure. It doesn't matter if 99% of the text actually _criticizes_ these personalities. What matters is the takeaway a typical reader would get from reading it. It's in the lines of "they're not tech geniuses, they're manipulators". This takeaway is carefully designed to cater to selected audiences (well, the author claims to be a media trainer, so fair game, I guess). I think the intent is to actually _promote_ these personalities. I know it sounds contradictory, but as I said, it gives them too much credit for "being good manipulators". Which audiences are catered to and how they are expected to react is an exercise I'll leave for the reader. That's a general overview of what this article does. Nothing related to actual claims.
- PaulHoule 1y agoYeah, it's like the way you have to ask leftists "What is your expectation for how many votes this post will move the next election D or R?" with the recognition that their radical posturing might really be something the Koch Organization should fund.
- alganet 1y agoI don't understand your comparison.
- PaulHoule 1y agoThere's a theory that "the meaning of a communication is it's effect". If I make a message that I think is a left-wing message but it causes sufficient right-wing backlash to motivate opponents to oppose me, my message wasn't really a left-wing message but a right-wing message from that viewpoint -- one that benefits my enemies. Isn't that what you're saying here? The author pretty obviously thinks that Altman and company are horrible bullshitters and that's a bad thing, but you seem to think that somebody could come to the conclusion that they are actually really good bullshitters.
- alganet 1y agoMy original comment included a political example, but I removed it before posting precisely to avoid confusion between what I said and simple polarization schemes. It's not about backlash. Media has several ways to deliver a different message, to different audiences, using a single piece. What I mean by "audiences" is much more granular than "against" or "in favor". The article attempts to do that (there are hints of this granularity of target profiles all over it), but it's not very subtle at doing it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]