3 ms·
I was surprised to find out that this study finding comes from a long-running longitudinal study http://dunedinstudy.otago.ac.nz/news/dunedin-study-theme-leade
by tokenadult 14y ago
I was surprised to find out that this study finding comes from a long-running longitudinal study
http://dunedinstudy.otago.ac.nz/news/dunedin-study-theme-leaders-win-us1-million-klaus-j-jacobs-research-prize-for-productive-youth-development http://dunedinstudy.otago.ac.nz/news/dunedin-study-theme-lea...
that has produced some other path-breaking research papers on child development. In other words, while this study is not the last word on the subject of the headline here, it is conducted by researchers who are used to scholarly controversy and having other researchers check their work. So I'll be curious to check the underlying journal article (for which I have yet to see a citation in any of the several news reports about this today).
- lutusp 14y ago> it is conducted by researchers who are used to scholarly controversy and having other researchers check their work. Repeating a study with no meaningful controls ignores the same factors, and doesn't change the outcome -- until a prospective double-blind study is carried out, we don't have anything except a correlation, and a correlation is not a cause-effect relationship. Here's a perfectly plausible explanation that the research ignores -- individual who choose to smoke pot are under peer pressure to avoid intellectually stimulating activities. The latter factor causes their measured IQ to drop, compared to others who embrace a lifestyle with more intelligence-enhancing activities. Is that possible -- can an individual improve his IQ by choice of activities? Yes, according to animal studies that do have meaningful controls -- animals that are placed in stimulating environments grow new brain cells: http://www.pbs.org/saf/1101/segments/1101-2.htm http://www.pbs.org/saf/1101/segments/1101-2.htm It doesn't matter how many times such drug use studies are conducted or replicated -- if they have the same systematic flaws, repetition doesn't increase their value. The gold standard for this class of study is a double-blind, retrospective study, and such a study has never been conducted for ethical reasons. This study is typical "psychological science" -- science in name only.
- lutusp 14y agoCorrection to the above: when I said "double-blind, retrospective study", of course I meant "double-blind, prospective study".