4 ms·

Ask HN: Why doesn't HN have notifications for replies?

5 points by dcreater 1y ago

I have no idea when my post/comment has received replies. Seems like a glaring gap in basic functionality?

bradlys 1y ago
I think the lack of notifications is what makes it less likely to turn into a flamewar type of place. You don't know that someone is wrong. I've considered creating an extension for firefox/chrome that added this feature because I'm argumentative.
deleted 1y ago
[deleted]
MatthiasPortzel 1y ago
=> https://www.hnreplies.com/ https://www.hnreplies.com/
max_ 1y ago
Try using hnreplies.com
stego-tech 1y ago
I quite like that it doesn’t. The reputation counter is all the feedback I need in order to know if I need to back off for a bit and do more research (going down) or if I’m making valid points that others find useful (going up). It also means I’m not overwhelmed with more manipulative stimuli (notification indicators) and can engage with HN at my own pace. Honestly, if HN added notifications I’d probably just leave. I don’t need Yet Another Attention Thief in my life.
perihelions 1y ago
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22930391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22930391
pvg 1y ago
You can always hit the 'threads' link in the navbar. Internet forums evolved without this glaring gap in basic functionality and some somehow continue to eke out an existence without it.
- Jeremy1026 1y ago
  Internet forums have had the ability to get email notifications when there was a reply to subscribed posts, username mentions, and private messages for 20+ years.
  - pvg 1y ago
    Some internet forums, lots of others have done without. Either way, the idea you can't have a forum without it isn't quite right given that HN has outlasted most.
mmarian 1y ago
I built https://hackernewsalerts.com https://hackernewsalerts.com just for that!
krapp 1y ago
Hacker News is designed to prefer fewer, higher quality comments over more lower quality comments - signal over noise. To that end it has numerous features intended to discourage engagement over the long term, as the quality of conversation tends to diminish and the chance of flamewars tends to rise over time. Get it, say your piece, and get out. That's how one uses HN.
- dcreater 1y ago
  But arent features like Ask HN and Show HN by their nature geared towards discussion?
brudgers 1y ago
People using Hacker News without notifications for replies suggests notifications for replies is not basic functionality for Hacker News. Other sites often have other requirements. But of course they are not HN. Good luck.

5 points by dcreater 1y ago

I have no idea when my post/comment has received replies. Seems like a glaring gap in basic functionality?

I think the lack of notifications is what makes it less likely to turn into a flamewar type of place. You don't know that someone is wrong. I've considered creating an extension for firefox/chrome that added this feature because I'm argumentative.

deleted 1y ago

[deleted]

MatthiasPortzel 1y ago

=> https://www.hnreplies.com/ https://www.hnreplies.com/

max_ 1y ago

Try using hnreplies.com

stego-tech 1y ago

I quite like that it doesn’t. The reputation counter is all the feedback I need in order to know if I need to back off for a bit and do more research (going down) or if I’m making valid points that others find useful (going up). It also means I’m not overwhelmed with more manipulative stimuli (notification indicators) and can engage with HN at my own pace. Honestly, if HN added notifications I’d probably just leave. I don’t need Yet Another Attention Thief in my life.

perihelions 1y ago

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22930391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22930391

pvg 1y ago

You can always hit the 'threads' link in the navbar. Internet forums evolved without this glaring gap in basic functionality and some somehow continue to eke out an existence without it.

Jeremy1026 1y ago
Internet forums have had the ability to get email notifications when there was a reply to subscribed posts, username mentions, and private messages for 20+ years.
- pvg 1y ago
  Some internet forums, lots of others have done without. Either way, the idea you can't have a forum without it isn't quite right given that HN has outlasted most.

mmarian 1y ago

I built https://hackernewsalerts.com https://hackernewsalerts.com just for that!

krapp 1y ago

Hacker News is designed to prefer fewer, higher quality comments over more lower quality comments - signal over noise. To that end it has numerous features intended to discourage engagement over the long term, as the quality of conversation tends to diminish and the chance of flamewars tends to rise over time. Get it, say your piece, and get out. That's how one uses HN.

dcreater 1y ago
But arent features like Ask HN and Show HN by their nature geared towards discussion?

brudgers 1y ago

People using Hacker News without notifications for replies suggests notifications for replies is not basic functionality for Hacker News. Other sites often have other requirements. But of course they are not HN. Good luck.