3 ms·
> it is conducted by researchers who are used to scholarly controversy and having other researchers check their work. Repeating a study with no meaningful cont
by lutusp 14y ago
> it is conducted by researchers who are used to scholarly controversy and having other researchers check their work.
Repeating a study with no meaningful controls ignores the same factors, and doesn't change the outcome -- until a prospective double-blind study is carried out, we don't have anything except a correlation, and a correlation is not a cause-effect relationship.
Here's a perfectly plausible explanation that the research ignores -- individual who choose to smoke pot are under peer pressure to avoid intellectually stimulating activities. The latter factor causes their measured IQ to drop, compared to others who embrace a lifestyle with more intelligence-enhancing activities.
Is that possible -- can an individual improve his IQ by choice of activities? Yes, according to animal studies that do have meaningful controls -- animals that are placed in stimulating environments grow new brain cells:
http://www.pbs.org/saf/1101/segments/1101-2.htm http://www.pbs.org/saf/1101/segments/1101-2.htm
It doesn't matter how many times such drug use studies are conducted or replicated -- if they have the same systematic flaws, repetition doesn't increase their value.
The gold standard for this class of study is a double-blind, retrospective study, and such a study has never been conducted for ethical reasons.
This study is typical "psychological science" -- science in name only.
- lutusp 14y agoCorrection to the above: when I said "double-blind, retrospective study", of course I meant "double-blind, prospective study".